Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria! We are a family-owned and operated pizza shop that offers New York traditions fused with Mexican and Southwestern flavor. We have established a reputation for providing high-quality food, excellent customer service and speedy delivery to customers in the Arcadia area. We can promise satisfaction because all of our dishes are freshly prepared every day with premium ingredients. At My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we are where New York meets the Southwest. We also offer hand-tossed wings in any of our homemade sauces and a wide range of salads and sandwiches. Our fresh ingredients, handmade mozzarella, ‘secret recipe’ dough and pizza sauce make us stand out! Stop in our Arcadia shop today!
Modest nook turning out New York–style pizzas with a Southwestern twist, plus wings & salads.
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | Closed Holiday hours |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3724 E Indian School Rd, Phoenix, AZ 85018
Phone: (602) 975-2026
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
My Slice of The Pie Pizzeria – Arcadia
Welcome to My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria – Arcadia. We are a family-owned and operated business that offers New York traditions fused with Mexican and …
Phoenix Pizza Catering – Delivery & Takeout Available
No matter what your lunch time event is, we can cater it. Here at My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria, we have experience catering lunches and other events for parties …
My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria Arcadia Menu: Phoenix, AZ Pizza …
My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria Arcadia is located at 3724 E Indian School Rd, Phoenix, AZ 85018. What are the hours for My Slice of the Pie Pizzeria Arcadia?
Reviews
Fabian R
I tried the pepperoni pizza, and it was really good! Thin NY style hand tossed crust, pepperoni was super flavorful without being too oily and salty. The guy behind the counter knew what he was doing, much like a car salesman will “butterfly” the car doors for you as display technique, he opened the huge box with a flourish and spun it for my gaze and approval Awesome confidence and showmanship, pizza was crazy delicious as well!
… moreAmanda Hayes
Was so excited to try this place and I am conflicted on the rating. We got the You Got a Carne Asada pizza and it was really good but the meat was light. I definitely enjoy a balance and don’t want it overloaded but I really only tasted the carne once in two slices so it was disappointing since it is not cheap prices. I can see it there but it wasn’t holding up against all the other flavors. The onion was heavy and very present. The sauces too but all delicious, just wish I could have got that carne coming through more. We spent $70 and did not feel it was worth it. My biggest issue is the employees act like you are bothering them by being there. There is NO customer service and barely any engagement period. I truly had to stop myself from matching their attitude. They brought our pizza out for dine in in a box which is a plus so we don’t have to ask for one with leftovers but we had to go ask for plates and wait in line for it. We had three boys with us dying to eat but needing that plate. Overall, get employees that want to be there and are at least friendly and engaging with the customers. Work out the meat ratio because my carne asada pizza shouldn’t be close to vegetarian and this could be a 5 star because the flavors are great.
… moreStephanie Logan
Not sure what happened to this place. Came here 3 years ago and the pizza was fantastic. Now it’s horrible. Hands down worse pizza I’ve had in Arizona. The pastor pizza didn’t have that avo drizzle it used to have. The crust completely ruined it for us. It was very dense and dry. It used to have a nice crisp to it and chewy. It resembled the crust from a tombstone frozen pizza. Not sure if it’s under different owners and they changed the recipe or what.
… moreRobert Villegas
Best pizza in the area in my opinion! The pizza is big and toasty, the salad is on point! The wings are pretty dang good! They have a great combo deal that gets you a good amount off food. They also have some Mexican style puzzas that I’ve heard are recognized and worth the try. Check them out!
… moreKayla Dreska
Creative and unique take on pizza! We loved all the pizzas we tried, but the El Blanco and Al Pastor were exceptional! On top of that, the crust is crunchy, chewy, and so delicious!! Can’t wait to try everything else. Highly recommend if you want to explore a new take on pizza.
… moreDolores Damian
Had the opportunity to try out this little gem.
… moreThe Analytical Sagittarius
Awful place! I’ve had better pizza at Costco!
… moreAmanda
True east coast style pizza and wings. I was hesitant about trying buffalo wings in Arizona but they were just as good as any place in Buffalo. The waitress was very kind, welcoming and grateful for our business.
… moreAZ Scrambler
Super intimate and friendly spot here for some delicious and innovative pizzas and more. Some of the best New York style pizza I’ve had since moving to Arizona. And all of the other off-the-wall creations they have won’t leave you hungry. I really enjoyed their Elote Flatbread. Also, good beer selections to boot, and checkerboards built into their high top tables!
… moreRyan Kelley
Always good. Such a good twist between SW meets NY. Super polite staff and owner. The 12” and wings are good for 2. Decent choice of beers on draft. Or take to go and eat at many beer places around the area. Slices available too
… more