Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4825 Milton St, Cape Coral, FL 33904
Phone: (239) 549-0151
Website: https://www.stuffabagelfl.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Find your Location – Stuff A Bagel
Item added to your cart ; STUFF-A-BAGEL DELI-BAKERY. 4825 Milton Street. Cape Coral, FL 33904 ; STUFF-A-BAGEL DELI-BAKERY. 8911 Daniels Pkwy. Suite 2. Fort Myers, …
Stuff A Bagel | Cape Coral FL – Facebook
Stuff A Bagel, Cape Coral. 4631 likes · 39 talking about this · 1537 were here. New York deli and bagels made the old fashioned way.
Stuff A Bagel | Florida’s Legendary NY Bagel | Jersey Turnpike
Stuff A Bagel is a bakery with a large selection of pastries and beverages in FL. We even have sandwiches and bagels that are made fresh every day.
Reviews
Veronica Mato
I really liked this place. We were in Cape Coral for vacation and found this place next to the Chinese spot we ordered dinner from. We decided to eat here the next day. I got an everything bagel toasted with bacon egg and cheese and my wife a cross isn’t with scallion cream cheese. Everything was fresh and delicious! We saw that there was an olive cream cheese and asked if we could try it. The lady was super kind and brought some out on a fork. Delicious! The place was packed and they had some cool bagels as well like French toast and rainbow. Will go back for sure!
… moreMairead Jensen
Amazing bagels, delicious pastries and the coffee is fantastic-the real winners are the staff!! So polite and they use your name when giving you what you ordered-sounds small but honestly it’s very meaningful. You can get decent bagels anywhere but customer service can be hard to come by.
… moreR.P.E.
I stopped here every day during my visit in Cape Coral and this bagel shop by far is the best experience I’ve had over any bagel restaurant. The prices are fair, the bagels are outstanding with multiple options and the pumpkin cream cheese was beyond amazing! Lots of options for lunch and crafted coffee.
… moreRob Wilkerson
While Visiting Cape Coral, we were looking for breakfast and found this place online. We placed an order and picked it up and were amazed at how huge the bagels sandwiches were. They were also delicious. The bagel was chewy and maybe one of the best bagels I’ve ever had. If you’re looking for a great breakfast in Cape Coral, their breakfast sandwiches on bagels are incredible.
… moreBec Wester
Joe with Stuff A Bagel was so helpful! They catered breakfast and lunch for the
morning of my wedding in December 2024.
They supplied us with everything we needed and the food was DELICIOUS. I mean even the fruit platter tasted better than any fruit I’ve ever had. We ordered almost all the sandwiches, macaroni salad, breakfast sandwiches, bacon and waffles. The WAFFLES were 100% the best waffles I’ve ever had.
Thank you so much Joe and the team for making our special day, seamless and delicious! If I lived closer – I’d eat here all the time.
(I didn’t take very many photos – wish I would have.)
… moremorning of my wedding in December 2024.
They supplied us with everything we needed and the food was DELICIOUS. I mean even the fruit platter tasted better than any fruit I’ve ever had. We ordered almost all the sandwiches, macaroni salad, breakfast sandwiches, bacon and waffles. The WAFFLES were 100% the best waffles I’ve ever had.
Thank you so much Joe and the team for making our special day, seamless and delicious! If I lived closer – I’d eat here all the time.
(I didn’t take very many photos – wish I would have.)
DamnYouRabbit
Honestly, not very good. Look at all the bagel pics in these reviews- untoasted and very plain tasting. My orange juice tasted metallic, like it came out of a Country Inn free breakfast machine- just concentrated stuff. It had a custom sticker on it, so I was hoping for something more fresh. The baked goods are not home made, and are uninspiring.
… moreA G
Stopped by Stuff-A-Bagel Deli & Bakery for breakfast. The bagels were fresh and delicious — just be sure to mention if you want them toasted, otherwise they’re served as is.
They give a huge portion of cream cheese — some will love it, but I’ll probably ask for half next time.
Overall, a great local spot for freshly made bagels and a satisfying breakfast.
… moreThey give a huge portion of cream cheese — some will love it, but I’ll probably ask for half next time.
Overall, a great local spot for freshly made bagels and a satisfying breakfast.
Steve and Lisa LaBrant
I’ve been going to stuff a bagel for years up on Pine Island road and they are always very friendly, have good supply of bagels etc. This location on Cape Coral parkway is just the opposite. The people are always rude. They hardly have any bagels ever and when you ask them a question they act like you are bothering them. Happened again today. This will be the last time I ever go to this location
… moreCindy Hicks
Ordered a variety of bagels to take to a relative’s home. I don’t know if they were days old or what, but they were so hard we could barely cut them in half (we picked them up early morning). The only one I tried was the cinnamon raisin bagel. It had one raisin in the entire bagel and was pretty much tasteless. Nobody had anything good to say about any flavor. My sister decided she’d just try making croutons out of them vs. throwing away. Very disappointed!
… moreAnthony Peluf
We stopped in for breakfast on a Sunday morning about 10am. It was buzzing with a good, busy energy. Took about 5 minutes to get up to front of the line to order.
We got 2 bagel sandwiches in store and some bagels and cream cheese to-go. Both sandwiches were cooked to order and really good. They have signs posted that they don’t toast unless you specify.
The decor was New York themed and fun. We would definitely come back and would recommend.
They also have a nice selection of bakery items and coffee, juice, etc.
… moreWe got 2 bagel sandwiches in store and some bagels and cream cheese to-go. Both sandwiches were cooked to order and really good. They have signs posted that they don’t toast unless you specify.
The decor was New York themed and fun. We would definitely come back and would recommend.
They also have a nice selection of bakery items and coffee, juice, etc.