Address and Contact Information
Address: 5521 NY-28, Eagle Bay, NY 13331
Phone: (315) 390-4101
Website: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100093997067091
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: toasttab.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Eagle Bay House – Facebook
Cover photo of The Eagle Bay House. The Eagle Bay House. Pasta & Steak House … See more. Restaurant · Eagle Bay, NY · The Eagle Bay House · $$ · (315) …
The Eagle Bay House – Inlet
The Eagle Bay House. Pasta & steak house – Upscale casual dining for everyone. 2026 Paid member of the Inlet Area Business Association …
The Eagle Bay House – Facebook
The Eagle Bay House, Eagle Bay. 3199 likes · 9 talking about this · 272 were here. Pasta & Steak House Upscale casual dining for everyone.
Reviews
Dawn Kurtz
What an absolutely delicious meal and wonderful service. My husband and I celebrated our 18th anniversary together here and it did not disappoint. The food was made with pride! He ordered the Prime Rib, and I had the kale salad (incredible!) and the Delmonico steak. He has high standards for prime rib after growing up going to the Big Moose and he was very pleased with the Eagle Bay prime rib which is saying a lot!!! He also got the best old fashioned he ever had. I had a lemon meringue martini that was fantastic. The desserts are HOMEMADE!! The apple berry crumble we shared was AMAZING!! I never want to eat this much again in one sitting but every single bite was fabulous! Our server was so dear too! The perfect amount of checking in, friendliness and privacy! Eagle Bay House gets a 10/10 from us!
… moreKIM S
Went for valentines day. Out of prime rib. Food was good. Very expensive. Once you could get a cocktail they were good. Loud.
… moreAndrew Large
Very friendly, attentive staff and great food. Everything was well presented and delicious (even the veggies ). Don’t miss the mashed potatoes. Small, but excellent dessert menu. We had a reservation and the table was waiting for us when we arrived. There didn’t seem to be too much of a wait, but it is a small dining room, so I’m guessing peak season gets pretty busy.
… morehwbout
The food and service were great. Walked in and were immediately seated. Had made a reservation online the day before. The menu is fantastic. So many choices but not to many which can be overwhelming. We used a gift certificate that I had won at The Raquette Lake Auction. (Thank you for your generous donation) we will definitely be back to enjoy another meal here. It was delicious.
… moreJason Collier
This is as good as it gets for the best dining experience in the Inlet/Eagle Bay area. I love pizza and wings as much as anyone up here, but if you want to elevate your cuisine vibe a bit this is the place to do it. It’s not cheap but it’s really tasty and well-executed. The lamb lollipops were cooked perfectly and just exactly what was expected. The fish fry, while an Adirondack Friday night staple, still had a uniqueness to it that put it a level above. The haddock was very fresh and the breading unique. If you want to get out of the regular ADK zone of food, try the eggplant too. An exemplary dish in both presentation and flavor. Will definitely make this a regular dining event each year we visit.
… moreNoah Large
The food here is great, the menu is small but mighty. There is a good selection of appetizers, salads, pastas, and different meats. The place serves well sized dishes with a nice variety on each plate. However the big standout to me was the mashed potatoes, those were the best I have ever had. The other vegetables also had great flavors. Overall this place is a cozy place to go and enjoy some quality food.
… moreCyndee Socci
I flipped over one piece of the Bistro Chicken just to see maybe how this magic was done. The most delicious chicken I’ve ever had! Pan sauce was so savory and complex and utterly delicious, wow. Everything about this dish was so well executed- the staff here is awesome too.
… moreJudi Kiefer
Trying to find a good dinner as tourists over Labor Day weekend was not easy. Someone mentioned The Eagle Bay House to us and were glad they did. Atmosphere was very pleasant and the food was delicious! My husband said the filet was so tender, the best he has had in a long time. My shrimp primavera was awesome. We will certainly return.
… moreJeffrey Baran
Everything was delicious. Wings as an appetizer are a must. We got both flavors and can’t decide which I liked more. Wedge salad was excellent. Delmonico Steak was cooked to perfection. All staff was very friendly especially our server. We will definitely be back.
… moreAlex
Went with a party of 5 and everything we ordered was excellent. The staff was attentive and welcoming. Fantastic food in Eagle Bay!
… more