Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
IL CASTELLOS PIZZERIA e RISTORANTE: Home
Online ordering menu for IL CASTELLOS PIZZERIA e RISTORANTE. Il Castello Pizzeria e Ristorante, located at 3438 NY-97 in Barryville, New York, …
Castellos Pizzeria & Bistro | Barryville NY – Facebook
Castellos Pizzeria & Bistro updated their status. Dec 23, 2025 . . Christmas Eve Hours – Il Castello Pizzeria & Bistro Please note that on …
Il Castello Barryville – PoconoGo
Il Castello Barryville makes a traditional NY Pizzeria Menu. This is as old style as it gets. Many specialty pies are available. Calzone, seafood, veal, …
Reviews
Anthony Ritter
Great restaurant.
My wife and I have been coming to Il Castello for over thirty fiver years (when it was near the river) and the food and service are wonderful. Estupendo y delicioso! Delicious pizza with superb crust, hot melted mozzerella cheese and a tangy tomato sauce. Accompany that pie with a crunchy ceasar salad and top it off with a cheesecake with whipped cream and raspberry drizzle…and you are in heaven! EN PARADISO! Thank you Peter and family. Il buon gusto!
… moreMy wife and I have been coming to Il Castello for over thirty fiver years (when it was near the river) and the food and service are wonderful. Estupendo y delicioso! Delicious pizza with superb crust, hot melted mozzerella cheese and a tangy tomato sauce. Accompany that pie with a crunchy ceasar salad and top it off with a cheesecake with whipped cream and raspberry drizzle…and you are in heaven! EN PARADISO! Thank you Peter and family. Il buon gusto!
J Pepi
My wife and I had an awesome meal at a reasonable price. The portions were big and the food was prepared with care. I had the chicken parmigiana and you could tel that the chicken was fried fresh to order, so it was soft and juicy. It was not precooked and then just sauced and reheated like at other restaurants. The red sauce was a little spicy , but very good. The restaurant was very busy with both take out and sit down orders, but the wait for food was not unreasonable. They have a small salad bar that is included with your meal when you order an entrée. There were a good amount of choices and 4 different dressings to choose from. I will definitely return if I am in the area again. If you are in this area stop by you won’t be disappointed.
… moreSvenja Bonanza
We love love love this place. Best pizza within 25 miles. The desserts are also absolutely amazing. Sometimes the wait can be a little long and the salad bar could have a few more options. Overall our favorite pizza place still.
… moreJeff Brown
Loved it the first time. Excellent red sauce (gravy). Im from NYC. I work in kitchens for 30yrs in Manhattan. The second time I ordered spaghetti and clam sauce. Pasta was way over cooked almost to mush, swimming in oil. I couldnt even eat it. I dont send food back, it should have never left the kitchen. The waiter gave us a jar of grated cheese covered in mold spots you could see from across the room.
Very disappointed.
… moreVery disappointed.
Maxx Ammo
Excellent pizza but both my wife and I felt we got ‘the look’ that says, you’re not from around here are you? Not sure where that’s coming from but it’s not a welcoming feeling. Again food was great and fast service. While eating I was somewhat irritated by Pandora which was not the paid service – so between each Christmas song we had loud McDonald’s commercials or holiday shopping commercials at various retailers. This negativity impacts the Atmosphere rating. Why let McDonald’s advertise their junk food in your establishment? Pay for Pandora or play a CD.
… moreTiffany Diao
I just want to thank you guys for making my friend’s birthday special when another pizza place dropped the ball.
Kelly and Peter, thank you for your above and beyond service, kindness, understanding, and care for the situation.
I know that all of us really appreciated your gestures!
From,
The people from NJ, CT, NY
… moreKelly and Peter, thank you for your above and beyond service, kindness, understanding, and care for the situation.
I know that all of us really appreciated your gestures!
From,
The people from NJ, CT, NY
Jake Allen
My son said it was the best lasagna he’s ever had. The lobster ravioli is fine but nothing special and the zuppa di pesce was pretty good. Overall the prices were a lot higher than expected
… moreTitus
The food was exceptional. Everyone working there was very nice… I was treated like I was a long standing customer, even though it was my first time there.
… moreJohn Arehart
Pizza places usually make good cheesesteaks. The one I had here was one of the best cheesesteaks I’ve ever had in my life… and it was huge. I ate the whole thing and barely touched my cheese fries because I was stuffed! I’ll have to go back and try the pizza some time, if I’m not at the cardiologist haha.
… moreGeorge Kumburis
I love this place it was my wife’s birthday tonight and we have been going here for a very long time this place never disappoints
… more