A full range of Italian fare, like pasta, pizza, grinders & mains, is offered at this casual spot.
Luly I.
The bread is made in house, all the dishes are flavorful and generous portions. The atmosphere is great, very welcoming, good for either a family outing or a business dinner. The bar area is big, and there’s a tv for game night. Everything is clean and well kept and parking is plentiful. The desserts are a must-try. Nice feature: a separate entrance for pick-up orders than the dining room entrance.
… moreMs. Papa
A+/Superlative food! Tastes like my late grandma’s cooking! Exquisite, immaculate atmosphere, and excellent service! Marinara sauce, meatballs, mashed potatoes, pizza mozzarella, chicken cutlets, are what I order, and food is superb. And the customer service is magnificent! Inside is gorgeous and immaculate. Kudos to Sammy, owner, Sammy’s wife, Amelia, Tony, and all of Fratelli’s!
… moreMilutin Bjelanovic
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ – Fratelis impressed me again! The best food I’ve had in a long time!
I returned to Fratelis once again, and I have to say — they impress me more every single time! The food is extremely tasty, the portions are large and generous, and everything is so fresh and perfectly prepared that you can’t help but want to order more.
The staff at Fratelis is incredibly friendly, fast, and professional. From the moment you walk in, you feel like you’ve arrived at a friend’s place. Every recommendation they give is spot-on, and they always have a smile on their face. Truly outstanding!
The prices at Fratelis are more than affordable for the quality and the amount of food you receive. Nowadays, it’s rare to find a place like this — where the food is fantastic, the people are wonderful, and you simply want to keep coming back.
A warm recommendation to everyone! If you haven’t tried Fratelis yet — you absolutely should. And I will definitely keep coming back again and again, because food and service this good are hard to find.
… moreMichael Stringer
Three of us had a very nice dinner there a couple of weeks ago. Ou
Our 3 different cocktails were all good.
My wife had the lasagna, which is some of the better lasagna we’ve had around. Our friend got a shrimp dish, which was good though smelled a little fishy and my soup and veal scarpariello were very good as well.
Our server was excellent and she was very attentive.
We’ve never been there before I never even knew where the place was but now that we’ve discovered it we’ll Hope be back sometime soon. future.
… moreSalvatore Lombardo
My wife and I have been coming to Fratelli’s in Wallingford for years, and it has never, ever disappointed us. The food is consistently amazing — every meal we’ve had has been fresh, flavorful, and absolutely delicious. You can truly taste the care and quality in everything they serve.
What makes our experiences even more special is Emila, who has been our waitress so many times over the years. She is simply wonderful. She always takes such great care of us, checks in to make sure everything is perfect, and does so with the warmest, sweetest personality. She makes you feel genuinely welcomed and valued as a guest.
Great food, great atmosphere, and exceptional service — especially from Emila. We’ll continue coming back for many more years!
… moreandrea puzio
I came here for dinner with my family and I must say the food is absolutely delicious but it is a little bit smaller than the Milford location. At the time when I went, there was another major party going on just arriving with Quinnipiac university which these women filled up most of the dinning area. I did call ahead of time and put a last minute reservation but still this restaurant needs to expand and have a separate area for parties it is way too small. A lot of people don’t like to sit at the bar area for dinner squeezed into a booth with a noisy party eating buffet style.
… moreMs. Papa
As I’ve said for years, A+/Superlative food and service!!! What a value for high quality food and service. A special shout out of excellence to Sammy and Ameila for their superior customer relations. Food tastes like my Grandma’s, so a shout out to the cooks. My favorite dishes are pizza mozzarella with mashed potatoes, chicken cutlets and mashed potatoes, and pasta and meatballs over marinara. I refer customers, bring family and friends, and celebrate occasions, such as birthdays, at Fratellis. A beautiful, immaculate restaraunt. Free parking in a big parking lot. I dine in and do take out. I continue to highly recommend.
Updated Review: November 2025
… moreSherrie Fairchild
Fratelli’s restaurant on Yale Ave. is an amazing hidden gem in Wallingford. The atmosphere is relaxing and their food is consistently delicious and never disappoints. Staff is so friendly and they treat everyone like family. They also make the best bread and Espresso Martini’s. Give it a try!
… moreEric Najduch
I just went in for a slice of cheese. Asked for it to be extra crispy, and that I wanted to add Parmesan, chili flakes, and a little garlic powder. Got my slice in a bag, asked the dude about the condiments..he said it’s all on there.,.slice was soggy, no parm, no chilli flakes, no garlic powder, its a slice of cheese pizza. Simplest order ever. I still devoured the slice cuz I was starving, but cmon mannn. Smh
… moreScott Durso
Pizza was amazing! The pizzeria is tucked away in the sliders parking lot. Have heard a lot of good things about their pie…and everyone was right very great spot for Wallingford! 100% worth a try! My order was a bacon hot pepper pizza. Plenty of toppings great crust and a nice firm slice. Had to add a slice of cheese for comparison and top-notch pie! fair pricing as well
… more