Social Profile: 
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2428 Willow Street Pike, Willow Street, PA 17584
Phone: (717) 435-9696
Website: https://www.micksallamericanpub.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Home – Mick’s All American Pub – Pub in PA
Mick’s is a family-friendly pub with a sports focus. Full bar with great draft rotation and specialty cocktails. We are known for our wings, sandwiches, & …
Willow Street – Mick’s All American Pub – Pub in PA
Menu for Mick’s All American Pub in Mount Joy, PA. Explore latest menu with photos and reviews.
Mick’s All American Pub, Willow Valley | Lancaster PA – Facebook
. $$$. . Open now. . 2428 Willow Street Pike, Lancaster, PA, United States, 17603. Links. . micksallamericanpub.com. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in · …
Last Updates
Reviews
Jordan Breeden
We stopped in here today on a whim. We are from Maryland, drove the two hours to only have our plans fall through last minute. We stopped at the CVS around the corner and decided we would stop in to Mick’s for something to eat. We were greeted by a friendly hostess, got a table for two immediately, and then got to figuring out what to order. Fried pickles were an obvious starter… and their house sauce they are served with is fantastic. I saw a picture of the chicken tenders on the website and they looked so good. My boyfriend got the Ruby… a monster of a sandwich, a burger between two bacon tomato grilled cheeses. Somehow he tackled the whole sandwich. We got the limoncello cake to go which I know is not going to make it very far down the road. If you haven’t been to Mick’s you’ve gotta go! We cannot sing our praises enough!!
… moreKaitlynn Blyth
Omg we were so pleasantly surprised and will be back! We traveled in from NYC and stayed at the Doubletree nearby, and to be honest originally went here because it was close and open late.
The shrimp basket hands down was the best I’ve ever had: great quality seafood and delicious breading. The mozzarella sticks were slamming and we had to order another basket. The guava passion fruit margarita was amazing (and I’m a bit of a cocktail snob). My husband said the burger was great and my kids loved the a la carte style kids menu. The salted caramel dessert was amazing too!
The waiter was so sweet. My toddler ordered one drink, and in typical toddler fashion, decided he suddenly hated that drink and “didn’t order it” (even though he did), and the waiter was a great sport about it and asked on the spot what drink he wanted instead.
… moreThe shrimp basket hands down was the best I’ve ever had: great quality seafood and delicious breading. The mozzarella sticks were slamming and we had to order another basket. The guava passion fruit margarita was amazing (and I’m a bit of a cocktail snob). My husband said the burger was great and my kids loved the a la carte style kids menu. The salted caramel dessert was amazing too!
The waiter was so sweet. My toddler ordered one drink, and in typical toddler fashion, decided he suddenly hated that drink and “didn’t order it” (even though he did), and the waiter was a great sport about it and asked on the spot what drink he wanted instead.
Nelson Winter
The food is reasonably price and has large portions. The area is beautiful, the interior is inviting with a nice bar and TVs for watching whatever sports is on during your visit. We will be back again.
… moreDennis Regitz
We had a wonderful time with our friends. The service was fantastic. The food was really good. It was hot and came out as expected. I believe every person in our group really enjoyed their meal. The background music was in the background so we could hear each other but loud enough to enjoy it.
The atmosphere was one of community.
… moreThe atmosphere was one of community.
Curt G
01/23/26 update: First time back in quite a while. Wings were some of the best I’ve had in a long time. Cooked well and crispy with great sauce flavor and proportion. Bumped up the star rating. Still good service as well.
Friendly service and good atmosphere. Just need to get get some decent IPAs on tap. Troegs Perpetual should be a staple.
… moreFriendly service and good atmosphere. Just need to get get some decent IPAs on tap. Troegs Perpetual should be a staple.
Michael Brendle
Server was nice. However, apoetizer came just after the entrees. Judging by the quality of the appetizer, she must have forgotten about it, as it definitely had to been sitting in the pass thru.. our entrees were ok, they looked great, but the recipes not to our tastes or liking. That would be on us, . Atmosphere was good. Not likely to go back, but its because its not my style. Im sure others will love it
… moreM E
The bartender was nice and helpful, and the service was good. The pizza was OK, but could have been a little less garlicky. The locals were friendly. It was trivia night, which drew a crowd, but they left as soon as it was over. I’d come here again.
… moreKelcie Gebhard
The staff at Micks were super accommodating for our large party that we called ahead for, expecially when we needed our table brought from outside to the inside. The food was alright, the usually pub food, but the amber wings were delicious and they were willing to make them extra crispy. We appreciated their flexibility with our large group and the children.
… moreKevin & Crystal
Greeted as soon as we walked in by a friendly hostess. Server came to our table right away. Drinks came out pretty quickly. Our food was very good and very large portions.
We were surprised how long we waited to get our food. We asked for our soup first and ordered two appetizers for our meal. I got a picture of the soup but by the time the rest of the food came we were so hungry I forgot to snap a picture. The place was empty other than a couple of people at the bar so no clue why we waited so long to get our food.
Other than the wait time, everything was great!
… moreWe were surprised how long we waited to get our food. We asked for our soup first and ordered two appetizers for our meal. I got a picture of the soup but by the time the rest of the food came we were so hungry I forgot to snap a picture. The place was empty other than a couple of people at the bar so no clue why we waited so long to get our food.
Other than the wait time, everything was great!
Ryan Hackel
Variety of food and drink options available, several “pub-style” options. Our food was delicious with decent portion sizes as well.
Service was wonderful; our server and all of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful.
I very much enjoyed the atmosphere of this restaurant! Beautiful, modern interior with several seating options (high top, low top, large booths for families/groups, bar seating) available. Covered, outdoor patio seating is also available, which includes a very nice view of the nearby pond with an island and walking paths surrounding.
… moreService was wonderful; our server and all of the staff we interacted with were friendly and helpful.
I very much enjoyed the atmosphere of this restaurant! Beautiful, modern interior with several seating options (high top, low top, large booths for families/groups, bar seating) available. Covered, outdoor patio seating is also available, which includes a very nice view of the nearby pond with an island and walking paths surrounding.