Social Profile: 
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Hours
| Tuesday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Wednesday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Thursday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Friday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Saturday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Sunday | 7 AM–2 PM |
| Monday | 7 AM–2 PM |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Welcome to Bagelman
Bagleman of Garden City is a great place to be for breakfast or lunch offering the freshest bagels, baked goods and the best coffee on long island.
Bagelman Full Menu
Bagleman of Garden City is a great place to be for breakfast or lunch offering the freshest bagels, baked goods and the best coffee on long island.
Bagelman of Garden City NY (@bagelmanofgardencity)
The Original Bagelman A Garden City Institution Since 1988 ☕☕☕ Breakfast All Day, Every Day (516) 746-2881 · Now serving hash browns! Throw em on a …
Reviews
Graydon Briguglio
Fresh bagels, breakfast sandwiches, & coffee. I definitely recommend not toasting the bagels & getting a veggie, scallion, or specialty cream cheese.
… moreGian Sorto
I got a egg everything w cream cheese. the bagel taste fine, a bit salty. but BARELY ANY CREAM CHEESE!! and the workers were all staring at me weird from the moment i walked in.
… moremariana laverde
So I was looking for bagels, and I ended up here! Did not disappoint!! I got an egg everything bagel with cream cheese and bacon. So so good, fresh and crispy! To drink I got a Bagelman Mixer which is their creation of pink lemonade and sweet iced tea! Very very good!
… moreAli Sheikh
We just got bagels from here. Due to our dietary restrictions, we asked the server (older guy) to change his gloves. While changing the new glove fell on the floor. He picked up the one that fell on the floor and started wearing it. My wife then pointed out that it fell on the floor and in disgust he replaced it again. Total disregard despite when the costumer can see him. Never going here again.
… moreGemma Johnson
Nice sandwich, stuff full of fillings. The roast beef was soft and tasty. I wasn’t keen on the macaroni side pot though. Well priced and in a nice location
… moreIn Wonder
Amazing experience ordering mini bagels for a party the day before. They were ready earlier than the original pickup time we were told. So professional and super nice.
… morePaul Mostoff
Great neighborhood bagel/sandwich spot. Delicious food and more importantly great service and management. Will be coming back here often!
… moreMadeleine
The rainbow bagel looked super cool but really didn’t taste great. Good salmon and cream cheese though.
… moreYolo M
AMAZING BAGELS AND KIND STAFF! This was my very first experience trying New York Bagels and BOY IT DID NOT DISAPPOINT! I was very confused at first with the amount of options offered but the cashier was very kind and helpful and explained how i could order my bagel! Everything was so yummy! I will be returning when i am back in garden city!
… moreBill M
My favorite breakfast spot. Sometimes the line gets backed up, but it’s worth the wait.
… more