Create your own pie at this surf-inspired pizzeria at Amelia Island, FL with craft beers, hand-tossed dough, and a laid-back atmosphere. Don’t skip out on dessert at Mellow Yellow. With nine refreshing flavors and a wide array of toppings, you can create your own frozen yogurt masterpiece. Pay by weight and indulge in a tasty and customizable experience.
Laid-back pizzeria with create-your-own pies, beer & wine, plus surf-inspired apparel & swimsuits.
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 11 AM–10 PM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 75 Amelia Village Cir, Fernandina Beach, FL 32034
Phone: (904) 491-4115
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Mellow Yellow – Frozen Yogurt Amelia Island – Omni Hotels
Mellow Yellow shares a space with the surf-inspired pizza shop, Natural Slice. Guest Favorites. at Omni Amelia Island Resort. Family Splash Pad …
Mellow Yellow Frozen Yogurt – YouTube
766 views · 1 hour ago NATURAL SLICE PIZZA & MELLOW YELLOW FROZEN YOGURT … with inground heated POOL – 95250 Cook Rd. Fernandina Beach, FL.
Natural Slice Pizza – Omni Amelia Island Resort
A surf-inspired pizza joint and shop, Natural Slice serves only the freshest ingredients on hand-tossed dough. View hours of operation and sample the menu.
Reviews
Joe
I don’t live in Florida, just here for vacation. Always looking to try restaurants that are more localized vs. chain restaurants. My girlfriend and I had a thin crust pepperoni pizza and was not disappointed. It was cooked perfectly and had great flavor. I topped it off with a Cherry Icee for dessert! I will definitely visit when I return in 2024.
… moreHolly Tosi
The employees were arguing behind the counter while making pizzas. They had to of been married. The husband hit the wife on the top of the head by accident with elbow or pan…I was unsure. I just know that she gave him the best go to he** look. They continued to argue about how he does everything wrong. We had to clean off our own table to sit somewhere to eat. They almost gave our pizza to the wrong table because we were number 14 and they were 4? I guess that’s confusing, I dunno. The pizza is good though just not a good atmosphere. Seemed hostile.
… moreLawrence Castillo
The best pizza I had so far. Delicious rip tide pizza sauce Parmesan mozzarella tomatoes pepperoni ham bacon and sausage. Ohh almost forgot salt water crust.
… moreBrittany Hepner
Nice restaurant, the pizza was pizza. However the lobby is full of arcade games and only some of them work and when I brought it up to the employee at the counter I was met by a look of complete confusion as to what to do. Then I was approached by the manager was also inserted money into the game in question and verified that it indeed was not working she says to me “oh it’s an outside vendor, I’ll return your quarter.” Then disappeared. I don’t care about the quarter what I asked her to do was to put an out of order sign on the machine bc as I sat and eat my pizza I watched several ppl come and put money in the broken machine. Shady. Just put the sign up.
… moreShelley Shinabarger
Good pizza! Thin crust, good sauce, lots of toppings. Everything is made to order, even single slices. You can order by the slice, but this is not one of those places where the slices are just sitting there. Also, there are a couple video games, air hockey, in and outdoor dining. There is a shopping area with some clothes, beach shoes, sunglasses, beach purse and bags.
… moreshelly cheek
Pizza was good, but it took 90 minutes to get to us and 1 of the 2 pizzas wasn’t the correct order.
… moreLaLaLand Anesthesia
We have gone to this place multiple times and never an issue. Tonight we waited over an hour for this pizza. As you can see the majority of the toppings are on 2-3 slices.
… moreMichelle Nguyen
Decent pizza at a great price considering their location. We ordered The Point Break pizza which came freshly prepared but a little under cooked. Overall I was just happy to get some cheap, greasy food into my stomach after a long weekend of resort food. Great place to let your kids let out some energy. They have a few arcade machines and a cute surf shop to browse.
… moreZachary Ponder
Definitely surprised to see so many poor reviews on here. We absolutely LOVE this place. Prices are very fair, especially considering how delicious the pizza is. There is never a crowd and the atmosphere is wonderful. While it is not a proper “stay and dine” facility it provides exceptional food in an excellent location for a fair price. I have taken numerous people here and it is always very well received. 100% best pizza in the area in our opinion.
… moreDonald Rull
We made the mistake of stopping by here, as Jacksonville locals, while taking my mother-in-law for a little ride. My spouse was checking out and we were just looking for something quick and close by because the hungry monster was starting to show. I should have known as soon as we turned into the Omni that it wasn’t going to be great. And we weren’t disappointed. The pizza was edible and the quality was like any gas station pizza in any small town across America. I don’t know about the salt breast with salt harvested from the local Atlantic Ocean, but it certainly didn’t add anything besides a few more words to the description. Our pizza had plenty of cheese, but it was almost like the shreds didn’t melt. Another reminder that you’re in a resort are the $5, self-serve, soft drinks. If you can’t leave the resort then this is an inexpensive place to eat and someplace kids would probably enjoy and can remain pretty casual. But if at all possible, find a local place because we’ll never return.
… more