Joey Sgarlata
Absolutely tha best pizza I’ve had in really long time!!!
… moreMichael Dobbins
Great little family owned pizza place. Service was fast and friendly. I ordered the Sheila supreme and the Philly cheese steak pizzas and both were great. The offered subs, burgers and wings as well
… moreJs heavy
Ordered at 7:09, they told me 30 to 45 minutes for a friday thats understandable. When u receive it an hour and ten minutes later and there not but 2 miles up the road. That is a little much. The pizzas on the bottom were both very undercooked, almost to the point of raw. As u can see. I haven’t really had good luck with this place ever since ordering here. You alone can only determine to go eat here or order delivery. I think this will be the last time for me. Oooo and the people that give this place a good review are friends and locals just trying to make it look good.
… moreTricia Hill
Buffet is nice. They will make your favorite pizza for you. The salad bar has a great variety of veggies.
… moreTaylor Sanderson
Very disappointed in Shelia’s Pizza. We have eaten here for many years even though we have to drive quite a distance (approx. 30 minutes one way) to get there because we really enjoy the pizza. The Marbury Youth Football and Cheer League partnered with Glass Door, who offers discount cards with local businesses, as a fundraiser opportunity for the children. Glass Door reached out to Shelia’s Pizza, signed a contract, and Shelia’s offered a BOGO any size and toppings pizza on the discount card, which was sold to over 100 parents! Shelia’s is now refusing to honor it. They are stating that someone forged the information and that Shelia White did not agree to it even though it clearly states, “authorized by Shelia White”. Shelia’s refused to honor to discount card (one time use). We will not be back. It is not about the money but simply the fact that Shelia’s agreed to offer this deal to local families then refuses to honor it. We have used our MYL discount card at many other local restaurants in the area with zero issues.
… moreChris Jackson
Great little place to grab a bite to eat the owner’s granddaughter and the young woman working the cash register and bringing pizza to the lunch buffet were both as sweet as they could be like they known you for year’s our first time grabbing a bite to eat lunch there after fishing on lake Jordan we will definitely be back. They have a pizza buffet at lunch plus a sandwich and even baked sub menu as well.
… moreMMS Hwy70
We got a Chicken Parmesan sub and a ham and swiss sub. Ham sub had 2 pieces of ham on a 6” sub roll. Chicken sub had 2 small chicken fingers and the marinara sauce was soaked into the breading of chicken. Very disappointing for spending $21
… moreChuck Allen
Great small town pizza shop with super friendly staff and a good variety of offerings on the menu. Make sure to check them out.
… moreJohn Bryan
Sheila’s has some of the best pizza. We ordered half Cheese and half Chicken bacon ranch and it was really good. We ordered hot wings as well, they were not that good. I would definitely come back.
… moreAndrew Crawford
Maui Waui was great! They were very nice and only waited 10 or so minutes which is great considering the quality. The cheese seemed different than what I remember but it’s probably been 10 years since I ate Sheila’s and that was at the Millbrook location. If you’re looking for great local pizza this place is a legend in the area and you’ve found the right place.
… more