YNP, Ed McMurphy!
It was a Joy to Find that a Favorite place is Still making 1 Bad Ass Pizza for All these (1999) years! We had the Best Meal with a The Caboose, with A Fantastic Fresh Salad, 2 liter soda, Hell they had Milk for Me! Love there Newer place!!! Last place was above Hwy 65 were I eat last! I won’t to start by saying, The Care that went in are meal was Precise in every Way. The Salad was So,So Good. Fresh, Clean taste, Assemble beautifully. Pizza, WoW, we’re do I start? Crest, Perfect, Allow to raise at least three times? Garlic White Sauce, Thank you, YES! Toppings, The Caboose is my Favorite! I have NEVER had a Bad Meal here, Thanks for All The Years & Hard Work you put into This Oasis in Lincoln!
… moreJoe Songer
Football on the TV. Beer. Good Pizza. We had the Royal Hawaiian and asked to add jalapeño. It was delicious. Cooked perfectly the way I like. Soft and lite on top with a crunchy bite on the bottom. Sauce had a sharp and subtle sweet flavor . Cashews were new on a pizza for me and to be honest I loved it. I didn’t know at first but the added texture was so satisfying.
… moreSally Ragusa
It’s been 15 years since I was last in Lincoln. I remember when the original location opened in 2004. I was really happy to see that they’re still doing business. The new location is really nice. The staff are friendly and pleasant. The pizza was great, just like I remember . Congratulations on your 20 years in business
… moreMark DeWitt
This review starts 10 days ago when we order a pizza to go. We picked it up with a salad and made it home 30 minutes later only to find someone had put a piece of tin foil between the pizza and the box. This congealed the crust back into dough. Accidents happen and we called to let them know. They offered to give us credit on another pizza in the future which brings us to today. We decided to try again and after working a long day to let Old Town Pizza do the cooking for dinner. I showed up around 7pm to the side take out counter and after a some checking they found the order. I was asked if “I wanted to take a picture” and she had been “told about me” wor really all we wanted was for them to make it right from the previous mishap. My family has been loyal to Old Town Pizza for 25 years and now they want to disrespect and challenge me for a $20 order. In this very competitive pizza environment where every dollar matters it’s unfortunate that I asked to get value for our families hard earned dollars and we’re looked down upon for asking. Sorry Old Town Pizza this is our break up letter and would encourage others reading this to patronize other options in Lincoln.
Mark D.
Lincoln CA
… moreAngelica Pama
Old town has been hands down the best pizza place in Lincoln my entire life. The crust is perfect. I actually want to eat it and not just leave it at the end of the night. The new building is gorgeous. It can get a little loud but the atmosphere really has a great community feeling. I can’t sit down in this place without seeing at least 3 people I know .
Servers are always friendly and fast. I’ve never had a bad experience at any of the locations. I wanted to shout out one worker in particular, Allie! With all her colorful pens. ❤️ She served my mom, boyfriend, and I, a little while ago and was the sweetest person. We all loved her and her energy. Thank you Allie!
OTP also does a lot of fundraising in the community which makes them a stand out business! My mom and I always make sure to go there and support when they do these.
We order delivery pretty often too and never had a bad experience. They almost always arrive early and the pizza is always hot a fresh.
Overall the food is great. The employees hardworking and friendly. Good for takeout or sit-down. A great business that gives back to the community. Thank you OTP!
… moreBilly Gross
Visited family and ended up trying this place for the first time even though I drive by it for years. I’m not a big pizza eater but I must say, if I do eat it, it will be from here when I’m in town. Probably the best pizza I’ve had. I actually planned on only eating wings but ended up having 20 wings and 5 pieces of pizza. Wings were bomb. The layout of this place is awesome. Very welcoming. Great selection of beer. And I believe they own the place directly next door that serves hard alcohol and also food.
… moreBlake6 Christiansen
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Best Pizza & Beer Combo Around!
Old Town Pizza is hands down the best pizza in Placer County! Whether you’re stopping in to enjoy a fresh pizza paired with your favorite craft beer, grabbing takeout for the family, or catering a big event, you can’t go wrong. You can even take home a 4-pack of your favorite brew!
The service is always top-notch — you can tell the staff genuinely care about great food and great experiences. With locations in Auburn, Roseville, and Lincoln, it’s easy to enjoy Old Town Pizza no matter where you are in Placer County.
I’m especially excited about the new Old Town Pizza opening in Roseville, June 2026 — in the historic Post Office building! Even better, it’ll include a Slice Beer Co Tap Room, bringing one of Lincoln’s best breweries even closer to you!
Pizza, beer, and amazing people — it doesn’t get better than this!
… moreJagan Sandhu
Very good pizza, one of the best I have eaten! The conductor was very flavorful and meaty
… moreGleb
Ordered a Steam Engine for take-out and was a bit hangry. Wasn’t happy with the amount of ranch they give you without paying for extra and the lid for the ranch jar was slightly ajar when I got it. Unfortunately it spilled out, and then accidentally knocked on the ground. I was pissed, felt like I was having a 0 star experience as I picked the remaining 1/4 of a ranch up off the ground. Then, I got home.
The breadsticks were perfect, the pizza even better. The ranch (what was left) was solid. I went from annoyed to happy in the blink of a bite. Had take-out so no judgment on the Service/Atmosphere, but the food is always so damn good. A little expensive, but always seems to deliver.
… morePam Martinez
We ordered 2 calzones and 1 slice of pizza to be delivered. All 3 were over cooked. The dough on the calzones was so hard that I couldn’t even cut through it with a serrated knife. It was dried out, hard and tasted slightly burned. These never should have left the business, someone blew it!
… more