Address and Contact Information
Address: 1387 NY-25A, Setauket- East Setauket, NY 11733
Phone: (631) 689-2253
Website: http://www.rollingpinbakery.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Rolling Pin Bakery – Every Cake Tastes as Good as they Look!
SETAUKET 1387 Route 25A Three Village Shopping Plaza (631) 689-2253. Wedding Cakes. greendot. Wedding cakes that are not only breathtakingly beautiful but …
Rene Augello (@rolling_pin_bake_shop) · East Setauket, NY
Don’t forget to grab our delicious, melts in your mouth rye bread for your corned beef dinners! And a side of Irish soda bread never hurt anyone! …
Store Cakes – Rolling Pin Bakery
We have the cake for you! Using an exceptional selection of fresh fillings and sponge cakes from scratch, our talented team of bakers and decorators can …
Reviews
Cody Meehan
Rolling pin bakery is delicious! I used them for my wedding and they had many cake options. I liked that they offered multiple taste testing combos. We went with the marble cake with banana custard. I still get compliments about our cake. Normally I hate wedding cake but I had 3 pieces on the day of my wedding. I can’t wait until my anniversary to taste this cake again
… moreKrystal Reynolds
We used rolling pin for our wedding at Atlantis in Riverhead!
The experience was amazing! We did two separate tastings that you order online and bring home! The staff/ chef is super nice and communication was great!
The cake the day of the wedding was fabulous!
Thank you rolling pin for an amazing wedding experience from the beginning!
– Joey and Krystal 12/12/24 wedding at Atlantis in riverhead
… moreThe experience was amazing! We did two separate tastings that you order online and bring home! The staff/ chef is super nice and communication was great!
The cake the day of the wedding was fabulous!
Thank you rolling pin for an amazing wedding experience from the beginning!
– Joey and Krystal 12/12/24 wedding at Atlantis in riverhead
Chelsea Winslow
Our wedding cake was absolutely perfect! We requested a chocolate sponge cake with alternating layers of chocolate and strawberry mousse filling. It was delicious and beautifully presented. We saved some cake for a few days after our wedding to have with family and it was still just as good as the night of! The Rolling Pin was a very easy vendor to book as they made the process of deciding on our cake and ordering our cake very smooth. When we picked up our samples, I also grabbed a blueberry scone for the drive home and it was so good. If they weren’t so far from where we live, I’d be going to the bakery regularly for my sweets!
… moreNicole Dawson
We got married on 11/21/2025 at Three Village Inn Stony Brook and Rolling Pin Bakery was the bakery in our package and I couldn’t have been happier.
Communication was so easy. From setting up cake testing to placing the order. 10/10. The cake was beautiful and delicious!
… moreCommunication was so easy. From setting up cake testing to placing the order. 10/10. The cake was beautiful and delicious!
Ashley and Jake P
Rolling Pin made it easy to get our free tastings and their cake was delicious! We ended up paying a small upgrade with our wedding package for the red velvet / cream cheese frosting option & it was soooo worth it. They worked directly with EW for the delivery and as far as I know, we had no issues!
… moreJeffrey Menzer
Wide ranging olde fashioned scratch bakery. Had a wonderful fruit tart square but lemon square did not meet expectations—weird lemon texture. If u need a celebration cake, this is the spot. No eat in. Cafe tables outside
… moreLyse Garant
Rolling Pin is an authentic bakery with on-site fresh baking DAILY. I’m a repeat customer… back again and again for the almond croissants, muffins, danishes, turnovers, bread and best mini scones on the planet. Service is always friendly and quick. Fruit tarts are amazing and perfect to bring as a dessert to your gatherings with their shortbread bottom crusts! Great donuts too. I highly recommend this place.
… moreJ L
Kid loves it! We have moved away and every year I drive one hour to get his birthday cake here.
… moreNoelle Etheridge
The Rolling Pin Bakery was the bakery that worked with our venue for the wedding cake. We had heard wonderful things about Rolling Pin but had never tried anything from them. Due to planning during COVID we did not do any sort of cake-testing and chose our cake at one of our meetings with our venue. We wanted to do a burgundy piping on the cake and the bakery reached out the week prior to our wedding to ask if we wanted to change the color because there was humid and wet weather in the weekend forecast. We were so appreciative of them being proactive and reaching out to us so that our wedding cake did not “sweat” and the colors did not run. When we saw the cake it was perfect and when we, and our guests, ate the cake we were blown away by the fabulous flavor! It was the best cake we ever had, we will certainly recommend the Rolling Pin Bakery to our friends and order from them for our next bakery needs!
… moreLeslie Fazin Lu
My mom and matron of honor worked with the Rolling Pin for my bridal shower back in March and although I didn’t work with them directly, the cake came out absolutely BEAUTIFUL. Truly one of the most beautiful cakes I’ve ever seen, and it went perfectly with the overall cherry blossom/floral theme. And it was delicious too!
… more