Tony’s Pizza

  3.3 – 8 reviews  $$ • Pizza restaurant

Tony's Pizza 25443

Address and Contact Information

Address: 126 E German St, Shepherdstown, WV 25443

Phone: (304) 876-2720

Website:

Related Web Results

Tony’s Pizza & Stonewall’s Pub – Shepherdstown – MenuPix

View the menu for Tony’s Pizza & Stonewall’s Pub and restaurants in Shepherdstown, WV. See restaurant menus, reviews, ratings, phone number, address, hours, …

Tony’s Pizza (Now Closed) – 6 tips – Foursquare

See 11 photos and 6 tips from 224 visitors to Tony’s Pizza. … Category icon. 126 E. German St., Shepherdstown, WV 25443, United States.

Tony’s Pizza & Stonewall’s Pub – Shepherdstown – MapQuest

Tony’s Pizza & Stonewall’s Pub. 126 E German St Shepherdstown WV 25443. (304) 876-2720. Claim …

Reviews

Chad Lowers
I stopped in on a Saturday evening around 7pm while passing through the area. There was one person working tables, one person in the kitchen, and nearly every table filled. I didn’t see any other bars/restaurants that looked like a quick place to grab some food so I decided to sit at the bar and place an order. The waitress/bartender was working very hard, bussing tables by herself, taking the orders, dropping off the food, refilling drinks, processing payments, and serving the bar. I waited about an hour for my food order that still hadn’t come up, so I decided to leave as my hunger and impatience got the best of me. Left a tip for the hard working bar tender, but there was no excuse for the under-staffing and hour long wait for a sandwich. Skip it and just go to Sheetz.
… more
Derrick Smith
DO NOT GO HERE……the bartenders get drunk and start fights with anyone that asks for their check to leave, then inquires why an unknown signature is on the tab when they get it. On top of which condemning us for not leaving a tip on the check that we had not yet closed out!!……we simply asked about the situation when we were spit on by the bartender, put in a choke hold by two from behind, beaten from the back by others and physically assaulted inside and outside the establishment by nearly every staff member. There was no asking us to leave (which we already were), no respect, and of course no accountability. When the police came they were no help at all; cussing us, provoking us to try and continue the beating and haul us to jail for assaulting a police officer (btw it obviously doesn’t take much more than getting off a meth addiction to become one in Shepherdstown)…..this establishment and the police dept. are obviously in bed which each other.
… more
Eidua Sregor
My opinion of Tony’s is that it is a miserable little place that caters exclusively to certain types of college kids that just don’t care how filthy a place is as long as they are served alcohol. Also, don’t leave your credit card to start a tab, once you do and have any alcohol, your in jeopardy of paying for all the booze that the bartenders are drinking. If you choose to leave your cc for a tab and you notice something perculiar as you check out, just suck it up and pay the tab. Any attempt at getting an explanation will result in you getting rudely excorted out of the building for starting trouble. If you put up any resistance, the cops will be waiting outside to make some more money off of you, literally. They are uninterested in what you have to say, they have either pre-determined that anybody that is bounced out of the facility is a troublemaker or the cops are related to the owners. Now that I think about it, a lot of them looked like they resembled each other. Hmmmm.
… more
Kaitlyn Poffenberger
Not sure why this place is only a 2.6 rating. We stopped here tonight after church. OUTSTANDING service and the BEST pizza and subs we have had in awhile. The atmosphere was even pleasing. We will definitely be making this a regular stop from now on. Thank you for wonderful experience!
… more
Tony Fogle
Tony’s cheese steak was really good, real steak. Sweet tea was just right and the waitress was very friendly
… more
Heather Mitchell
The WORST!!!!!!
… more
Gene and Renner
EXCELLENT FOOD & SERVICE!! Will definitely return.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment