Pasta Villa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria

Renowned for our highly rated dishes, we offer a diverse menu featuring an array of Italian delicacies, from flavorful pastas and authentic pizzas to …

Pasta Villa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria – View Menu & Order Online

Order online at one of the best restaurants in Columbus, OH! Pasta Villa Italian Restaurant & Pizzeria is a neighborhood favorite.

Last Updates

Reviews

Yassmena Pendleton-Burke

There was no cheese on my lasagna, salad was missing cucumber, croutons and pepperoncini peppers. The baked lasagna is listed as buy one get one free at $27.99 on Uber Eats but on the website baked lasagna is only $15… this was my first time ordering here and I was so excited to try the food but my order was definitely half assed. At least the cheese bread was good.

… more

Ashley Benson

Randomly selected this restaurant because we wanted pasta. The food was good, the lobster ravioli was amazing. We really enjoyed speaking with our server who was very friendly and welcoming. I would visit again.

… more

Manda Caldwell

Ordered on Uber eats. Spaghetti with meat sauce and lasagna. It was the worse I’ve ever had. Meat sauce is terrible. Leaves a nasty taste in your mouth and upset stomach. Lasagna was a grease pit. -stars if i could. YUCK.

… more

Edit: had change my rating sadly- the spaghetti with meat sauce had some kind of sausage rather than ground meat and tasted so bad that we threw it away and just split the other dish (ziti). I’ve had the spaghetti and meatballs before -which was pretty solid- so I’m not sure why they would do cook their meat sauce like this. If you come here, I would stick with the dishes that people rate highly and not deviate from that. My wife felt that the ziti this time was not as good, so maybe the quality has changed since the last time we ordered from pasta villa.

Original review: My fiancée and I have come here 3 times. She loves the chicken marsala. I’ve had one of the ravioli dishes, spaghetti and meatballs, and baked ziti- all were delicious, and the portions were substantial. I strongly recommend dining-in for this restaurant- they get a lot of UberEats/DoorDash, but there’s nothing like a plate of baked ziti hot out of the oven, and I don’t think you could capture the same experience from delivery. Check out their catering menu as well!

… more

MRBARBQ 1

Was out and about and have wanted to go to Pasta Villa. I had been to this place about 15 years ago. Phenomenal then. Today I would say it has definitely changed hands since I had been here. I entered and sat at a booth. Only one person working, he was having a heated conversation on the phone. He finally came out and took my order and brought me water as I requested. I ordered Lasagna which came with Garlic Bread. The bread was slightly burnt but was tasty. Ordered the Lasagna, a nice tomato taste which slightly chunky tomatoes in the sauce. One layer was made up of a huge square of ground beef. All in all it was a tasty meal. Plenty of seating for everyone.

… more

Vincent Lam

This Italian restaurant has been open close to north campus since I came here several years ago. Finally I would like to have some spaghetti as my dinner one day. The service was friendly and the place was clean. WiFi was fast. However, there was an extremely unpleasant smell in the dining room, especially in the restroom. Anyway, the chicken and eggplant Parmesan tasted authentic and juicy. They also served some free fried bread. The dish size was great but the price was a little high.

… more

Jennifer McIntyre

Ugh I just spent $64 and literally threw my food in the trash. The chicken Parmesan, whatever that was – the most disgusting thing I have ever smelled. And the spaghetti had some sort of weird mystery chunks of strange meat. It was watery. It smelled disgusting I couldn’t even eat more than one bite and threw the whole thing in the trash, so mad I spent this much money.

… more

John Lloyd

Pasta Villa is my favorite place to go for an authentic Italian meal. The entire staff goes above and beyond in every aspect. The garlic bread is to die for made from scratch daily. All natural ingredients cooked with old world methods. Highly recommend this classic north campus restaurant.

… more

John Derr

We visited after OSU football game. Pasta Villa is unassuming outside, hard to spot. Once inside our host welcomed us and spent time talking about the game. The food was the best Italian food we had eaten and portions were big and moderate priced. Highly recommend to anyone who enjoys good Italian food.

… more

Allison Kennedy

Terrible. Every dish was such a waist of my money and if I wasn’t very hungry, pregnant and everything else was already closed I would have taken it all back and asked for my money back. Barely managed to eat half of anything anyway. To start, nothing was fresh!!!!! I read other reviews saying the food was fresh but I have 15 years experience working in the best restaurants (the pearl, due amici, Mitchell’s steak house, etc.) in Columbus and I PROMISE nothing was fresh. Meatballs were frozen and microwaved and I can taste it. Confirmed with worker Cesar dressing is not made in house. Dressing was not normal creamy dressing but split as shown in photos(oil from other ingredients). The lettuce was dead (soft/old with no crunch). Hardly any cheese and croutons were certainly not made in house. Meatball red salsa also tasted like it came pre frozen in a bag from a restaurant supply store. Lastly the tiramisu portion was tiny for $10!!!!!!! I would willingly pay NO MORE than $4.50. Extremely angry that I gave this terrible restaurant my money…
I know almost all restaurants these days serve pre frozen food but I am still surprised when paying top price for food the quality is so efffffing CHEAP. CHEAP CHEAP CHEAP.

… more

… View more

Address and Contact Information

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results