Social Profile: ![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
This snug counter serve features build-your-own & specialty pies, plus subs & salads.
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Old School Pizza – Williamsport, PA
Appetizers · Onion Rings · Chicken Fingers · Fried Mushrooms · Breaded Cauliflower · Mozzarella Sticks · Breadsticks · Mac & Cheese Bites · Cheese Bread.
Old School Pizza – Williamsport, PA
Home of the $1 Slice! 12 East Fourth Street, Williamsport, PA 17701. 570-326-1466. Old School Pizza is currently closed for in-person dining, but open for …
Old School Pizza | Williamsport PA – Facebook
Details. . 78% recommend (583 Reviews). . $$. . Open now. . 14 E 4th St, Williamsport, PA, United States, 17701 ; Links. . oldschoolpizzashop.com ; Contact …
Reviews
Kelsey Anderson
I Love their pizza. Personally LOVE MANAGEMENT. My daughter loves their pizza and she is a picky eater. I am very disappointed in their strombolis though. Esp through delivery. It gets rolled up in what looks to be a hoagie and it’s wrapped in tinfoil. And all off the inside gets stuck to the middle so there’s about 4″ on each side that’s just bread out of a 14″ stromboli.thats more than half that’s only bread. Because it gets wrapped in the tinfoil it gets soggy. It’s really disappointing because I’d choose old school pizza over anywhere else in town. But I would never buy a stromboli from their again.
… moreIplayGamess
I have been coming here for over a decade and the staff has always been friendly and welcoming. The pizza and wings are consistently bussin. That’s all I get though, so anything else you’ll have to try for yourself! 5/5 🙂
-Jahiem Williams
… more-Jahiem Williams
Greg Baz
11:05 PM Monday night. The business hours say they close at 12 AM. But they are closed. And it looks like they’ve been closed for a while. I just wanted to slice of pizza. This review has nothing to do with their food, but with the fact that they closed an hour early. I’m hungry and not happy.
… moreRebecca Perkins
Stopped while traveling, Cheese steak was amazing! Wish we lived closer to come back regularly! Friendly staff and food was out extremely quickly. Only good things to say about this place!
… morePhilly Tee
Ordered a pepperoni pizza and they gave me an old cheese pizza and threw on some pepperonis. Pepperonis was falling off the pizza when you picked it up. Waiting on the replacement as I type. Severely disappointed. If you can’t make a fresh pizza, shouldn’t be in this business!! Last picture is the replacement pizza. Wayyyyyy different than the first.
… moreGrace Grace
I recently visited Old School Pizza and had a issue with my order. I was charged $4.75 for a drink that was listed as $2. When I brought it up the employee that rang me up did not offer an explanation or correction. I left feeling frustrated because I expected clear and accurate pricing.
… moreConnor Thompson
This place literally changed my life! The prices, the flavor, the accessibility (literally a 3 min walk from Lycoming College)….it’s SO good. You can buy pizza by the slice for a whopping $1.06…WHERE ELSE CAN YOU GET THAT?! It’s insane how cheap it is for the quality. It’s one of those places where the pizza is perfection. The flavors, the crust…so SO good. The place looks a little more rustic and older, however, that can’t change how fantastic the pizza is. Highly, highly recommend!
… moreEmmett Wilson
No sauce its pathetic. But for 9 dollars wat do u expect. Silly me. Tomato sauce 2 expensive eh,m
… moreMr. USA
Pizza delivered within allotted time but it was cooked beyond being edible. Crust was hard and crunchier than a potato chip and the cheese was burnt and bubbling in to hard cheese domes around the edges and hard all the way into the center. So disappointing, I’ve had better from them several years ago but I will not go back after this avoidable failure.
… moreAlthea Gaines
This is the last time I’m getting pizza from this place. Over the years their products and service has gone downhill, and the absurdity of it all is now the last question is “do you want to leave a tip fir the driver?” Hell no especially when the pizzas are cold once they arrive.
… more