Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
This simple, kosher pizzeria with counter service & booths features oven-baked pies & slices.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 250 E Broadway, Monticello, NY 12701
Phone: (845) 794-3420
Website: https://fialkoffskosherpizza.com/
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza | Kosher Pizza Delivered
Catskills, NY · Fialkoff’s Monticello · Fialkoff’s Kiamesha Lake at Gourmet Glatt · Fialkoff’s Four Corners · Fialkoff’s Loch Sheldrake at Fun Spot.
Locations – Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza
Catskills, NY · Fialkoff’s Monticello · Fialkoff’s Kiamesha Lake at Gourmet Glatt · Fialkoff’s Four Corners · Fialkoff’s Loch Sheldrake at Fun Spot.
Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza Monticello – Sauce
Takeout and FREE delivery from Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza Monticello menu in Monticello 12701, no hidden fees and live order tracking. Powered by Sauce.
Reviews
Steve Jesiolowska
If disappointment had a flavor, it would be Fialkoff’s frozen pizza.
Bought this thing at my local Montreal supermarket because the box screamed ‘authentic New York handmade pizza’ — turns out, it was as handmade as a vending machine sandwich.
First of all, $22? For what? A frozen, pre-sliced frisbee? I’ve had better pizza regrets at 2 AM from a gas station in the middle of nowhere.
I had to basically cremate it in my oven to make it remotely edible. The only thing ‘original’ about this pizza was the new form of sadness it introduced to my tastebuds.
Imagine taking a piece of cardboard, sprinkling it with Dollar Store cheese dust, and then praying for a miracle. That’s this pizza.
If you’re in Montreal and thinking of buying this, just grab a snowball, sprinkle some ketchup and grated rubber tire shavings on it — same taste, less heartbreak, 100% cheaper.
Save yourself. Save your family. Save your oven from the smell of regret. Avoid at all costs.
… moreBought this thing at my local Montreal supermarket because the box screamed ‘authentic New York handmade pizza’ — turns out, it was as handmade as a vending machine sandwich.
First of all, $22? For what? A frozen, pre-sliced frisbee? I’ve had better pizza regrets at 2 AM from a gas station in the middle of nowhere.
I had to basically cremate it in my oven to make it remotely edible. The only thing ‘original’ about this pizza was the new form of sadness it introduced to my tastebuds.
Imagine taking a piece of cardboard, sprinkling it with Dollar Store cheese dust, and then praying for a miracle. That’s this pizza.
If you’re in Montreal and thinking of buying this, just grab a snowball, sprinkle some ketchup and grated rubber tire shavings on it — same taste, less heartbreak, 100% cheaper.
Save yourself. Save your family. Save your oven from the smell of regret. Avoid at all costs.
N.Y. Rep.
Pizza is amazing.
The sauce is very well spiced and very tasty.
The dough is crispy and thin.
Killer combination.
… moreThe sauce is very well spiced and very tasty.
The dough is crispy and thin.
Killer combination.
Lipa B
Yesterday’s visit was a disaster from start to finish. First off, it was literally hotter inside than outside, like sitting in a sauna. After paying, we waited 45 minutes or more for a minimum order, only to be told after all that waiting and after already paying that the ice cream we ordered wasn’t even available.
The three slices we did get? Honestly, I’d rather not describe how they looked. By then, it wasn’t just us the entire line of customers was upset, everyone trying to cancel, and there was no one around to speak to.
They promised me a refund, but I’m still waiting. Between the heat, the wait, being told things aren’t available only after paying, the poor quality of the food, and the complete lack of customer service. this was one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had.
That said, I really do hope they take this feedback seriously, make the changes needed, and turn this place around — because it has potential to be so much better.
… moreThe three slices we did get? Honestly, I’d rather not describe how they looked. By then, it wasn’t just us the entire line of customers was upset, everyone trying to cancel, and there was no one around to speak to.
They promised me a refund, but I’m still waiting. Between the heat, the wait, being told things aren’t available only after paying, the poor quality of the food, and the complete lack of customer service. this was one of the worst dining experiences I’ve had.
That said, I really do hope they take this feedback seriously, make the changes needed, and turn this place around — because it has potential to be so much better.
Sara Dayan
Delicious pizza and amazing french fries. I hadn’t realized what time they were closing, but the manager was so nice and stayed open late to let us eat. Excellent food and service!
… moreAlex Levitsky
Like everything else when you cut corners the quality goes with it and unfortunately so does your customer base. They think by pre making the pizza hours or a day before and warming it up, it’s fresh pizza. The sauce is dried along with the cheese. It felt like eating leftovers. Regretful.
… moreAron Knopfler
If you would like pizza with a side of diarrhea – or diarrhea with a side of pizza – this is the spot. The pizza here used to be full of flavor without any regrets afterward. But now? Just spicy without much else. And you’ll be lucky to make it home from the Catskills without stopping at every bathroom on the way.
… moreN M
Their pizza is okay— garlic knots are not good. I asked for Parmesan cheese to go on our pizza and the guy behind the counter said he didn’t think they had that. ♀️ They don’t adhere to masks so most of the customers don’t wear masks either. We went on a Saturday and the place was packed and an absolute mess. Customers left their empty pizza boxes and plates all over the table as if there is table service. Kids were running all over the place and none of the staff even cared to tell them anything. I’ll give them 2 stars for their pizza — it wasn’t bad. They also only take cash FYI. The low rating is for their lack of consideration for other humans during a pandemic.. the regular customers make it an unsafe experience.
… moreMoshe Rapoport
Great place to get pizza and fries. The pizza sauce was delicious, and the pizza crust was just right.
Very friendly staff, and the place was clean.
Would have given 5 stars, but the service could be quicker (though very nice people behind the counter) and the selection is limited.
… moreVery friendly staff, and the place was clean.
Would have given 5 stars, but the service could be quicker (though very nice people behind the counter) and the selection is limited.
mendel farkas
Dirty there was no one going around cleaning tables I had to clean a table so I could sit and they gave old pizza reheated French fries
Recommendation for the owner please read the all the post and clean the place and get nice staff because ur pizza is delicious when it’s fresh
… moreRecommendation for the owner please read the all the post and clean the place and get nice staff because ur pizza is delicious when it’s fresh
Susan Odinsky
So disappointed in their delivery service. Unable to call me when they deliver food thus me and my grandchildren eating cold pizza fries and knish. Very unhappy with no plate nor utensils. Don’t order online
… more