Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1124 NJ-34, Matawan, NJ 07747
Phone: (732) 582-0000
Website: http://www.roundpie.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Matawan, NJ – Round Pie
We are located at 1124 Rt 34, Matawan, NJ 07747.
Round Pie – Eat More Round Pie
Subscribe to our newsletter and stay updated on our latest special offers! select a store. — select a store –, Hylan Staten Island, Matawan, Old Bridge …
Menu – Matawan – Round Pie
Pies, Classic Cheese Pie, Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella. 12″ $10.75 17″ $17.75, Margherita, Tomato Sauce, Parmigiano, Fresh Mozzarella, EVOO and Fresh Basil.
Reviews
frankismint
As Staten islander who moved to NJ I was happy to learn there was a Round Pie within 10 minutes from me. Slices are tasty and the food is ready pretty quick.
Recently my wife and I stopped in to eat a few slices. We orders two 20 oz bottles sodas that were unfortunately not very cold (guessing they just restocked the case)
I let the girl at the register know that the 2 bottles of soda I just purchased were not cold and asked for 2 cups of ice. She told me she would need to charge me the full price of 2 fountain drinks, so $6 total for ice. She offered an alternative, and presented me with 2 plastic cups about 3 ounces each, and said I can give you these for free.
I’m sure this young lady was following her managers rules, she was pleasant, but man what a weird interaction and honestly, really petty. A lot of great pizza in this area, I suggest you treat your customers a bit better.
… moreRecently my wife and I stopped in to eat a few slices. We orders two 20 oz bottles sodas that were unfortunately not very cold (guessing they just restocked the case)
I let the girl at the register know that the 2 bottles of soda I just purchased were not cold and asked for 2 cups of ice. She told me she would need to charge me the full price of 2 fountain drinks, so $6 total for ice. She offered an alternative, and presented me with 2 plastic cups about 3 ounces each, and said I can give you these for free.
I’m sure this young lady was following her managers rules, she was pleasant, but man what a weird interaction and honestly, really petty. A lot of great pizza in this area, I suggest you treat your customers a bit better.
Justin Caple
I stopped for the first time and ordered the signature pie, and was blown away at the refined simplicity and amazing flavors. Perfect execution in the oven! Great pie!
… moreGrgrvs Yprvsk
Good pizza spot. They make dough right there. Great food and great atmosphere. Friendly staff and owners. Definitely try their chicken parm stromboli, and Perry much anything on menu is quite good.
… moregreg castillo
Ordered in a pizza on DoorDash. We were excited to try with all the positive reviews. I want to give the benefit of the doubt that this one was a one-off L of a pizza, but it was so bad I can’t order again from here out of principle.
… moreStephanie Kakounis
My favorite spot in the area their arugula pie is to die for !
… moreFrank Esposito
Round pie is my go to lunch spot for pizza by the slice when working from home. Their selection is fantastic and the ingredients are great. My only complaint is the sized of their slices and how they vary. Paying full price for a tiny slice is mildly annoying and would like to see some consistency here.
In my attached photo, the larger slice on the right (artichoke), is smaller than your average slice found in this area, while the other slice on the left (white slice) was tiny. This is a standard size plate, and 2 slices from most places over hang the plate by a wide margin.
… moreIn my attached photo, the larger slice on the right (artichoke), is smaller than your average slice found in this area, while the other slice on the left (white slice) was tiny. This is a standard size plate, and 2 slices from most places over hang the plate by a wide margin.
Alla Altunian
At this point Round Pie is the only pizza place we are ordering from
Their signature and arugula pizzas are incredible
Highly recommended!
… moreTheir signature and arugula pizzas are incredible
Highly recommended!
justine mattioli
I’ve been ordering from this location for many years. The pizza, the chicken parm and vodka sauce..anything is always on point. They are friendly and have not disappointed. Thanks!
… moreMax W
Since its a pizza shop, the 4 stars will reflect the pizza
The 17” signature pizza was really good! Wish it was in the oven for a bit longer.. 8.5/10
Buffalo chicken wrap was ok 6/10
Jalapeño poppers were ok 5/10
The buffalo wings was a no go.. most are pinky sized and dry.. since its so small i guess it gets over fried easily 2/10
Stick to the pizza!
… moreThe 17” signature pizza was really good! Wish it was in the oven for a bit longer.. 8.5/10
Buffalo chicken wrap was ok 6/10
Jalapeño poppers were ok 5/10
The buffalo wings was a no go.. most are pinky sized and dry.. since its so small i guess it gets over fried easily 2/10
Stick to the pizza!
Ananya Gupta
Vegetarian review.
They serve some VERY flavorful pizza slices that are amongst the thinnest I’ve ever eaten without being rubbery, biscuit or like a cracker (think Pieology) but a perfect base that stays to the side of the experience allowing the sauce and toppings to dominate the taste spectrum.
The best experience is their Signature gourmet pizza which is just fantastic and aptly named.
The Grandma slice (which is their variation on the range) was a let down – too bready (ironically) and lacked its defining flavor.
Although I also tried the white pizza slice, I’m not a fan of it and so not qualified to judge it.
Update: My wife got a slice of it and absolutely loved it. She loved the strong pesto flavour on the slice considering it was a mild white base.
If you’re in Marlboro or passing through, put the Signature slice on your list.
… moreThey serve some VERY flavorful pizza slices that are amongst the thinnest I’ve ever eaten without being rubbery, biscuit or like a cracker (think Pieology) but a perfect base that stays to the side of the experience allowing the sauce and toppings to dominate the taste spectrum.
The best experience is their Signature gourmet pizza which is just fantastic and aptly named.
The Grandma slice (which is their variation on the range) was a let down – too bready (ironically) and lacked its defining flavor.
Although I also tried the white pizza slice, I’m not a fan of it and so not qualified to judge it.
Update: My wife got a slice of it and absolutely loved it. She loved the strong pesto flavour on the slice considering it was a mild white base.
If you’re in Marlboro or passing through, put the Signature slice on your list.