Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
A standby for Italian classics since 1912, this old-school, family-run spot offers a warm ambiance.
Hours
| Friday | 11:30 AM–1:30 PM, 5–8 PM |
| Saturday | 5–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–1:30 PM, 5–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–1:30 PM, 5–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–1:30 PM, 5–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 919 Vine St, Cincinnati, OH 45202
Phone: (513) 721-9484
Website: http://www.scottisitalianrestaurant.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menus | Scotti’s Italian Restaurant in Cincinnati, OH
A standby for Italian classics since 1912, this old-school, family-run spot offers a warm ambiance.
Dinner Menu | Original Italian Foods in Cincinnati, OH
Scotti’s Sirloin Steaks & Beef Dinners · Rolled Stuffed Beef – Bracioletti. Beef stuffed with meat and bread stuffing in a tomato sauce · Braciole Ala Veneziana.
Hours & Location | Scotti’s Italian Restaurant in Cincinnati, OH
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating. Hours & Location. 919 Vine St, Cincinnati, OH 45202 · 513 721-9484. Tuesday- Friday
Reviews
Timothy Miller
I went to Scotty’s Italian Restaurant last night for the first time, and I honestly can’t believe no one told me about this place sooner. This may be the best Italian restaurant in the city.
Classic, old-school Italian food straight out of The Sopranos. The house red wine was delicious. The slightly sweet, old-fashioned coleslaw-style salad was a surprise and worked perfectly, and the Italian bread basket was excellent.
I ordered the veal parmigiana, which was magnificent—perfectly cooked and served with a generous side of pasta and rich tomato sauce. My buddy had the shrimp scallopini, which was spicy and outstanding. My wife loved her lasagna. And the cannoli for dessert? Absolutely spectacular.
The waitstaff deserves special mention: incredibly attentive, warm, and refreshingly old-fashioned in the best way.
If you’re looking for a quiet, romantic, small, authentic Italian restaurant in downtown Cincinnati, don’t miss this place. A true gem.
… moreClassic, old-school Italian food straight out of The Sopranos. The house red wine was delicious. The slightly sweet, old-fashioned coleslaw-style salad was a surprise and worked perfectly, and the Italian bread basket was excellent.
I ordered the veal parmigiana, which was magnificent—perfectly cooked and served with a generous side of pasta and rich tomato sauce. My buddy had the shrimp scallopini, which was spicy and outstanding. My wife loved her lasagna. And the cannoli for dessert? Absolutely spectacular.
The waitstaff deserves special mention: incredibly attentive, warm, and refreshingly old-fashioned in the best way.
If you’re looking for a quiet, romantic, small, authentic Italian restaurant in downtown Cincinnati, don’t miss this place. A true gem.
Tamara Schwarting
We went to Scotti’s Italian Restaurant for our work holiday lunch, and it was the perfect choice for something a little special but still relaxed. There were three of us, and from the moment you walk in, you get that classic old-school Italian restaurant vibe—dim lighting, tiled walls, drippy candles on the tables, and plenty of red-and-white checkered tablecloths. It feels like stepping back in time in the best way.
The lunch menu is straightforward and comforting, focusing mostly on pasta and bread. You choose your sauce and pasta, keeping things simple and traditional. I ordered the baked lasagna, which was hearty, flavorful, and just the right portion for lunch. One colleague had baked ravioli, and the other chose a stuffed pasta—everyone was happy with their meal.
The Italian bread served with butter was a standout in its simplicity: a good-quality loaf, and perfect alongside the pasta. Portions were generous without being overwhelming, especially for a midday meal.
Service was quick and efficient, which made it ideal for a work lunch, and the total bill for all three of us—including tip—came in right around $55, which felt like a great value.
This is a family-owned Cincinnati institution that’s been around forever, and it shows in the atmosphere and consistency. If you’ve never been to Scotti’s, you absolutely need to try it—especially if you appreciate classic Italian food and a unique, nostalgic dining experience.
… moreThe lunch menu is straightforward and comforting, focusing mostly on pasta and bread. You choose your sauce and pasta, keeping things simple and traditional. I ordered the baked lasagna, which was hearty, flavorful, and just the right portion for lunch. One colleague had baked ravioli, and the other chose a stuffed pasta—everyone was happy with their meal.
The Italian bread served with butter was a standout in its simplicity: a good-quality loaf, and perfect alongside the pasta. Portions were generous without being overwhelming, especially for a midday meal.
Service was quick and efficient, which made it ideal for a work lunch, and the total bill for all three of us—including tip—came in right around $55, which felt like a great value.
This is a family-owned Cincinnati institution that’s been around forever, and it shows in the atmosphere and consistency. If you’ve never been to Scotti’s, you absolutely need to try it—especially if you appreciate classic Italian food and a unique, nostalgic dining experience.
David Trotto
This is my second time going there. And I live in Cleveland Ohio. The food is fantastic. And I love all of the pictures and wine bottles they have on display.
… moreJosh Frock
The food was hands down the best. The quality was amazing. I have never had anchovies and now I’m a fan. The deal was delish and the tomato sauce tasted out of this world. Do yourself a favor and make reservations!
… moreDawn Flanigan Johnson
I DO NOT RECOMMEND.
I had a horrible experience. I was genuinely excited for authentic Italian food, and absolutely everything was awful. The dark, uninviting ambiance, the extremely rude server, and the disgusting food made this one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had.
The server was rude from the moment he approached the table. When I placed my order, he acted like he couldn’t understand basic requests and flat-out refused to make any modifications. No explanation, no courtesy—just attitude. Completely unprofessional. He should be fired immediately. After the fact, I saw multiple reviews complaining about the same server, which tells me management already knows and simply doesn’t care.
The food was inedible. I took two bites, couldn’t force myself to eat another, left a $20 on the table, and walked out. Total waste of time and money.
This place is a complete disappointment. It’s a shame, but also avoidable if you read the reviews first—something I regret not doing. Do better.
Ew.
… moreI had a horrible experience. I was genuinely excited for authentic Italian food, and absolutely everything was awful. The dark, uninviting ambiance, the extremely rude server, and the disgusting food made this one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had.
The server was rude from the moment he approached the table. When I placed my order, he acted like he couldn’t understand basic requests and flat-out refused to make any modifications. No explanation, no courtesy—just attitude. Completely unprofessional. He should be fired immediately. After the fact, I saw multiple reviews complaining about the same server, which tells me management already knows and simply doesn’t care.
The food was inedible. I took two bites, couldn’t force myself to eat another, left a $20 on the table, and walked out. Total waste of time and money.
This place is a complete disappointment. It’s a shame, but also avoidable if you read the reviews first—something I regret not doing. Do better.
Ew.
Heather T
Really liked the food. Nice atmosphere. Good service. Nice family run restaurant. Very small, so don’t try large groups.
… moreTiffany Bradbury
I was very excited to dine here. The ambiance was fantastic. The service felt a bit rushed. The food was awful, tasteless and seemed undercooked. I was very disappointed. I don’t mind to pay more for good service and good food. This was not the case here. I won’t go back and would advise others against it.
… moreKelsey Storage
As always, Scotti’s is amazing! My boyfriend and I went there for our Valentine’s day dinner. We had such a good time and it was sooo delicious We love going not just for the food but it is super romantic aesthetically. Highly recommend for a date ❤
… moreFrancis Xavier
5 stars all around. As an East Coast transplant who grew up in an Italian family, this brought me back years. This is the best Italian food I have had here in 10 years. Our waiter was great telling us tales from the kitchen and family times that had me nostalgic. The food is authentic and outstanding. The atmosphere is magnificent. The old chianti bottles hanging and the table candles tie it all together with the red checkered tablecloth. The minestrone soup blew me away.
Do not make the same mistake I did and wait 10 years before getting here. If you’re a NY/NJ transplant this is a must go.
… moreDo not make the same mistake I did and wait 10 years before getting here. If you’re a NY/NJ transplant this is a must go.
Morgan
The ambiance was very nice. However, I was yelled at by the waitor for wanting to order 2 separate sides of the pasta and meatballs (on the menu). I was told I was very disrespectful to ask for that when someone else couldve taken my reservation if I didnt really want to eat. He threw his hands up and walked away from our table. I really thought it was a joke, until I realized it wasn’t. Unfortunately, I won’t be returning even though I was really looking forward to this. Wish you the best, just wasn’t for me!
… more