Pizzas, pasta dishes, ice cream & sweets are featured at this snug Italian spot with a relaxed vibe.
Hours
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Michael Trecaso’s Italian Restaurant – Ice Cream & Italian Food
Trecaso’s Mary Coyle. Ice Cream + Italian Foods. See the Menu. ;. On the Menu. Pasta · Pizza · Lunch · Ice Cream. CANDY & GIFTS AVAILABLE …
Trecaso’s Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream
Trecaso’s Mary Coyle Fine Italian Cuisine & Ice Cream. 1.6K pengikut. .
Trecaso’s Mary Coyle in Highland Square is up for sale
While the restaurant is now known for its ice cream and Italian dishes, Mary Coyle began in 1937 as a lunch counter at 26 E. Exchange St., where …
Reviews
Jon Kamholtz
My opinion of this place very different then the rest the party I was with. Four others in my company got here. Multiple times a day every year during the founders day weekend in June . They just love it and can’t say enough about it. With that said while I am not an expert on ice cream, myself and my wife eat ice cream every night and frequent ice cream parlors where every we are. We have ate ice cream at just about every stop along the NY state finger lakes ” ice cream trail ” and really enjoy Calhoun’s ice cream in conawango valley and man many more. I have even put the mint chips in the the mint chip ice cream at and ice cream factory in Westfield NY while working there as a temp for a couple days when I was younger. My point is that while I don’t technically know anything about good ice cream I eat a lot of ice cream . So here we go I ordered a hot fudge Sunday with whipped topping and a coffee from an older male with what appeared to be a chef’s hat on? I was told that they don’t have whipped topping . That it was not good for me. Maybe there right I don’t know , but I sure do like it. Is ice cream and hot fudge good for me? They also said we don’t serve coffee the place a few doors up does, you can get it there. Ok maybe they just do one thing and do it well. I ordered my ice cream and walked a few doors up, and found a wonderful artsy like coffee shop that sold their own desert. Luckily my friends were all back at the ice cream place , oh and I had already paid for my ice cream . When I got back and picked up my ice cream I was happy to find that they had put it back in the freezer until I arrived. That was nice of them. Now as far as eating the ice cream goes. It was ok. The first thing I noticed was that strangely it seemed dry? As in not creamy . Idoknow? As I sat in 85 degrees weather it didn’t seem to melt(at all) ? I thought that was strange and maybe I was expecting too much with it being talked up the way it was but when I say it was ok, I mean it was just ok. I have had ice cream that when I ate it I immediately thought……this is great ice cream. This was more of a huh? It was just about then that I noticed the multiple no dogs signs. Some people might like this ,but I enjoy other people’s dogs and I think it would be nice to take the dog for a walk to get ice cream and sit out on the patio. I believe they have been there a long time so it must be good ice cream to some folks, but I will opt for the every day ice cream stand with a kid making minimum wage serving melted ice cream with whipped topping and a hot coffee the next time I’m in Akron Ohio. Or just any other place that has toppings that I want not what they want.
… moreAthena McAfee
Went here based on a recommendation from my nephew. This was the best little retro ice cream/pizza shop that has AWESOME meatball subs. The service was great. The decor was 50-60’s which was fitting and very well maintained. The mocha chip ice cream was out of this world. I will definitely make the drive to come back to try their pizza and a different ice cream flavor. There’s convenient parking right next to the building and outdoor seating.
… moreRosa Nardo
Had a good experience. Checked out the menu outside, ordered inside, and waited outside for our food. We split a cheese pizza, which was really good! Then had the peanut butter banana bowl; it was incredible! First off, it was massive. I would recommend splitting it with someone! It was vanilla ice cream with peanut butter and marshmallow sauce with peanuts and banana. Pure perfection!
… moreKaitlin Shuber
Really enjoyed the icecream but the owner not so much…. very rude and talks down to his customers. Told me I was talking too loud when ordering. Ha
… moreGene Graham
Had ice cream with my Daughter Molly on Father’s day weekend. She bought, so cool…..Love you Molly….Thank you for taking here for some of the best ice cream north of Tennessee.
… moreChelsea Hottenstein
Me and my fiancé‘s first time going here and we will be back. The owner is the sweetest man I’ve meet and you can tell he makes everything with love the banana bowl is amazing and the cheery sundae is fantastic.
… moreMarsha Johnson
Before you go do keep in mind it’s strictly carryout, but they do have for comfortable picnic tables outside where you can eat your ice cream or food or phosphate.
… moreAmber Crossen
Not a family-friendly establishment. Kicked out before we could even order due to my daughter holding her little brother on her back… apparently, because the owners name is on the building he thinks he can speak to guests any kinda way. Oh well, heggys has better chocolate anyway and is a 20 minute drive south! Thank me later 🙂
… moreJustin Chalfant
Pb and j sundae is the best sundae I’ve ever had in my whole life. Hurry and try this now. It’s amazing.
… morePaul
This is the real deal, an old time ice cream parlor with great sundaes. My wife always gets the tin roof sundae with Spanish peanuts. This place is very authentic but be forewarned. Stick to the ice cream and sundaes and sweets. The food is just okay and that’s being generous. Indulge your sweet tooth but eat your main course elsewhere. Definitely worth a trip for the atmosphere and sundaes.
… more