Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Our focus is creating handcrafted and creative comfort food to please even the pickiest of eaters. For us, the food is our passion but it’s about more than that – we’re part of our community and aim to create an entire experience! Join us for one of our unique specialty pizzas, a cup of homemade soup or just pop on over for Happy Hour!
Casual American & Italian bar & grill known for imaginative pizza, plus sandwiches & craft beer.
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
Order and Reservations
Reservations: sugarriverpizza.comopentable.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sugar River Pizza Company | United States
608-497-1800. 957 Liberty Dr. Verona, WI 53593. Tuesday – Thursday: 11am – 9pm. Friday – Saturday: 11am – 10pm. Sunday: 11am – 9pm …
Food Menu – Verona | sugar-river-pizza
New Glarus · Sun Prairie · Verona · General Inquiry · Print Me · Order Online · Facebook Classic; Instagram Social Icon. © 2015 by Sugar River Pizza Company …
Sugar River Pizza Company
Fresh Original Pizza and Italian Comfort Food in New Glarus and Verona.
Reviews
Tom M
Place was very busy which we know why now. So we opted to sit on the patio to avoid the long wait. Very sunny and very warm which rightfully so; it’s outside. Might I suggest a sunscreen at least so you can at least enjoy your time outside even if it is sunny and warm. We did end up taking it to go. Our waitress was amazing! On the other hand the pizza was unbelievably great!! I strongly suggest chicken bacon ranch(right) buffalo chicken(one with ranch on it) sausage, pepperoni with ranch sauce! Absolutely delicious!!!!!!
… moreJackie R
Had a great experience here!
… moreShantel Yarborough
Thanks to Sugar River, I will never enjoy ranch dressing anywhere else again. I got a strawberry gin fizz mock-tail, side salad, spinach artichoke dip, and Amazon pizza. Filling and plenty of leftovers for lunch tomorrow. I can still taste the ranch. I don’t know what they did, but I need that bottled in a grocery store ASAP. I’ve never tasted a more refreshing or delightful dressing. Not too heavy and the dill was extremely refreshing. If you couldn’t tell, the ranch made the most impact. Everything else was delicious as well, but I’m stuck on the ranch.
… moreAllison Griffith
This was our first time trying Sugar River Pizza and it was truly something to write about. In this world of hit or miss resturants this place was a big hit! We started with some of the best fried pickles and wings my son and I have ever had. Perfectly fried and juicy with the house ranch which we are now in love with. The half garden salad was huge and so fresh. We ended up with 2 pizzas and both were perfectly crispy and amazingly delicious. The Figgy Pie was savory and a bit sweet so satisfying and my son’s pepperoni was stellar. We couldnt stop talking about it on the way home. I am kicking myself for not coming here sooner. The service was wonderful and our server was so personable and knowledgeable I believe her name was April. The outdoor patio was shady and peaceful on this hot day. 10 out of 10 will definitely end up being one of our favorite spots from now on! Thank you!
… moreBrent Erickson
Second sugar River pizza location we have visited. Food was awesome! Staff was ok our waitress needed a bit more training. Forgot straws for us and other tables. Forgot to put in our appetizer. Didn’t get us refills.
… moreLaura Tembei
I have dined in multiple times and have ordered take out many times as well and they have continuously reduced the amount of food you receive for the price you pay. I paid $10 for cheese curds and received about half the serving size I would have been given had I dined in. I will no longer be eating at this restaurant with their overpriced food.
… moreCalista Y
My husband and I’ve been regulars at Sugar River for several years, but I don’t think we’ll be returning. We were just there and as we start taking a few bites into the pizza, we noticed a long piece of hair stuck in the pizza. When we talked to the server, she didn’t apologize or looked concerned but just casually asked us whether we wanted to continue eating it (yuck!) or wanted a new pie baked. We asked to cancel the pizza and take it out from the bill and get us our bill for our drinks and the soup. She dropped the bill off and then we had to wait quite a while for her to pick up my card and the bill. Finally after a while she picked it up but later came back dropping off the card without any receipt for me to put my signature on. She walked away so quickly after dropping it off, we didn’t even have a chance to tell her that the receipt was missing, so we had to walk over to the counter in search of the merchant copy of the receipt for me to sign. Still no apology. I understand that an accident like baking hair in a pizza can happen (though it’s disgusting) but the whole situation could have been dealt better.
… moreEmily Roman
We loved this restaurant! The food was INCREDIBLE. The service was really nice. I’d recommend the MacDaddy pizza! The 12” was more than enough for my husband and I (we each got 4 slices!). We enjoyed the beer cheese dippers. Also, we went during happy hour so our appetizer was 1/2 off! It was so cheap!
… moreGeo K
i’ll be sure-gar to eat here again! wonderful service & just a lovely time! the pizza was solid & the pretzel bites were so good!
… moreLucas Robinson
Pizza was good with a generous amount of sauce on it. Which I’m my opinion you don’t find very often. If I had to critique it the only thing I could find wrong was towards the middle of the pizza the crust got a little soggy but I had a lot of toppings so this was minor to me and my family. We also had the sausage spinach and artichoke cannoli we couldn’t find one thing we didn’t like about this. Also wanna say it’s a very nice place for kids there menus for them are very reasonable. The icing on the cake for us tho was our waitress Nichole. She was very helpful knowledgeable about the menu and had tried most of the items just an all around good waitress. We were very blessed to have her.
… more