Robin Mertz
This charming little deli was an absolute delight! The moment we walked in, it had that cozy, inviting feel that makes you want to stay a while. We picked up a couple of sandwiches, and honestly, they were so good that they lasted us for two full days, each bite just as fresh and flavorful as the first. Everything about the place feels thoughtful, from the perfectly toasted bread to the generous fillings and fresh ingredients. It’s exactly the kind of spot you want when you’re craving something quick but don’t want to compromise on taste. If you’re looking for a grab-and-go meal that hits all the right notes, this deli is a must-visit. Simple, satisfying, and absolutely delicious, it’s the kind of hidden gem you can’t help but tell your friends about.
… moreJessica Cain
While I was only inside for about 10 minutes to pick up my food, I enjoyed every moment of it! The staff members were so fun. Who knew that you could actually enjoy picking up lunch.
And for the funny guy at the register, yes, I finished the whole thing, and I’m currently eating my cheesecake and snacking on my chips
… morednzl Hopkinson
I almost never leave reviews, but I felt like I had to for Reuben’s Deli. This place has such a homey feel to it — the kind of spot that instantly puts you at ease. The atmosphere is amazing, with a view that looks right out over Atlanta. It’s almost like finding a cozy little escape in the middle of one of the most hectic cities in America. Being here gives you a pause from reality, a real breath of fresh air. Definitely one of those places you end up wanting to make your spot.
… moreMonica Gonzalez
My partner and I tried the Reuben and the classic. The Reuben is delicious and with the right amount of sauce, and a good size that you can finish it without feeling extremely full. The classic is pretty big and meaty and has a lot more sauce, so way more filling. The brownie is perfect, big and fudgy but not too fudgy. And the staff are very kind! Would recommend and go back 100%.
… moreVibing With Tyii Goddess
First Time At Reuben’s Yesterday & I Absolutely Loved The Scenery. Loved The New York Vibe By The Workers. They Were Very Nice & Respectful & Greeted You Entering & Leaving. Yelling Out What You Want On The Sandwich Was Fun To Do Lol. I Ended Up Getting A Turkey Club & I Was Surprised By How Huge This Sandwich Was ! I Ever Had A Sandwich This Big But It Was Delicious & Worth The Money. It Reminds Me Of The Shaggy Sandwich Shaggy Made On Scooby Doo Lol. Definitely Would Go Back
… moreChristine Huynh
I used to come here a lot in college. Now, I work around the area and came here for the first time in a longgg time. Still as good as ever. Sandwiches are HUGE. Service is great, and I feel like each employee had a great personality and they’re just funny. Feels very New York, if you know what I mean. This is only half of the sandwich and it was packed. I obviously couldn’t finish lol.
… moreAlexandra Mccloggan
My husband went in to order two Pastrami Sandwiches on bun. The old man behind the counter was rude. They do not offer military discount. And honestly that was the blandest Pastrami I had ever tasted and it was on old dry bread. Even the pickle was old and soggy. We won’t be back.
… moreRuth Anand
Got the hot blue sandwich from their recommendation and it was amazing! My friend got the godfather sandwich and was equally pleased. The staff was friendly and fast and the atmosphere of the location felt authentic
… moreBrian Lawson
If you’re a fan of a classic hot pastrami sandwich, Reuben’s Deli delivers a satisfying experience that hits (almost) all the right notes.
The Pastrami
The star of the show—the pastrami—is tender, flavorful, and packed with a perfect balance of smokiness and spice. It’s sliced just right—not too thick, not too thin—and piled generously on the sandwich. Each bite melts in your mouth, with just the right amount of fat to keep it juicy without being greasy.
The Bread
A hot pastrami sandwich is only as good as the bread that holds it together, and Reubens does not disappoint. The rye bread is fresh, with a slightly crisp crust and a soft interior. Wasn’t toasted, so the juiciness from the pastrami made it
Toppings & Condiments
A smear of spicy brown mustard gives the sandwich a nice tang, complementing the richness of the meat. No frills here—just the essentials, done right. If you prefer extra toppings like Swiss cheese or sauerkraut, they offer options, but the sandwich stands strong on its own.
Portion & Presentation
This is the kind of sandwich that makes you pause before taking your first bite—stacked high, beautifully layered, and almost too big to hold. It comes with a side of crisp dill pickles, which add the perfect crunch and acidity to balance the meal.
Overall Experience
The atmosphere at Reubens is classic and inviting, with a no-nonsense, New York-style deli feel. Service is quick and efficient, and the staff knows their sandwiches. At around $12.83, it’s not the cheapest lunch option, but for the quality and portion size, it’s well worth it.
Final Verdict
For a proper hot pastrami fix, Reubens delivers in nearly every way. Whether you’re a die-hard pastrami fan or just craving a satisfying, well-made sandwich, this spot is worth a visit, although the price is somewhat high. No military discount and parking is terrible.
… moreOkRa Family
Stopped by Reuben’s for an early lunch and had the Reuben and the New Yorker. Omg, these sandwiches are excellent! They are so well made. The Corned Beef and Pastrami were so delicious, with spicy mustard and the dressing. Pasta salad was also wonderful. We’ll definitely be back for more.
… more