Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1234 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 564-2397
Website: http://newarkpizzahouseoh.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Newark Pizza House and Bakery – Newark, OH – 1234 W Church St …
Order Hours About. 4:30 PM-10:00 PM; Shop address is 1234 W Church St, Newark, OH 430551234 W Church St, Newark, OH 43055; (740) 564-2397.
Newark Pizza House & Bakery – Facebook
Newark Pizza House & Bakery, Newark. 680 likes · 6 were here. Pizza isn’t just food, it’s our passion. We believe every slice should be a perfect balance…
Pizza House & Bakery
Welcome to Pizza House & Bakery, your new go-to spot for handcrafted, delicious pizza in the heart of Newark, OH! We’re passionate about using fresh …
Reviews
Jason Tolbert
Wife and I been waiting to try Newark Pizza House since it opened. This was our 1st time and it was great. I got the supreme wife got double double l(double pep double cheese) Both hand tossed crust. Both pizzas were very good ! It’s straight forward pizza good ingredients. I loved the sauce not sweet good flavor. Wife drove to pick it up said service great and very friendly. Best part is their pricing this is not a Fort Knox pizzeria very affordable! I typically like more ingredients on my pizza than my wife and here we could get both variations at good prices. I recommend this to anyone. I hope they stick around ! Thank you Newark Pizza House
… moredreaded gonzo
Ordered a triple double with stuffed crust and a sub. The sub was pretty solid. The pizza has regular cheese and regular pepperoni with no stuffed crust. Not worth the drive to pick it up.
… moreJ G
MAKE SURE TO SPECIFY WHAT CRUST!!! The first time I got. Large pepperoni pizza with thin crust and it was great!! This 2nd time I ordered pepperoni and sausage expecting to get what I did the first time just + sausage and it was totally different. It was a Italian/new York style pizza. I have never liked New York style pizza BUT I must say this was acrylic pretty decent. After calling and asking why it was different this time the man was kind and let me know to specify if I want it thin or Italian/New York style next time. Good pizza and kind service.
… morescott horning
When Lakehouse Pizza first moved into this location I was excited. It was great pizza, with consistency every Friday. It quickly became our households new weekly favorite. This has not been the case the past three times I’ve been here and it’s disappointing. When I’ve called I’ve been greeted with a lethargic hello, one time I had to ask if this was Lakehouse Pizza because I thought I called a random person who did not want to take the call. The consistency of the pizza from the amount of sauce, thickness of crust to taste has greatly been different. The past two times I’ve gone, the pizza has not been cut & I had to do it myself. Photos are from 6.6.2025. It appears they go about 40% through the crust. Judging from the lackluster & lethargic demeanor of the person taking calls or the person that sits in the corner listening to music as others work (I think this is the cutter) it’s not surprising. The drink cooler doesn’t seem to have been stocked in over a month. They are out of most everything and each week it gets less & less. With all this, and as unfortunate as it is, I probably won’t be returning.
… moreBryn Dunaway
We ordered a medium pepperoni pizza, breadsticks, fried zucchini, cheesesteak quesadilla w/fries, and New York cheesecake. The pizza was amazing, lots of cheese and pep even though we did not ask for extra, great tomato-y sauce and cooked well. The fries and fried zucchini were great and seasoned so well. My husband raved about the cheesesteak quesadilla and said it’s the best one he’s ever had. By the time my son got to his cheesecake to see that there were two slices, he could only eat one because he was so full. The gentleman who took the order over the phone was professional and kind, the wait was only 25min on a Friday evening around 5pm. We picked up and the restaurant looks really nice and clean. The gentleman and young woman who helped me were both professional and nice and the price was a bit lower than expected. We will definitely be back! We love supporting local small business.
… moreStephanie H
On a mission this year to stop eating at chains and support more small businesses. I found the Newark Pizza House to be super affordable, fast, and delicious! Will defn order from here again.
… moreAbdou Menacer
The Best Pizza and Fun Vibes in Town!
If you love delicious pizza and fast service, Newark Pizza House is the perfect place! The crust is crispy, the sauce is perfectly balanced, and the cheese and toppings are generous. Not just pizza—the hot wings, crispy fries, tasty sandwiches, and refreshing drinks are all amazing!
It’s a great spot for lunch or dinner with friends and family, and every visit leaves me happy and satisfied. I highly recommend Newark Pizza House to anyone looking for tasty, quick meals without compromise!
… moreIf you love delicious pizza and fast service, Newark Pizza House is the perfect place! The crust is crispy, the sauce is perfectly balanced, and the cheese and toppings are generous. Not just pizza—the hot wings, crispy fries, tasty sandwiches, and refreshing drinks are all amazing!
It’s a great spot for lunch or dinner with friends and family, and every visit leaves me happy and satisfied. I highly recommend Newark Pizza House to anyone looking for tasty, quick meals without compromise!
James Matheny
I ordered this past Tbursday. This may be the absolute worst pizza I have had in 48 years. Bland, toppings on one side, barely any sauce. Crust was chewy, not crispy as they advertise. Had 2 pieces and threw the rest out. Not sure the owners or staff have tried this pizza.. if so, how did anyone ever think, this is a great idea? Terrible. Save your money for one of the much better pizza places around. Garbage!!
… moreBrandon Ward
Tried ordering from this place multiple times, first time through the app “slice” they just basically said nah can’t do that… tried ordering in today… order accepted, waited 10 minutes and no update on my order. Order delayed… swiftly followed by order canceled, you won i wont order from you anymore.
… morenawal Ramirez
Amazing pizza made with fresh ingredients! Ever since the new management took over, the quality has been outstanding. Super friendly staff
… more