Maria’s Pizza & Subs

  4.4 – 346 reviews  $ • Pizza restaurant

Social Profile:

If you’re looking for the absolute best pizza and Italian food in MilltownNJ – made with only the freshest ingredients available, look no further; Maria’s Pizza is your place for amazing Pizza & Italian food. We offer Online Ordering as well as fast and fresh delivery.

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery Maria's Pizza & Subs 08850


Sunday11 AM–10 PM
(Labor Day)
11 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
Tuesday11 AM–10 PM
Wednesday11 AM–10 PM
Thursday11 AM–10 PM
Friday11 AM–10 PM
Saturday11 AM–10 PM

Address and Contact Information

Address: 119 N Main St, Milltown, NJ 08850

Phone: (732) 214-0033



Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Marias Pizza & Subs Milltown, NJ Pizzeria

Order Online · Save 5% · Instantly! · (click here to order) · Voted One of the Best · 2018, 2019, & 2020! · Thank you ! · Order Online.

Menu | mariaspizzamilltown

top of page. Home · Menu · Gallery · Our Story · *NEW* Order Online · Specials & Discounts · Contact us · My Account …

Maria’s Pizza & Subs | Milltown NJ – Facebook

Maria’s Pizza & Subs, Milltown, New Jersey. 2319 likes · 67 talking about this · 373 were here. Family owned & operated since 1987, Maria’s pizza has…


Stopped for a plain pie for an early Friday dinner. Service was great, 10 minute wait for a pie there. Pie was good, a little to much cheese for me. If your looking for a pizza place in an around New Brunswick, Maria’s is it.
… more
Mark Hoff
Great place. Great people
… more
Scott Harrigan
It takes love and passion to make a great pizza and this place has it in spades. Talk about an amazing pizza. Had both a slice plain and an “upside down” pizza that my buddy Uncle Eddie Eats ordered and just the aroma alone pulls you in. Seriously it’s one really good pie.
… more
Stephen Feldman
Even during a period of high track I got my pizza quickly. Hence the high service score. The pizza itself had alot of cheese, so if you are into that good for you. However the cheese was very uneven, probably having to do with how quickly the pizza was made. Overall, tasty pizza, just not my thing.
… more
David Bell (Realtor)
Dave Portnoy was right! Stopped in for a couple slices for lunch. The traditional pizza is fantastic. Perfect amount of cheese and great sauce flavor. The crust has a nice flour dust which I’m a big fan of. BONUS: for lunch you get a free drink with 2 slices for $4.99. If you’re in central Jersey, you must give Maria’s a try.
… more
Jules Mac
Had a work event in North Brunswick & they provided pizza from Maria’s. It was so good when I went back the 2nd day I ordered & picked up to bring home to Newark. I will stop here anytime I’m in the area.
… more
Gin A
Today I picked up a party package from Maria’s and I have to say that I couldn’t have been more satisfied. Every dish was fresh and delicious. I appreciated that it wasn’t salty which is something that happens often when I order out. We had never tried their food or pizza and I honestly was afraid because I couldn’t find any reviews online about their party package. I went to Milltown to was order a couple of trays from the business across the street and found out when I went there that they had just gone out of business, I saw Maria’s and decided to give them a try as we were celebrating my daughter’s bday and was having 12 college kids at our house. Everyone loved everything and asked me to give them some food to take home. There was plenty so they all left happy. This was our first, but definitely not the last time we’ll order from here.
… more
Darlene MsDove
Such a great restaurant, super friendly staff, awesome food that is consistently great. Love their bar pies, and they have great choices for pizza. Chicken Francese and Marsala are also super dishes. This is on our rotation for restaurants when not cooking!
… more
Brandon Ross
Thank you Camillo and staff for a wonderful experience! Great guy to talk to, the grandma pizza is amazing too. My girlfriend and I stopped in last night after bowling because we saw the Prez (Dave Portnoy) rated them so high. We understand why. Camillo and I instantly bonded over New Haven pizza as that’s where I went to school. Great service and food. we will be back to try the other pies they have! Thanks Camillo!
… more
Joe Scaturro
Spicy Nonna – one of the best I’ve had in my 60 trips around the sun.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment