Address and Contact Information
Address: 1617 Main St, Belmar, NJ 07719
Phone: (732) 280-6990
Website: http://www.reyesnypizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Reye’s NY Style Pizza
Reye’s NY style pizza, Belmar Pizza, Belmar NJ, New Jersey Pizza.
Reye’s Pizza, 1617 Main St, Belmar, NJ 07719, US – MapQuest
Reye’s Pizza is a popular eatery located in Lake Como, NJ, known for its delicious pizza offerings and a variety of catering services.
Reye’s Pizza Reviews | Belmar, New Jersey – One Bite
Reye’s Pizza 1617 Main Street, Belmar, New Jersey (732) 280-6990 Pizza review Dave 0.0 Pizza review Community 7.0 Rated 7.0 based on 14 reviews.
Reviews
Rob Regad jr
Delicious pizza. Got the buffalo chicken and a plain slice. Both as delicious.
Kinda small. No bathroom.
… moreKinda small. No bathroom.
Allie
Such a great spot, the employees are so kind and food is amazing. Chicken parm sandwich and chicken parm wrap were awesome. Prices are even better, especially for the huge portions. Seemed like the employees knew every customer that came through, great energy and awesome food.
… moreR WeThereYet
Going to make this short and sweet. Hands down the best pizza down the shore. Nothing better in Belmar. Their buffalo chicken slice is perfection and blows out everyone in the area. Good deal for subs too.
… moreAva F
I used to be a regular at Reyes Pizza but after this experience I won’t be coming back.
I placed a delivery order and was told it would take about 30 minutes. Instead, it took almost two hours. The driver got my address wrong three separate times and I had to go back and forth on the phone with him just to get the food delivered.
When the food finally arrived, it was cold and soggy and clearly had been sitting too long. On top of that, our garlic knots never came.
I called the store to explain the situation, hoping they would make it right. The manager came on the phone and not once did he apologize. Instead, he just asked, “Do you want the garlic knots?” After waiting nearly two hours already I told him no. The food was already cold, why would I want to wait again? His response was, “So you want us to come pick up all your food? You don’t want it?”
I explained that I waited too long to throw it out, but I did want a refund on my card for the missing garlic knots and some kind of solution for the cold food. He said the driver would bring my cash for the knots and I said no he’s obviously busy I want it on my card. Then the call ended there.
THEN, the delivery driver called me (clearly irritated) saying the manager told him to bring cash to my house for the garlic knots. After already messing up the delivery and being clearly busy and stressed, why was the driver expected to fix the restaurant’s mistake? I told him to keep it. No employee should be put in that position!
As someone who has worked in the restaurant industry my whole life, I understand that mistakes happen. But it’s how a business handles those mistakes that matters. Reyes failed completely. No accountability, no empathy, and not even a simple “sorry.” That says everything.
… moreI placed a delivery order and was told it would take about 30 minutes. Instead, it took almost two hours. The driver got my address wrong three separate times and I had to go back and forth on the phone with him just to get the food delivered.
When the food finally arrived, it was cold and soggy and clearly had been sitting too long. On top of that, our garlic knots never came.
I called the store to explain the situation, hoping they would make it right. The manager came on the phone and not once did he apologize. Instead, he just asked, “Do you want the garlic knots?” After waiting nearly two hours already I told him no. The food was already cold, why would I want to wait again? His response was, “So you want us to come pick up all your food? You don’t want it?”
I explained that I waited too long to throw it out, but I did want a refund on my card for the missing garlic knots and some kind of solution for the cold food. He said the driver would bring my cash for the knots and I said no he’s obviously busy I want it on my card. Then the call ended there.
THEN, the delivery driver called me (clearly irritated) saying the manager told him to bring cash to my house for the garlic knots. After already messing up the delivery and being clearly busy and stressed, why was the driver expected to fix the restaurant’s mistake? I told him to keep it. No employee should be put in that position!
As someone who has worked in the restaurant industry my whole life, I understand that mistakes happen. But it’s how a business handles those mistakes that matters. Reyes failed completely. No accountability, no empathy, and not even a simple “sorry.” That says everything.
keith fisher
Best bang for your buck if you looking for great tasting food at reasonable prices. Great freaking place.
… moreRobert Kinzley
Finally decided to try this place. Ordered a margarita pie. Didn’t look or taste like any margarita pie I’ve ever ordered from a pizzeria, more like frozen from shop rite or 711 with a taste to match. Terrible. Delivery guy was nice.
… moreGillian Brogna
Have ordered from here before and decided to give it a second chance. I was told it would be 30 minutes to deliver from to 14th ave. 2 hours later, restaurant closed, no food arrived. Will never give this place another try again and will definitely never recommend
… moreSHAMUS NEWCASTLE
UPDATE ALERT!
zero stars if possible.
over the past 9 months this place has become incredibly disgusting. i can confirm with pictures but they are not pg-13 so i will post them hither.
bad customer service.
unsafe food. // unfriendly employees.
will never go back even if for free.
… morezero stars if possible.
over the past 9 months this place has become incredibly disgusting. i can confirm with pictures but they are not pg-13 so i will post them hither.
bad customer service.
unsafe food. // unfriendly employees.
will never go back even if for free.
Marlene Cano
Great people, I NEVER had a bad experience with food. All of it is great! They will not disappoint, I’ve been ordering from them since they opened, which is about 10 years ago.
… moreLynne Burke
2 large grilled chicken salads – the best salad ever. This salad had just as much if not more, chicken and veggies than lettuce. Meaning they do not skimp on the chicken and fresh veggies. Delicious and so reasonable!
… more