Social Profile: 
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
… View more
Family owned pizzeria with Italian entrees. Homemade dough, sauces, entrees and desserts. Offers over 18 different varieties of specialty pizzas and over 12 different homemade Italian entrees. Our menu had fresh salads, wings, subs and desserts. We also offer catering. Fast casual. Outdoor seating and parking available.
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday (Labor Day) | 10 AM–9 PM Holiday hours |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2645 SW 91st St, Gainesville, FL 32608
Phone: (352) 333-6185
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
I Love NY Pizza – Gainesville – Menu & Hours – Order Delivery
View the menu, hours, address, and photos for I Love NY Pizza in Gainesville, FL. Order online for delivery or pickup on Slicelife.com.
I Love NY Pizza (Gainesville Fl) – Facebook
I Love NY Pizza (Gainesville Fl), Gainesville, Florida. 1729 likes · 2 talking about this · 1074 were here. We’re bringing the flavors of New York City…
I Love NY Pizza Menu: Pizza Delivery Gainesville, FL – Order
I Love NY Pizza is located at 2645 SW 91st St, Gainesville, FL 32608. What are the hours for I Love NY Pizza? Answer: I Love NY Pizza is open every day of the …
Product
Reviews
Melissa Narum
We ordered delivery a few weeks ago at work. We ordered over the phone and the service was great. The pizza was a huge hit and disappeared quickly. Highly recommend the pepperoni rolls and the Roma pizza!! We will definitely order from here again
… moreJose Torruellas
This place offers single slices which was a surprise to me since I ordered online. The place was clean and most importantly the food was great. You know it’s good pizza when you can’t find parking nearby and have to park in the back of the plaza but it’s worth it. I had the wall street pizza XL and I would say the pizza was an 8.1/10. It’s probably one of the best if not the best place in town to get some pizza. It’s a little pricey but worth it. My only issue was that the center of the pizza was soggy and floppy. I recommend this place.
… morejustin thomas
Every time I have gone, the food has been excellent. I do my order online it’s ready on time. Unlike other places one time they didn’t have something I had ordered on my Pizza they gave me a call asked if there was anything else. I would like and applied it toward the tip for me. Most places won’t even call they’ll just do whatever they want which ticks me off this place is amazing five stars no doubt
… moreJonathan Adcock
I hate to even post this, I’ve enjoyed many lunches at this restaurant, but recently learned ownership changed. How I learned is where the issue was created. We had a $25 gift certificate from the restaurant. We ordered dinner and when we went to pay, we were told that the certificate wouldn’t be honored due to ownership change. Nowhere on the certificate did it list restrictions or disclaimers. However the new owner has decided that loyal customers that have gift cards aren’t valuable. I think this is a poor marketing decision on their part. Sad, as I enjoyed the pizza and garlic bread from there, but hard to support a business that won’t honor the commitments of the business. The previous owner should have disclosed how what was outstanding in gift cards, this shouldn’t be a surprise to new ownership. But, it’s a clear sign that they don’t want to retain customers.
… moreTommie Harris
People People this is nasty Meatball sub n fries Subway is better n Piesanos Pizza is a 1000% better believe me I paid 16.66 for nothing wasted my time n money
… moreJennifer Lohr
I LOVE ny Pizza! I have loved this place for 13 years, I worked there as a teenager and fell in LOVE with their Penne ala Vodka. It may be the best I’ve ever had. It is rich and creamy and so flavorful. Please try it. The chix, bacon ranch pizza is also really good. Some of my favorites have come and gone, if they’re ever doing their bruschetta pizza, (specialty item not typically sold) try it!!! Antonio the entree chef has been there for decades and is so great, stays late making FRESH dough every night (if things haven’t changed). The fresh ingredients that go into the food are evident in what you eat. Honestly I think the salads and entrees are the unsung hero’s of this place, oh and there calzones are worth trying if you haven’t.
… moreMRS. RRC
Yesterday 5/2/23 was the first time my husband and I had I love my pizza since moving to Florida and I gotta say this has been the best pizza by far we’ve had. We moved from Massachusetts where there is a few places with great pizza and we tried a lot of places down here in Gainesville Pisano’s is good but this place takes the cake. The only bummer is they don’t deliver to where we live and that is totally ok it is definitely worth the 20 min drive they show you the pizza to make sure it is to your liking the crust is cooked just right and the sauce is not heavy and acidic like some places are we can’t wait to try there sandwiches if you haven’t tried i love my pizza yet you need to go toy it because id say your missing out on some great pizza. So happy we found this place.
… moreZia Khan
I am a huge fan of the pizzas and pastas this place offers. Today, I tried the new arrival “butter chicken pizza”, and I loved it. The rich juicy flavor of the sauce makes the bite melt in the mouth. A little bit of spice sprinkle makes it even more delicious.
… moreRyan Buckley
Some of the specialty slices here are among the best you can get in town, they really load them with toppings. Everything that isn’t pizza is pretty disappointing so stick with the restaurant’s namesake.
… morepatricia eplee
Best Cauliflower Crust Pizza you will ever eat! My favorite is the Roma! They cook it perfectly how like it every time and and the staff is very friendly! I like mine well done because I like my crust crunchy!!
… more