Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Breakfast ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: W2360 Kiel Rd, New Holstein, WI 53061
Phone: (920) 894-1776
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe – Fond du Lac
The Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe is famous for their Amish treats, from cookies and donuts, to pies, jellies, and jams. Amish candy is seasonal.
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe, [W1939 – New Holstein – MapQuest
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe is a quaint bakery nestled in the heart of New Holstein, WI. Specializing in freshly baked goods, this charming shop offers a variety …
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe – Reviews, Photos & Phone Number …
Toasty Oven Bake Shoppe stands as a delightful gem in the heart of New Holstein, WI, renowned for its exceptional array of baked goods crafted with care and …
Reviews
Nicole Laumann
This is a cute little shop, the drive makes gor a nice scenery as well. The pies,turns over are the BEST. We got a coffee cake that im so excited to try. And they even have treats for our fur baby that she LOVES.
… morerobert Wilson
Very cute little Amish Bakery. Pies, doughnuts, cookies, bread, turnovers, noodles, angel food cake. So good and all fresh made. Cash or check only. No credit cards.
… moreAshley Flores
Drove over an hour today to visit the bakery, had heard many good things. Lady working was not friendly at all we said hello she just glared at us, didn’t say a work. Now the bakery it’s were good but service horrible. She heard my daughter talking about the horse and wanting to see it. I said we can see it from
The car, the lady ran up to
The horse and moved it to the other side of the house so my 4 year old couldn’t see it. Then can back and proceeded to watch us through the window giving dirty looks. It was not very welcoming at all, I will never go back.
… moreThe car, the lady ran up to
The horse and moved it to the other side of the house so my 4 year old couldn’t see it. Then can back and proceeded to watch us through the window giving dirty looks. It was not very welcoming at all, I will never go back.
Lucas
Best apple pie over ! Needs to be opened every day Amish !!!! You can make more money open on week days !
… moreJeff Hibbs
I am very grateful for knowing the family of this bakery. They work very hard to produce a wide variety of baked goods. The ingredients they use are either made from scratch at the bakery or are of a more all natural ingredient that proves to be more on the healthier side, compared to thise found in store bought baked goods.
… moreNicole Braun
Great selection of baked and canned goods. I love their turnovers and candy.
… moreNikkole Gonzalez
This bakery is amazing. Huge family favorite. Prices are reasonable. Very friendly. Helpful. Everything tastes amazing. From donuts to turnovers to bread and cookies its all delicious. They do open the 1st week in april cant wait.
… moreLiz Grunert
I’m just in love with the sugar cookies! They take me back to being a little kid and baking Christmas cookies with my grandma. Everything I’ve had from here is delicious, and very well priced.
… moreSarah Zoschke
Today I went to the farmers market and purchased freshly baked Italian herb bread homemade dog biscuits and fresh and crunchy peanut butter cookies. These are by far the best peanut butter cookies I have ever had! They had some amazing looking pies that I did not have a chance to buy but I am hoping to next weekend. I would highly recommend
… moreSusan Spielvogel
Our granddaughter had their turnovers at her wedding instead of cake or cupcakes. The turnovers were awesome and we also took 3 home. We will be visiting their store this Friday.
… more