Casual, family-run establishment providing pizza, sandwiches & Italian entrees, plus espresso.
Cory Laws
Had a cheese steak. Expected better. But there was a street fair, so it was crowded. We got a table right away. Not complaining.
… moreGuy Martini
This place has the worst pizza i EVER had. And i been eating pizza for over 50 years. The sauce tasted like watered down ketchup. I wanted to try it , since new owners took over. TERRIBLE. The old place was very good. Shame. Because they have a great location. Anyone saying this pizza is good. Honestly , never had a good pie. Probably eat Domino’s pizza too do yourself a favor go to mossuto’s for a real pizza six kids behind the counter laughing , not even noticing i was standing there for a couple minutes before they even acknowledged me. Then acting like they never even worked there
… moreHeather Chinery
Spring Lake Pizza is the best! Their hot honey pepperoni pizza is my absolute favorite, the perfect mix of sweet and spicy. The crust is always crispy, the ingredients taste fresh, and the staff is super friendly. Definitely my go-to spot whenever I’m craving great pizza!
… moreElizabeth R.
Came here after seeing a show at the Spring Lake Theater, the margarita pizza was very flavorful but THIN crust, even though it looked normal, it was thin. I also got the sicilian slice, pretty tasty and had the thickness to the crust that made both slices taste nice haha overall good experience
… moreSal Cali
Excellent food.
Tables and seating is Pizzaria style, nothing fancy, but the awesome food certainly outweighed any atmosphere shortcomings.
Wait staff was excellent too.
… moreAllie
Cute place to stop for lunch in Spring Lake. The sandwiches are amazing and prices well for what you get. The grilled chicken sandwich with roasted red peppers, mozzarella, and balsamic is a must try. Everything is fresh and the staff is very kind and attentive. I recommend ordering ahead online and finding a spot to sit in town, the restaurant itself is a bit smaller.
… moreDennis Adkins
Austin, TX native here on business. Asked a local where to get authentic Jersey pizza and this place was on top of the list. It did NOT disappoint. When I took my first bite I HAD to sit down it was so good. Thin, hot and perfect! This is how pizza is supposed to taste. On top of that the staff was super friendly and everyone eating in the restaurant was having a good time. It had a great vibe to it. Loved it, can’t wait to come back.
… moreJanice Lam
Every time we visit Spring Lake, we always come to Spring Lake Pizzeria. The pizza is crunchy and delicious, and the Buffalo wings are must have. The linguine with baby clam in white sauce was fresh and tasty. Our server Fiona was polite and attentive + she had really cool pizza earrings. We will def come back next year!
… morestephanie bricken
We love Spring Lake Pizzeria for more than the pizza! Don’t let the quaint pizzeria-look store-front deceive you, they have a full Italian menu. Favs are spaghetti alle vongole…linguine in white clam sauce…we are still on our taste comparison journey (@the world and in all echelons), and SLP is still the best! Also love the Spring Laker salad and Jaqueline’s pasta (with arugula!) The icing on the cake is the friendliness of the owners, Barry and Holly, it’s a real family business.
… moreA J
Seems like this place has changed hands and the new management have completely ruined the pizza – before, this was the best pizza in the entire county, with a great depth of flavor. Now the slices are bland and greasy with a thin tasteless crust and plastic-feeling cheese – just awful. Sad to say that after coming here for years, we will not be back.
… more