Old Ice House Tavern

  4.4 – 259 reviews   • Bar & grill

Social Profile:

✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Old Ice House Tavern 47362

Hours

Monday7 AM–12 AM
Tuesday7 AM–12 AM
Wednesday7 AM–12 AM
Thursday7 AM–12 AM
Friday7 AM–1 AM
Saturday7 AM–1 AM
Sunday12 PM–12 AM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 1550 Walnut St, New Castle, IN 47362

Phone: (765) 529-9990

Website: https://www.facebook.com/profile.php?id=100088974665241&mibextid=ZbWKwL

Menu Photos

places.singleplatform.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Old Ice House Tavern | New Castle IN – Facebook

Details ; . 84% recommend (5 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 1550 Walnut St, New Castle, IN, United States, 47362 …

Ice House Tavern, 1550 Walnut St, New Castle, IN 47362, US

Ice House Tavern, located in Phoenix, Arizona, is celebrated as one of the best hockey bars in town, showcasing NHL games daily on flat screens and offering …

Ice House Tavern | New Castle IN – Facebook

Ice House Tavern, New Castle. 1959 likes · 6 talking about this · 4677 were here. since 1951.

Reviews

David Jackson
This is a very cool bar with a great vibe! The food was excellent the steak sandwich was great, especially when paired with the delicious homemade horseradish. The staff was superb, too, with super friendly waitress and waiters. The unique decor, like the old wheelchair hanging from the ceiling, certainly adds character! Will definitely go back.
… more
G Neal
Their food and atmosphere is excellent. Try their legendary Steak sandwiches! You will love it any way you want it. This place use to be a Stag Bar many years ago. I can remember when I was a kid in the late 70s lol. Small town. This place has always had its regulars and they are always nice and respectful in my experiences. Try it you will not be disappointed.
… more
Sleeping Beauty
Great dive bar. Good drinks. Cheap. Don’t expect fancy bar food. The older lady that tends to be there on Sundays isn’t the most friendliest at times. Even told me she doesn’t make fancy drinks when I ordered a margarita but I was okay with the mix. It kind of caught me off guard. She seemed to be friendly with the regulars or people she knew.

We’ve been there a couple of other times with a younger brunette working. She’s definitely a strong bartender and makes everyone feel welcome
… more
blacc sixowe
amazing place amazing people amazing food amazing karaoke amazing singers amazing host cute too respect all around amazing staff amazing everything blacc and blue da twins highly recommend this place everybody is one big happy family here .
… more
Isaiah Jolley
Every time I go in the place past 930 pm I’m told grill is closed and can’t get food happened about 6 times now just happened again at 1015 pm was told she is closing always the same old Karen 1/21/2026
… more
Taylor Marsh
Great atmosphere. LOVE they’re steak burger and breaded mushrooms! Plus, the bartender is awesome! Super nice and friendly guy!
… more
Tim Conway
It’s worth dealing with the smoke. The burgers and rings are exactly what I remember from 4 decades ago.
… more
Ronda Apodaca
Great vibe. You’ll walk in and instantly love it. There are movies playing on a white wash brick wall. Cozy couches and tables for you to choose from.

We got the duck turnovers (delicious) and the cheese and meat board (even more delicious). Cocktails were awesome too! Anything Goes will have you feeling really good.
… more
Colin Sanberg
Great local bar.

Service is always very good. The food is the big draw. Typical “bar food,” with the steakburger being the standout item on the menu. Cooked fresh to order, great flavor, and all the fixin’s. As a bar, good drinks at decent prices. Good local atmosphere, with a loyal contingent of regular patrons.
… more
David Miller
Had a great steak burger and a couple of beers for only $12!! Tessa is a Doll, took great care of me. Good old rock music.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment