Doreen Anderson
Visiting family who live in Eleva this is one of their favorites for wood fired specialty pizzas ! We were able to head there during a quieter Saturday after the typical lunch rush.
Easily got a table for 6 – YAY !
Wanting to try a few different pizzas we over ordered but happy to leave with leftovers
We ordered
Meat, Baby !
Aloha
Custom – Prosciutto & fresh basil
Kids cheese on cauliflower crust
I forgot to grab photos the second the pizzas hit the table so photos are after we dug in & grabbed some slices. Ooops
Delicious !
Servers kind & attentive
Kiddos beverages have a bendy straw shaped into a heart so cute
The enclosed patio area is now closed for the season – fire place is a nice touch.
… moreDouglas Price
We had Jill as our server. She was absolutely fantastic!! The food was awesome. Wood fired brick oven pizza is in a category all by itself. Please go here and give it a try….you’ll love it.
There is also a respectable bar, cheese outlet and close-out sales on goodies
… moreCasey-Jo Irsik
We moved to Wisconsin in October 2025. We drive 80 miles round trip, once a week, to get a pizza to go. Foster’s pepperoni pizza is awesome! They also have an area to buy fudge, salsa, pita chips and cheese.
… moreJill Lucas
We stopped for lunch, Zoe was a delight! Absolutely delicious! We enjoyed wood fired pizza and flatbread! And found some yummy cheese to take home!
… moreRick West
The only negative thing I have to say about this place is one time I had to wait 15 minutes to get a table-because there was a line of people waiting to get in! IT’S THAT GOOD! The pizzas are amazing, matched with a great selection for your desired taste. The staff are cordial and represent our area well with their small town charm. If you sit in the back by the wood fired oven, you get to enjoy the radiant heat and watch your pizza cook.
… moreLacie K
We saw their “Cheese” sign from the highway and decided to stop. I’m so glad we did! A restaurant with inside and outside seating, ciders, a full bar, a mini cheese cooler and wood fire pizza. Everything we tried was delicious! The waitresses were informative, polite and let me sample the ciders.
… moreAbby Davis
This place is great! Only wish there was a smaller size that was normal crust, but I’m ok with splitting or just ordering a gluten free crust! Me and the family stop here any time we’re passing through, and I cannot recommend it enough.
… moreJessica Bee
Our server Brogan was top notch! The everything but the kitchen sink pizza and Aloha pizza were full of flavor, the fireside pretzel with cheese sauce was incredible and so delicious. I had the chocolate peanut butter cake for dessert. Yum
… moreMichelle Hairston
Foster’s Fireside Pizza is a must-visit for pizza lovers! The inviting atmosphere, enhanced by the warm glow of the wood-fired oven, sets the perfect backdrop for a delightful meal. The staff here is exceptional—friendly, knowledgeable, and genuinely passionate about providing a top-notch dining experience.
I was pleasantly surprised by their Big Mac pizza, which quickly became my favorite. This unique creation captures all the flavors of a classic Big Mac on a crispy, wood-fired crust. Each bite is a delicious blend of seasoned beef, melted cheese, pickles, lettuce, and special sauce.
If you’re looking for great food and an amazing vibe, don’t miss out on Foster’s Fireside Pizza It’s a culinary gem that will leave you craving more!
… moreSJ Albee
Last-minute dinner stop tonight, and it was fantastic! The boys had the Holiday Sweet Heat” not too spicy, just a little heat and absolutely loved it. We shared a salad and a pizza, both of which were delicious. Our server was amazing—so friendly, engaging, and attentive. The atmosphere was wonderful and full of Christmas spirit. Such a great experience, and we will definitely be back!
… more