Austin Mitchell
We have been here twice. Both time the meat was excellent! The portions are big and flavorful. The brisket is perfect! The only downfall are the sides. I would give the sides 2 out of 5 stars. Each time the sides were under cooked and bland. If they put as much effort into the sides as they do their meat it would be 5 out of 5! Overall this a good barbeque joint. Come for the meat and you won’t be disappointed.
… moreTucan Sam
First time visit yesterday, 5:30pm Sunday. Got 1/2 lb brisket, 1 hot link, and a side of sweet potato tater tots. Ordered to go. Got home and was very impressed with the brisket!! Moist, smokey, no visible huge chunks of fat. Hot link was great too. Really wanted potato salad as a side but they didnt have it; sweet potato tots were ok but dont expect same crispy texture as good regular potato tots. In our to-go bag the food was all packed well in clam shells and they added a nice helping of traditional BBQ condiments of sliced onions, pickles and some sliced jalapenos, and 2 small containers of house BBQ sauce which had great flavor. Cost was just over $17, and we consider it a bargain for that quality brisket, and I think they went well over 1/2 pound.
Interior was very cool…country bar theme, wood plank walls/floor, galvanized steel here & there, full bar with cheap beer and apparently good booze selection. We will definitely come back to dine in. Oh- very nice and welcoming ladies working there! This biz is only about 7 months old…if you live in the area, GO!!! We need places like this to survive & thrive.
… moreKen Sutley (Kentley)
This place has won our hearts for the best BBQ in the four states area. The Ribs are wet, tender and the flavor has to be an old family recipe. The portions are well above average and the service is johnny-on-the-spot and friendly. Price? It’s fair for what you get considering all aspects of the dinning experience. Highly recommended.
… moreTracy Davidson
First time trying Rusty Anchor. I was a bit skeptical after reading a few bad reviews. I told myself to just walk out if I got a bad reception, however to my surprise, the waitresses were very pleasant and very attentive in waiting on us and coming back to check up on us numerous times. My husband and I both had brisket, fries, onion rings, and bbq beans. I had meal he had basket. The brisket was super delicious! Sauce was perfect! Beans, oh my! Fantastic! Fries and everything else was excellent. Will definitely be back! Super clean restaurant and great atmosphere!
… moreEllen Knight
What a fun, hidden treasure! We were invited to meet friends at the Rusty Anchor and we’re so glad for the invite because we had no idea it even existed. The service and food were wonderful and in addition, we could all talk and enjoy each other without the noise of most restaurants. Try the Rusty Anchor. You’ll enjoy it!
… moreAmber Whitmire
I had the brisket, bologna, and homemade baked beans, and everything was absolutely delicious! The brisket was tender and smoky, the bologna had incredible flavor, and the beans tasted just like something made from scratch. The restaurant was clean, open, and airy with an amazing atmosphere — and the wait staff was just as impressive! Friendly, attentive, and genuinely welcoming. It’s the kind of place you want to come back to again and again. Highly recommend!
… moreJaimie Perkins
We ordered the 2 meat dinner, and WOW! is there such a thing as TOO much food! Sorry, no picture because I tore into my tray as soon as it was set down. Definitely the Best BBQ in Oklahoma! Thats coming from a KC girl, and just yhink its just across the lake from me❤️
… moreMike Brightly
Beyond great. Excellent staff. Amazing brisket chili and hot links. Very affordable and will definitely be back. Thank you very much
… moreCarolyn Richards
We normally go to jls bbq but I told my son I’m sick of that food so I googled restaurants in pryor n this new one popped up . I checked out menu n told my son to go there . He went n picked up food for us , got it home , i opened mine and the house bbq sauce i put on the meats I ordered , the first bite of bbq i could taste the smoky taste n it was love at first bite . I got smoked sausage n brisket n I wanted lil smokes but they were out . The brisket was mmmmmmh soooo tender . I ordered onion rings n they were big good ones n I ordered okra !! It was goid n I got a yeast roll !! Hands down , our new resturant will be the rusty anchor , or los cocos, or pig n out !! My new go to places to eat will be in salinqa n not pryor !! Rusty anchor : ahhh ya better expand ciz ur gonna grow bigger !!
… moreCR 3
So glad we tried this place for dinner! The pulled pork and ribs were spot on. And their beans were outstanding. The sweet potato tots were yummy and be sure to save room for dessert. Spotless inside, friendly service and big portions. Enjoyed!
… more