Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
… View more
Relaxed restaurant offering an upscale surf ‘n’ turf menu with steak & lobster, plus harbor views.
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 448 W Lake Dr, Montauk, NY 11954
Phone: (631) 238-5707
Website: http://sammysmtk.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sammy’s: Restaurant in Montauk
LIVE FAST, EAT WELL at a Restaurant in Montauk · Restaurant and Bar in Montauk · 448 West Lake DR · Montauk, NY 11954 · 631-238-5707.
Menu – Montauk – Sammys
Sammyse. Restaurant and Bar. 448 West Lake Dr. Montauk, NY 11954. 631-238-5707. HOURS: Serving Lunch and Dinner Friday through Tuesday.
Sammys Restaurant | Montauk NY – Facebook
Sammys Restaurant, Montauk, New York. 1065 likes · 12 talking about this · 2059 were here. Sammys on the Go, food truck is open daily from 8:15 A.M.to…
Reviews
federico bastiani
Lovely place. Lobster sandwich supreme, eating outside on the bay is lovely. The waiter from Ireland was lovely and kind. The best place I ate in Montauk
… moreS F
We went here on the recommendation of the desk clerk where we were staying, and this was a rare miss! We got the fish and chips and the Lazy Man’s Lobster, and the food was only okay. Atmosphere was also only all right. It had a casual seafood shack vibe, but without the cortesponding prices. Our waitress was nice, though.
… moreMack Vismusic
We are headed to the seafood festival and were reminded of our wonderful experience last May during the annual music festival. The drinks and beer taps are tops, but we were hungry too! Unquestionably, the best fish and chips ever! Need I say more? Obviously, after partaking of the seafood fare at the fest, we will have to revisit Sammy’s on our next trek to Montauk. This place is a standout in the area. Updated August 2023. Place is empty at 530pm for dinner! Table of 6. On porch. The fish and chips were below par. Halibut fresh. Disappointed. Better options from here on in.
… moreScott K
Went there for lunch, we were the only ones there at the time which I should’ve realized that was not a good sign. Sat at the bar was going to order some lunch , there was an older gentleman at the bar. I think it was the owner. There was a beer I didn’t recognize, and I said, could I taste that and the bartender says to me we don’t do taste test sir.,who says that !!! So I ordered one of the beers I recognized so we had our 1 drink and then we left no lunch. Go to Montauk all the time won’t be going back to Sammy’s that’s for sure. Plus the place wasn’t clean !
… moreAmanda Grace Petrocelli McLean
This review is for Sammy’s to Go (the food truck). Amazing place to get reasonably priced delicious takeout breakfast or lunch. And… you can sit on the beach and eat it! I can only speak about the fish tacos (I ordered 2 and they were delicious), and the fried flounder sandwich came on a toasted potato bun with delicious tartar sauce on the side. Perfect breading. Great quick lunch with a view! 🙂
… moreMandilynne F
We stopped at Sammys on the go, their food truck across from Gosman’s Clam bar waterside. There was a long line of locals. The only one working was an older lady on the inside managing it all and super busy. I was very grossed out by her receiving money and then immediately turning around and touching food with her bare hands without washing them. Not so much as even an antibacterial pump. The menu was scarce with high priced items ranging from fish to fries. $21.99 for a “lobster roll” which was more like a lobster or seafood salad, I’m not entirely sure it wasn’t a mix of seafood/imitation seafood, or just shredded lobster. Not my favorite. The mahi tacos were reasonably priced at $4.95 a piece, but came from a freezer. They came in a decent tasting corn tortilla adorned with cabbage, shredded cheddar, pico mix, a lime, and an unidentifiable orange cream sauce. They were okay. The mozzarella cheese sticks were $6.95, your average everyday frozen to fried sticks with pre packaged marinara. Overall I was very unimpressed with their food safety practice and overpriced mediocre average old school fair food truck taste….
… moreSheryl Kleven
Delicious Oktoberfest dinner at Sammy’s tonight. The food never disappoints but the Sauerbraten and Wienerschnitzel were both exceptional. Great Montauk restaurant with great hard working people that make this place one of our local favorites.
… morePaul Forsberg
Absolute – Hands-Down Best Restaurant in
… moreRyan Konrad
Food was not very good and there was a large spot of mold on the bun of my fish sandwich. And the cup of soup is actually half of a cup of soup. I would not recommend this place to anyone.
… moreAndrew
Food was good. Attitude on the blonde girl turned me off and she would be the reason why I take my business elsewhere.
… more