Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 183 S Main St, Naples, NY 14512
Phone: (585) 374-6550
Website: https://www.facebook.com/groups/108352075856451/about
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Middletown Tavern | Facebook
… amazing event! Visit Naples NY Middletown Tavern Naples Ny Saturday March 7th, 9- midnite! Tracy Bartlett and 23 others. 24 reactions ·. 2 comments. ·. 1 share.
Middletown Tavern: A Local Culinary Gem in Naples, NY
Middletown Tavern, located at 183 S Main St in Naples, NY, is a beloved local establishment known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious food.
Middletown Tavern – Home | Facebook
Middletown Tavern, Naples, NY. 855 likes · 53 talking about this · 4441 were here. Bar.
Reviews
John Penkitis
Classic local tavern. Very rustic and authentic feel to it. Service was top notch. Food came quick. Some of the best wings I’ve had recently. Large and perfectly cooked. Snowmobile trail leads right to the parking lot. They take credit cards now.
… moreA.B. Clawson III
Plenty of room and very welcoming. I played darts on what seemed like a brand new arcade dart board. Great prices and delicious bar fare.
… moreAbby Townley
Came for a birthday lunch (mine!) with my parents and son. Went to the bar to order drinks and food, but the food we ordered never came. My parents received their food in a timely manner, but 20 minutes after they finished I went to the bar to get a refill and inquire about the rest of the food. Was told that ‘we ordered a lot of food’ and ‘wings take a long time’. I agreed but not this long.
Another 10-15 minutes go by and we’re then informed by the kitchen that that part of the order was never put in the POS…what?! Asked how much longer it was going to be and was told the food hadn’t even been started yet!
No, ‘ I’m sorry, can we do anything to make this right?’ Just lies.
Then, I found out after the fact they gave my parents drink chips to make up for it..huh? Make it make sense.
As a patron that has frequented this place for over 30 years, I’m sad to say I won’t return. If this place survives it’ll be a miracle. Don’t bother going if you’re not a local and/or regular, you won’t be served.
… moreAnother 10-15 minutes go by and we’re then informed by the kitchen that that part of the order was never put in the POS…what?! Asked how much longer it was going to be and was told the food hadn’t even been started yet!
No, ‘ I’m sorry, can we do anything to make this right?’ Just lies.
Then, I found out after the fact they gave my parents drink chips to make up for it..huh? Make it make sense.
As a patron that has frequented this place for over 30 years, I’m sad to say I won’t return. If this place survives it’ll be a miracle. Don’t bother going if you’re not a local and/or regular, you won’t be served.
Perry Soper
Was looking forward to going back and trying it now with new ownership. We don’t frequent bars often but after our work day we thought stopping in would be a nice change and give us a chance to try things out and look at menu changes….all that would’ve been great IF WE HAD BEEN WAITED ON WHILE SITTING AT THE BAR!
Nope! Finding a game on the TV right in front of us, cleaning off popcorn baskets from a couple empty seats, talking to regulars, and folding some silverware were all way more important than asking what we wanted to drink. But hey, at least she said hi after completely ignoring us for a couple minutes I guess. We finally walked out. There’s no reason at all why she couldn’t have said “hey guys, I’ll be with you in just a minute” or something….but I guess since we aren’t regulars it doesn’t matter much. The lack of response by ownership on previous poor reviews tells me that they possibly don’t care much either….especially since all the poor reviews carry almost the exact same theme.
NOTE: It was NOT busy at all. Maybe 7 people at the bar and 3-4 tables seated and already served. Nothing compared to how we’ve seen it before; to the point where I would say that this lack of service is inexcusable on every level. If the owners read this and want to look at camera footage so you know I’m not just saying something negative for the hell of it, here are the details for you.
Thursday 09 Oct 2025
Some time between 8-8:20pm
Far corner of the bar (black hoodie/ball cap and older gentleman in red/white flannel shirt).
Hopefully tourist season treats this place well because fall and winter may become pretty dry if service like this continues. As a local business owner in a customer service driven field, service like this really chaps my ass. If we ever go back and have a totally different experience I’ll be more than happy to change my review.
… moreNope! Finding a game on the TV right in front of us, cleaning off popcorn baskets from a couple empty seats, talking to regulars, and folding some silverware were all way more important than asking what we wanted to drink. But hey, at least she said hi after completely ignoring us for a couple minutes I guess. We finally walked out. There’s no reason at all why she couldn’t have said “hey guys, I’ll be with you in just a minute” or something….but I guess since we aren’t regulars it doesn’t matter much. The lack of response by ownership on previous poor reviews tells me that they possibly don’t care much either….especially since all the poor reviews carry almost the exact same theme.
NOTE: It was NOT busy at all. Maybe 7 people at the bar and 3-4 tables seated and already served. Nothing compared to how we’ve seen it before; to the point where I would say that this lack of service is inexcusable on every level. If the owners read this and want to look at camera footage so you know I’m not just saying something negative for the hell of it, here are the details for you.
Thursday 09 Oct 2025
Some time between 8-8:20pm
Far corner of the bar (black hoodie/ball cap and older gentleman in red/white flannel shirt).
Hopefully tourist season treats this place well because fall and winter may become pretty dry if service like this continues. As a local business owner in a customer service driven field, service like this really chaps my ass. If we ever go back and have a totally different experience I’ll be more than happy to change my review.
Pistol Pete Luciano
BRING CASH! But boy do I love this place. It’s a locals/biker bar, but they are all super friendly. And the FOOD is really good homemade bar food. Can’t forget Stacey! Great and fun bartender, I’ll be stopping there every time I’m in Naples!!
… moreAmos Fraccica
Woah. We came because we wanted some wings. Was recommended by a local bartender from Engine 14 Brewery.
First off, the sweetheart bar tender was super accomodating. My bro asked the bar tender if he could sample the wing sauce. Without hesitation, she brought out a little to check out. It was good.
Plenty of beer choices.
We went with the killer wing sauce. Oh my goodness. It was hot as hell but also had a ton of flavor and didn’t set your mouth on fire. The wings were crispy. They didn’t drown the wings in sauce like some places.
My sister got cauliflower something and boneless wings.
Strongly thinking about making the 2 hour trek again to get these wings again. Wow.
… moreFirst off, the sweetheart bar tender was super accomodating. My bro asked the bar tender if he could sample the wing sauce. Without hesitation, she brought out a little to check out. It was good.
Plenty of beer choices.
We went with the killer wing sauce. Oh my goodness. It was hot as hell but also had a ton of flavor and didn’t set your mouth on fire. The wings were crispy. They didn’t drown the wings in sauce like some places.
My sister got cauliflower something and boneless wings.
Strongly thinking about making the 2 hour trek again to get these wings again. Wow.
Judi Stryker
Great place to gather with friends and family. Or to just grab a cold one on your way. Stop by for a good time. The food is always delicious .
… moreThailmun Hunt
Went to middle town for first time, food was good. Place looked good and people are friendly. I enjoyed it.
… moreDrake Hance
Would give 0 stars if i could, never had an experience like this. Came in at 4pm and sat down at a table directly infront of the bar where all waiters could see me clearly. Passed the 1 menu at the table back and forth till we knew what we wanted to order. After 20 minuites of not being acknowledged or spoken to for drinks or anything as if we where ghosts we decided to give our buisness to the redwood restraunt down the road 1 minuite and got great service and good food immediatly! Wouldnt try this place again.
… moreTravis Mabee
Good but not correct based off what i ordered and was never told I had to put my own condiments on the burgers
… more