Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in
… View more
Stately, white-tablecloth restaurant for classic surf ‘n’ turf, plus game such as venison & buffalo.
Hours
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1108 Main St, Fishkill, NY 12524
Phone: (845) 897-3300
Website: http://fishkillprime.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fishkill Prime Restaurant – OpenTable
Fishkill Prime offers a delightful dining experience with “fresh, fresh, fresh” seafood, steaks, and desserts. Diners rave about the “excellent service” and ” …
Fishkill Prime – Fishkill, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery | Seamless
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for Fishkill Prime in Fishkill, plus popular items & reviews.
Fishkill Prime- Land & Sea – Facebook
Restaurant · $$. . Follow. Details. . 2 Reviews. . $$. . 1108 Main Street, Fishkill, NY, United States, 12524. . Fishkill, NY. Links. . fishkillprime.
Reviews
Nicole Alicea
Cozy and warm atmosphere. The food was absolutely delicious and perfectly cooked. Highly recommend this place for a special evening out; birthday, anniversary, Valentine’s Day, etc.
… moreChristian Campos
I was here this Sunday, I set at the bar. The oysters were a standout. Super fresh and incredibly good, hands down some of the best oysters I’ve had.
The atmosphere was welcoming, and the curly haired bartender was awesome!!! So friendly, warm, and genuinely nice. She made the whole experience even better. Fishkill Prime is absolutely worth it. Definitely coming back.
… moreThe atmosphere was welcoming, and the curly haired bartender was awesome!!! So friendly, warm, and genuinely nice. She made the whole experience even better. Fishkill Prime is absolutely worth it. Definitely coming back.
chloe gaer
I wish I could give more than 5 stars. Our server was RJ and he was the best server I have encountered in all my dining experiences. We came here for my boyfriend’s birthday and we all had the best time ever! We appreciate you RJ and all the staff that assisted our table. Dining here is a must! We will be back!
… moreMichael Tischler
Cute restaurant, nice waitstaff, food met expectations but was nothing special for how pricey it was. Service was atrocious, we waited 45+ minutes to order and had to ask (sometimes numerous times) anytime we needed a water refill and when we asked for the check. It was Valentine’s Day so my partner and I gave some slack to the waitress who seemed overwhelmed, but every other party around us was miserable and kind of killed the mood with their bitching about how long they (also) had to wait and because their steaks were not cooked enough. I think one couple sent their steak back 3x. Ours was a little undercooked in some areas (ordered medium) but overall was solid. Probably won’t come back ♂️
… moreAudrey Robles
First time here under Fishkill Prime Land & Sea. I’ve been to this place twice before when they were other restaurants. One thing remains the same, it’s never packed. Interior is nice, this space is large and always feels empty when I come.
Nonetheless service is great. Anthony was very nice and made good recommendations.
We opted with sushi to start since everyone raves about it. It was good however it was also very big, compared to most sushi rolls. I would recommend this.
Dinner was the NY strip and chicken Milanese. The steak was average, lacked flavors that would leave a lasting impact. Good presentation. The chicken Milanese was underwhelming, the chicken itself had no flavor. I was disappointed.
Cheesecake was good.
… moreNonetheless service is great. Anthony was very nice and made good recommendations.
We opted with sushi to start since everyone raves about it. It was good however it was also very big, compared to most sushi rolls. I would recommend this.
Dinner was the NY strip and chicken Milanese. The steak was average, lacked flavors that would leave a lasting impact. Good presentation. The chicken Milanese was underwhelming, the chicken itself had no flavor. I was disappointed.
Cheesecake was good.
Marc Cretara
I recently had the pleasure of dining at this restaurant, and it exceeded all my expectations. From the moment I walked in, I was greeted with warm smiles and attentive service that made me feel genuinely welcome. The ambiance was inviting—perfectly balancing comfort and elegance—making it an ideal spot for both a casual dinner and a special occasion.
The food was absolutely outstanding. Every dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. You can truly taste the freshness and quality of the ingredients in every bite. The menu offers a great variety, ensuring there’s something for everyone, and the portions are generous without being overwhelming. The desserts were the perfect ending to the meal—rich, indulgent, and unforgettable.
What stood out most was the attention to detail, from the carefully crafted dishes to the knowledgeable staff who were happy to make recommendations. It’s clear that the team takes pride in creating a memorable dining experience.
I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for delicious food, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere. I’ll definitely be returning soon!
… moreThe food was absolutely outstanding. Every dish was beautifully presented and bursting with flavor. You can truly taste the freshness and quality of the ingredients in every bite. The menu offers a great variety, ensuring there’s something for everyone, and the portions are generous without being overwhelming. The desserts were the perfect ending to the meal—rich, indulgent, and unforgettable.
What stood out most was the attention to detail, from the carefully crafted dishes to the knowledgeable staff who were happy to make recommendations. It’s clear that the team takes pride in creating a memorable dining experience.
I would highly recommend this restaurant to anyone looking for delicious food, excellent service, and a welcoming atmosphere. I’ll definitely be returning soon!
Dominique Barbella
Exceptional atmosphere! The steak and fries sans truffle oil and salt reminded us of Peter Luger Steakhouse in Great Neck NY! Salad delicious, my husband loved the shrimp cocktail, the lentil soup was perfectly seasoned and even the warm bread was amazing!
Update 8/15/2025
Went a second time. We received old bread. Ordered a cocktail, amaretto sour (tart and disgusting). Waitress insisted we order a different drink. We finally caved and requested a mojito! That was even MORE sour and tart than the first drink!
Male waiter came over and stated that the drinks were made EXACTLY according to the recipe/s…ok. They were still AWFUL! ♀️
We received our salad still delicious! Tried rigatoni pasta alla vodka. Cooked al Dante sauce eh. But tasty. Got the same steak requested same temp medium rare. Fries sans oil and salt! Fries came out with salt and truffle oil. Steak was TERRIBLY Bland and cooked horribly.
Waitress tells us that we never asked for no salt smh. Overall, we suppose some days are better than others for this restaurant.
Additionally, there was NO ONE THERE both times. Two couples came in after we were leaving however. But how can they make such mistakes with so little customers? Lastly 7 pieces of Asparagus for $8 is pretty ridiculous!
… moreUpdate 8/15/2025
Went a second time. We received old bread. Ordered a cocktail, amaretto sour (tart and disgusting). Waitress insisted we order a different drink. We finally caved and requested a mojito! That was even MORE sour and tart than the first drink!
Male waiter came over and stated that the drinks were made EXACTLY according to the recipe/s…ok. They were still AWFUL! ♀️
We received our salad still delicious! Tried rigatoni pasta alla vodka. Cooked al Dante sauce eh. But tasty. Got the same steak requested same temp medium rare. Fries sans oil and salt! Fries came out with salt and truffle oil. Steak was TERRIBLY Bland and cooked horribly.
Waitress tells us that we never asked for no salt smh. Overall, we suppose some days are better than others for this restaurant.
Additionally, there was NO ONE THERE both times. Two couples came in after we were leaving however. But how can they make such mistakes with so little customers? Lastly 7 pieces of Asparagus for $8 is pretty ridiculous!
rosy lynch
I had such an amazing experience at Fishkill Prime! We started with drinks at the bar and they were absolutely perfectly well made, strong, and delicious. The food was just as impressive. Everything came out cooked exactly how we asked, hot, and full of flavor. You can tell they really care about quality here.
The service was outstanding from start to finish; attentive, friendly, and professional without being overbearing. Overall, such a great atmosphere and dining experience. I’ll definitely be back!
… moreThe service was outstanding from start to finish; attentive, friendly, and professional without being overbearing. Overall, such a great atmosphere and dining experience. I’ll definitely be back!
Nicole McCutcheon
We come here 2 times a month because we love the food and the service, usually come with either 4 or party of 12 everytime…. We came Sunday day after Valentine’s Day and have so far had the worst experience yet. Walked in and was told to seat myself, have to go up and get my own menus after waiting 20 minutes for someone to come up to us, to then waiting another 15/20 for someone to take our order. Then it took an hour for us to get our appetizers and waiting even longer to get our main meal that we ordered at the same time. Really disappointed to walk in and see that the gentleman and his wife are no longer here because they really brought amazing customers service and energy to this place, always made sure our food was on point and came out in a timely manner really overall was a great team and brought good energy to the rest of the staff. Our sushi sat on the counter for 20 minutes before it was brought over to us, when we said something to the waiter about it he proceeded to let us know how busy and overwhelmed he is. Had to go up to the bar constantly to get a refill on drinks,Really all around disappointed in the service and the food. Will come back again if I hear they are back
… moreCharmaine Morala
First of all, thank you to Niti B and the other servers who sang happy birthday to my mama. She was really happy.
The service was really good. The place is clean, and they have a parking spot at the back.
We ordered the soup of the day, which was lobster bisque, and OMG it was so good. We had fried calamari, which was good as well. We had the porterhouse for two, which was so good as well. I loved the truffle fries because they were so good, and the asparagus was good as well. Overall, the foods that we ordered were really good.
We ordered dessert, a tiramisu with coffee and it was a good dessert as well. Ohh the bread wa so soft as well
We will come back to this place again when we are in the area.
… moreThe service was really good. The place is clean, and they have a parking spot at the back.
We ordered the soup of the day, which was lobster bisque, and OMG it was so good. We had fried calamari, which was good as well. We had the porterhouse for two, which was so good as well. I loved the truffle fries because they were so good, and the asparagus was good as well. Overall, the foods that we ordered were really good.
We ordered dessert, a tiramisu with coffee and it was a good dessert as well. Ohh the bread wa so soft as well
We will come back to this place again when we are in the area.