Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Pizza is what we do…and we pride ourselves on staying true to our New York roots! We believe that everyone should experience the culture of an independent business focused on family and community. Not only do we have a passion for pizza and bourbon, we have passion for our customers. Come in and let us prove to you why they call us Goodfellas.
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 11 AM–12 AM Hours might differ |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Friday | 11 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–2 AM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 642 Baxter Ave Suite 102, Louisville, KY 40204
Phone: (502) 398-5704
Website: https://www.goodfellaspizzeria.com/
Menu
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Baxter Ave – Goodfellas Pizzeria – Pizza and Bourbon Bar
Located on the corner of Baxter Avenue and East Broadway in the heart of the Highlands Neighborhood of Louisville, Goodfellas Baxter is our most recent …
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Baxter Ave | Louisville KY – Facebook
Goodfellas Pizzeria – Baxter Ave, Louisville, Kentucky. 2067 likes · 45 talking about this · 1908 were here. New York style pizza accompanied by…
Baxter Ave – Goodfellas Pizzeria – Pizza and Bourbon Bar
Menu for Goodfellas Pizzeria in Louisville, KY. Explore latest menu with photos and reviews.
Last Updates
Reviews
Tina Wood
.First time, The workers were so nice and up beat . They gave me a menu right away and politely told us to sit where ever we would like. The atmosphere was very friendly and as I was reading the menu the manager informed me that they have a Lunch Special.
… moremichelle royall
Had to wait for a bit 20/30 minutes. Not busy. Late lunch, early dinner. Pizza a little soggy. Got the Monday special 12 inch 1/2 off. Pepperoni, mushrooms and onion. Very tasty. Loved the sauce. Giant pepperoni. Fresh mushrooms. Will try again might ask for well done. Pizza slices very random in size. 1/4 of pizza to 1/6. Hard to share.
… moreTeresa Beard
Being from NY I didn’t have high expectations for a pizza shop in Louisville, but I was pleasantly surprised.
… moreKaren Renata
Well I’m not the first but I had to come in. I was going to order from a local pizza place but they closed at 11pm. Someone suggested Goodfellas and it wasn’t just open it was bustling, bright and alive! Not only were they were creating and baking fresh pizzas, there were 25 people in line waiting to but a slice! The facility was clean and looked well maintained. Ordering a whole pie took a while but by the slice was quick and efficient.
… moreDawnsheika Yates
We went on a monday 12-inch pizzas and are half off. And our fanily of 4 all have different tastes so it was perfect.
… moreMiss Ross
The pizza is OK but the bar is amazing. The decorations and decor are top-tier at this location. Parking can be a bit sketchy depending on when you visit and what time of day but I was able to get the Bourbon flight. It was very reasonably price quick service the bartender was super super cool we had a great conversation. It was just a really relaxing environment that makes you want to come back and it wasn’t too crowded. It was just perfect.
… moreTim Jefferson
I’ve tried a lot of pizza in Louisville and all around the country. Goodfellas pizza has got be one of the best. You can order by the slice or have one made just for you. Don’t miss any chance you get to stop in and see the “Made” guys and gals behind the counter.
… moretanya smith
I was really hopeful about a really good pizza. This pizza was a over priced Little Ceasars pizza it was very gummy to chew. And the cheesecake didn’t have any graham crust.
… moreJustin Pries
Bad service. Ordered online, walked in. I was not acknowledged whatsoever for several minutes. The customer should never have to be the one to gain the employee’s attention specially when the employee is not busy and is just chatting away. After several minutes, the employee mumbles at me in which sounded like we’ll be right with you. A few more minutes of blank staring, I have to gain her attention once again and state my pickup order name. No apology and not a single care in the world. On to the food review, the pizza is average at best. Definitely not worth the price and resembles a frozen pizza. Perhaps you’ll experience better service your time around but unless you want to overpay for mediocre pizza, I’d suggest looking elsewhere. Definitely not returning.
… moreTiffany Elery
I enjoyed the pizza quite a bit. I love how open the restaurant is and I like being able to see the staff make the pizzas in front of me. Someone complained about the pizza being cut uneven. Yeah some slices were the size of two and some were the size of one but how many people are going to eat one slice anyways?!? That just saved me time by picking up an oversized slice. I always ask for extra sauce when I get pizza but I wanted to try as is. I got extra sauce to go and the pizza was even better. Nothing like extra sauce. Definitely will be back again. I also liked my chocolate chip
… more