Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Here at Sherrill New York Pizzeria, there are three concepts that built our foundation: Family, consistency, and PIZZA. Since its beginning in 1982, we have been family owned and operated. Originated by the Lazio Family, Frank, Eleonora and Salvatore. The Lazios successfully built and ran the business for 20 years. Since 2002, The Krawiec family has been committed to serving Sherrill with quality ingredients and service. For 33 years, our pizza has been made with the recipe Frank originally brought over from Sicily. To this day we use only the freshest ingredients to make our signature sauce. Pizza is our passion, we hope you enjoy our pizza as much as we enjoy making it for you!
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sherrill New York Pizzeria
Sherrill New York Pizzeria. Love At First Slice. HOME · MENU · ABOUT US · CONTACT. Order Now.. Daily Specials. Large Cheese Pizza & Boneless …
MENU – Sherrill New York Pizzeria
abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyzABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ. Sherrill New York Pizzeria. Love At First Slice.
CONTACT – Sherrill New York Pizzeria
Sherrill, New York 13461. (315) 363-2189 · [email protected]. HOURS OF OPERATION. Monday – Thursday…11:00am-8:00pm.
Reviews
Megan M
Super disappointed with how this restaurant has ‘rebranded’. Basically if your beliefs don’t align with theirs, you aren’t welcome there. This is why the political divide continues to grow deeper. You can’t even get a pizza anymore without a far right agenda shoved in your face. As for the pizza, it was incredibly greasy. I thought cheese would be a little less grease but I was mistaken. The wings and salad are great and this place is practically around the corner from us but sadly we won’t be back because it’s clear we aren’t welcome there.
… moreAshley Terry
A great place to grab a bite. The boneless wings are perfectly crispy and delicious. The pizza is also amazing. The service was very fast and the staff were great. I love stopping here when I’m in the area.
… moreAshley Harvey
Fast service and delicious slices ready to go. A selection of tables to sit at, if you want to sit and enjoy your slice.
… moreGoat Talk
This place use to be my favorite pizza in town . The food is good DONT get me wrong but when pull up and the entire staff doesn’t even have a mask on it’s a hard no for me and my kids . Maybe next year will try this place again .
… moreTheJummy Jum
For a long time I have been getting the same things from here, and today i decided to try a Philly Steak sub. No cap the best sub i have ever eaten subway aint got nothing on this.
… moreChad Combs
Called and ordered a large pizza with extra cheese/pepperoni. I get it home and there is hardly any cheese on it and the crust wasn’t even done. Worse pizza I have ever ate. TERRIBLE PIZZA. Should be ashamed of yourself!!
… moretar6569
Excellent NY Buffalo Chicken pizza! Would stop here again on my way from Maine. Very good prices and quality
… moreDanDannyDano
The pizza is bland. I think they need to change their tomato sauce to a more vibrant supplier or at least add some more spices in it.
… moreCyndi Tarry
We had pizza and wings with fried dough delivered last night. Everything was delicious! The service was great from the person answering the phone to the delivery driver! Highly recommend this place, it’s going to be our new “go to ” place.
… moreGreg Smith
Rude and short with me at the counter. Then I ordered antipasto 2 slices of pepperoni and mozzarella sticks. I apparently did pronounce antipasto to his liking because he acted like he didn’t know what I meant till I said the salad with the meat and he said antipasto we have some pre-made. Hardly any meat on it and only ham at that. The 2 slice were obviously reheated no surprise it was late at a new york pizza joint that wasn’t the problem. The problem was they didnt heat them up enough and I saved the crusts to feed to my dog he wouldn’t even eat them. I can’t blame him because honestly the dough taste like cardboard with a little sugar on it. The mozzarella sticks were obviously the frozen kind. You van get these same mozzarella sticks at Arby’s.
… more