Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Branch of a local bar chain serving American comfort food & signature battered fish ’n’ chips.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3220 Tremont Rd, Upper Arlington, OH 43221
Phone: (614) 486-6976
Website: http://www.oldbagofnails.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Upper Arlington, OH – Old Bag of Nails
our pub in A twee little columbus neighborhood. 3220 Tremont Road, Upper Arlington, OH 43221. PHONE. (614) 486-6976. HOURS. MON – THURS 11AM — 9PM.
Old Bag of Nails
We have nearly twenty restaurants across Ohio and Michigan, serving up the best fish & chips and pub fare in your town.
Old Bag of Nails Upper Arlington – Facebook
Old Bag of Nails Upper Arlington. The Old Bag of Nails location in Upper Arlington, Ohio. We are known for our British Style Fish and C. Pub · $$. . Follow …
Reviews
Ed Wetzel
Everything was passable, but not great. We had a nice waitress and that was the highlight of our visit. The crab cakes were authentic, but had heavy filler and were oddly seasoned. The fish sandwich was not the same as I remember from years ago. We tried the specialty Old Fashioneds and again, they missed the mark. Surprisingly, there was a short list of available drafts. It is unlikely we’ll go back.
… moreAmber
I ordered takeout from here and was disappointed with my order. I asked for a burger cooked medium-well, but it arrived medium-rare. It was a simple request, and they couldn’t get it right. Since it was a buy-one-get-one deal, I ended up with two burgers that were not edible. Please do better.
… moreAmanda Daily
First time eating here. We stopped after a cheer competition. Service was great – locals at the bar were friendly. The French onion soup & chicken Philly were the best I’ve ever had!! Visited 11/9/25
… moreJames Goodman
We’ve ordered the fish tacos numerous times on site before. This time we order takeout. Some fish tacos had one piece of fish while others had two as usual. The O ring used to be the best in town. Nolonger. All batter, no onion. The sweet potato fries were soft, no flavor. Very disappointing after spending nearly $40 for two containers of greasy food. The food has taken a dive since the move from Tremont center. Should have known, Saturday evening only 4 people in the place. Used to love this place.
… moreElizabeth Fequiere
They had really great food but subpar service. They were also out of coconut shrimp but the food was overall pretty great.
… moreUmeko V
We ordered for a mid-day pickup. The fish and chips and fish and shrimp were delicious! However, the chocolate cake was not worth the price. The cake’s taste, its hard/dry texture, and the bloom on the chocolate chips make me think it was pre-cut/boxed up before being stored in the fridge for a while.
… moreMr. Branham
Fish and chips are always the best in Central Ohio. You really can’t go wrong. Going there getting fish and chips. On the side note it’s also shareable. They give you enough where you can share and still leave not hungry. I also enjoy the fried mushrooms as well
… moreJenna Richardson
Food quality was poor, so over cooked and dry. We received 4 onion rings for over $5.00 see photo. I was shocked. I understand there’s an inflation on food prices but that is the most ridiculous thing I’ve ever seen.
… moreLinda Evans
I ordered you lobster rolls for my birthday dinner. It was delivery because I can’t leave home. The rolls were burnt how any chef could let that leave the kitchen is way beyond me. I am so disappointed and heartbroken my birthday was not up to the usual standards of your restaurant. So disappointed
… moreVictoria Austin
We did a to-go order. I got chimichurri flat iron steak with grilled zucchini as the side, plus we got some fried pickles. The fried pickles and ranch were spectacular. I can see myself going back just for the pickles. The steak, however, was a bit disappointing as I asked for medium and got what looked more like medium rare. The garlic bread and zucchini were good though.
… more