Mighty Fine Pizza

by

  4.6 – 411 reviews   • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

Cutting no corners and using only the finest, freshest ingredients available, Mighty Fine Pizza proudly become a Petoskey legend and has won more awards over the years. At just 8’ wide and 60’ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!” The building originated in 1966 and was Petoskey’s first pizza place. Mighty Fine Pizza is set apart from others in the industry because they make their own fresh homemade dough and pizza sauce. There is nothing “franchise” about Mighty Fine Pizza! You’ll find fresh and local products that are chopped and prepped by hand. Mighty Fine Pizza takes pride in having a friendly, welcoming, neighborhood environment for the staff.

Storied mom-&-pop nook making pizza with gourmet toppings, plus sandwiches & daily specials, to go.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Mighty Fine Pizza 49770

Hours

Tuesday11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday11 AM–9 PM
Thursday11 AM–9 PM
Friday11 AM–10 PM
Saturday3–10 PM
Sunday3–8 PM
Monday11 AM–9 PM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 222 E Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI 49770

Phone: (231) 347-3255

Website: http://mightyfinepizza.com/

View on Map

Menu Photos

mightyfinepizza.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Mighty Fine Pizza

At just 8′ wide and 60′ long, and once an alleyway, the Mighty Fine Pizza building is now known as, “The hardest working 480 square feet in Petoskey!”

Menu | Mighty Fine Pizza

Specialty Pizzas; Build Your Own Pizza; Appetizers; Grinders; Burgers; Salads … Mitchell St. Petoskey, MI 49770. 231.347.3255. Mighty Fine Deals. Don’t miss …

Specials | Mighty Fine Pizza

Family Special: Two large pizzas with two toppings, Garrett’s Pizza Bites … Mitchell St. Petoskey, MI 49770. 231.347.3255. Mighty Fine Deals. Don’t miss …

Last Updates

Reviews

B SNOW
********CARRYOUT or DELIVERY ONLY********

Apparently, I missed that detail somehow! They do have a small table out front that’s probably nice when it’s warm outside.

The items we ordered were excellent. For the price, this place really hit the spot. Between the XL pizza, large salad, and order of breadsticks, our order was only $36. Jalapeño Ranch for the salad was a nice touch!
… more
Scott Strawhun
We always try the local favorite when we travel. Jacob at Hampton Inn highly recommend Mighty Fine Pizza. We followed his recommendation and were very pleased. Generous toppings and the sauce was really good. Family owned and operated. Always love to see the family involved.
… more
Valerie Riedel
Always delicious and fast. Highly recommend their salads as well. Great local pizza!
… more
Enrique Garcia
We were in the area for our Anniversary and based on previous reviews we had to try the pizza. It is Take-Out only, but they had outdoor seating available along the sidewalk which we enjoyed on the cool, breezy evening. We even enjoyed the crust that was a good balance between soft and crispy. We definitely recommend this place when you’re looking for some mighty fine pizza.
… more
Hayden Hogg
Not much of an interior, only outside seating. Doesn’t matter. This pizza was the best pizza I have ever had. Everything was hot and fresh, the breadsticks were perfect and the crust had a slight crunch, but was still soft. Don’t miss out.
… more
Ashton Jakeway
To the manager that did not believe me, all I was asking was if this was normal and you didn’t understand what I meant. This is the see through, paper thin pizza that I called about that was burnt and gross. Worst part was, I tipped. I’m not coming back. Thank you.
… more
Teemaree
There is nothing but an order counter inside so be prepared to enjoy great customer service, place your order, and have a place to eat your food once it’s done. Their pizza is loaded with large chunks of fresh high quality ingredients. It tasted great and we loved it. Don’t want pizza? They have more than that! Give them a try when you are nearby.
… more
J.W Michano
Pizza is always great, only complaint I had was asked the girls why it was 5 dollar more? I ordered the exact same thing just 2 weeks ago. Said something about a fee which makes zero sense if I had the same order. Orders the 2 topping XL special added green peppers. Paid $24 before , this time was almost $29.
… more
Lora Hall
Loved their pizza! Love the owner and staff. Very friendly. Came in and ordered and waited outside with a beautiful view of town and bay.
Best pizza we had on our trip.
Loved all of it.
… more
Nik St
Tried the pizza for the first time. The crust is delicious with a hint is sweetness. Very fresh. Looking forward to trying grinders and salads
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact