Social Profile: 
![]()
![]()
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizzeria chain making pies with unusual toppings (wings too), offered at counter or via delivery.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2971 S Chicago Ave, South Milwaukee, WI 53172
Phone: (414) 571-1200
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
South Milwaukee WI Restaurant | Toppers Pizza
Welcome to your local Toppers Pizza! We believe better doesn’t have to cost more. Our dough is made from scratch every day. We use 100% real Wisconsin …
Toppers Pizza: Crave-Worthy Pizza Delivery & Carry-out
Delivery or carry out, late night or right now – Toppers Pizza has you covered. Try our famous Topperstix cheesy bread or one of our specialty pizzas now.
Toppers Pizza | South Milwaukee WI – Facebook
Toppers Pizza · Details · Links · Contact info. . (414) 571-1200. Photos. See all. Posts. Toppers Pizza. 2d · . . Bracket Season just got tastier …
Last Updates
Reviews
Brenda Bruce
I made a mistake while ordering my food tonight (12/23/25). I called and the manager was so nice and got it all straightened out for me. I appreciated her kindness and great customer service!
Thanks again!
… moreThanks again!
Kat Kretschmer
I’ve literally been eating Topper’s Sticks since the original location opened in town when I was in college. I’m not exactly proud of the skill, but I consider myself a legit connoisseur of Sticks, and the South Milwaukee location is one of the few to do them as well (and reliably) as the original store. They also make a better than average thin crust pizza.
… moreJohn Doe
I Ordered a large cheese pizza, received the first cold burnt pizza and called to have it reordered and they sent out a even more burnt cold pizza ruining my family’s New years party. The place is 5 minutes down the road. The pizza barely had any sauce and was harder than cardboard. Then go to return them they would not issue a refund and the Hindu guy making them in the back is not even using gloves I will never order from this franchise ever again. Stay away from the one in South Milwaukee.
… moreJenna Hanizeski
Wow! If I could leave zero stars I would. I’m not normally one to complain. We have ordered from here many times and every time it gets worse and worse. Today took the cake. After waiting 2 hours for our delivery our pizza came ice cold. Our pizza? If you want to call it that was uneven, it looks like one side is thin crust and the other side is hand tossed. The crust on one side looks like it was completely cut off and the rest of it is hard because it was probably sitting around for an hour. The stix were not cut down the middle and there was no parchment paper or liner underneath to keep the cheese from sticking to the cardboard. Waste of $30 cuz I don’t even want to eat it now lol sad day cuz i don’t get to choose which location delivers to us. No more toppers for us!
… moreFaiqa
This is the second time I order from this site and both times I’ve received burned pizza. One of the pizzas was messed up; not sure how this happened. Will not be going back to this location. The only good experience was the delivery service.
… moreGoogle User
They don’t use gloves when making pizza be careful. Also zero for customer service they barely speak English so you have to keep repeating yourself, they’re very rude people, I won’t be back. Rip toppers south milwaukee
… moreShaun Edwards
Stopped in this little pizza place during my Wisconsin visit. My buddy who I was visiting said let’s go here since it was after 1:00 AM local time and it seemed to be the only place open the pizza was super tasty. Service was fast. I’d be coming back during my next visit here. The location is conveniently located in a large strip mall and easy to see the big sign from the street.
… moreForevver Tracy
Do NOT EAT HERE!!! It is POLICY for them to NOT HAVE TO WEAR GLOVES! Claiming that the heat of the oven would kill any bacteria!! ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING!!! They would not refund everything ! They kept my delivery fee! The girl named Sophia said that I was lucky i talked to her, because she asked her higher ups and they told her not to do the refund at all!!!!! She said “ we are a franchise! “. WORSTTTTT NIGHTMARE PLACE YOU CAN GO TO !! SAVEEEEEE YOUR MONEYYYYYYYY!!!!!!!!!
… moredekuboi donut
Amazing food, extremely short wait times, and some of the best customer service I’ve ever had. What more could I ask for?
… moreAmy Siettmann
Pizza arrived almost an hour late and cold. I tried to call the store and was just placed on hold and no one ever answered.
… more