Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Casual Italian restaurant offering homemade, thin-crust pies plus subs & pasta dishes since 1957.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1821 Calumet Dr, Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 458-4171
Website: https://www.fayespizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: alohaorderonline.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Faye’s Pizza | Restaurant | Sheboygan, WI
Since 1957, Faye’s Pizza has been making pizza the traditional way. We have not changed the way that we offer a unique taste from a unique place.
Faye’s Pizza | Sheboygan WI – Facebook
Since 1957 Faye’s Pizza has been making pizza the traditional way. We haven’t changed our ways since! Thin crust pizza to specialty sandwiches, to frozen …
Faye’s Pizza is Poised to Expand | 1330 & 101.5 WHBL
… Faye’s Pizza . … Listen. 1330 AM in Sheboygan, WI; 101.5 FM in Sheboygan, WI; Listen on …
Reviews
Shannon Goebel
New to the area and told by MANY people to try Fayes. Delivery was fast, pizza was hot and fresh and the cracker crust was amazing. Five stars all the way around.
… moreTj Schultze
The thin crust pizza was great, ordered sausage pepperoni and cheese bread-cheese bread order is quite big and very good but one of the better thin pizzas I’ve had
… moreDriftlessdude
Yummy!
We ordered Hawaiian pizza with individual side salads and everything was delicious. Service was fast and staff was kind. What more could you ask for? Can’t wait to go back again!
… moreWe ordered Hawaiian pizza with individual side salads and everything was delicious. Service was fast and staff was kind. What more could you ask for? Can’t wait to go back again!
Yo Momma
Usually very good but I’ve ordered twice in the last month both times were issues..it’s not as good anymore or it’s the service considering your hiring all kids ..first pizza was pepperoni w bacon , bacon was all FAT or raw !!! It was disgusting not even edible I had to pick it off and eat what I could which was half my pizza if not more wasted so I thought well I’ll try again never had such issues before so we ordered again on the online app u have , pizza came ICE COLD!u can’t tell whoever made it was not happy with the tip so when he delivered it he made sure to thank my husband for the” tip” specifically..we don’t live far so no excuse for a cold pizza and I’m not paying and arm n leg on top of the already existing delivery fee won’t be ordering in the future !
… moreKenneth Keeling
This place used to be very good, one of my favorites. Now it it is GARBAGE. The service is poor, and the pizza’s quality is terrible. Had a large sausage pizza, we could count the number of bland sausage pieces with one hand, probaly on purpose so next time we would order extra and be upcharged for what used to be a normal amount (shrinkflation). But there will not be a next time.
… moreM Allan
This is one of my favorite pizza places in Wisconsin. I’ve probably had pizza from 50-70 restaurants and pubs across the state over the last 25-30 years. Faye’s is a timeless classic, that has remained unchanged since 1999, when I first moved to Sheboygan Co. We ordered Faye’s as a delivery to the Kohler Co, often. I always appreciated the quality ingredients, thick crust, ample cheese, and great service/ delivery.
Now fast-forward 26 years later, and I find myself 4 counties away from Sheboygan Co. I always try to fit in a visit to the restaurant when I make a Sheboygan Co run for other shopping or business. It’s as good today as I remember it was a quarter century ago!.
I’m so glad this place is still serving the Sheboygan area. We just visited them again today, and we were as happy as ever with the food and service. This place is a gem of a restaurant in Sheboygan!
You can’t go wrong with Faye’s Pizza!
Enjoy!!!
… moreNow fast-forward 26 years later, and I find myself 4 counties away from Sheboygan Co. I always try to fit in a visit to the restaurant when I make a Sheboygan Co run for other shopping or business. It’s as good today as I remember it was a quarter century ago!.
I’m so glad this place is still serving the Sheboygan area. We just visited them again today, and we were as happy as ever with the food and service. This place is a gem of a restaurant in Sheboygan!
You can’t go wrong with Faye’s Pizza!
Enjoy!!!
Veronica Bonin
Our pizza was delicious! We had a pepperoni, sausage & mushroom pizza tonight. While it is always tasty, it was just exceptional tonight! Thanks, Faye’s!!!
… moreMistahZ
I’ve seen Fayes advertised as one of the better pizza places around and while it isn’t the best I’d say it’s good overall! The building is nice inside and out, spacious and clean albeit with a somewhat AWKWARD parking lot to navigate. Service was good and patient, no problem there. The food was good, from the mozzarella sticks to the mini tacos and the pizza, it wasn’t the best I’ve had but it was still tasty. My ONLY complaint is they switched up my pizza as it was a normal one and not a deep dish but it was alright in the end! Try Fayes out but if you’re getting a takeout pizza, check it first to be safe!
Pictures are the outside and inside of the building and food!
… morePictures are the outside and inside of the building and food!
B Roeck
By far best pizza around! We have had Deep Dish and Traditional both were AMAZING! Garlic and Garlic Cheese Bread are delicious! Staff is always friendly and helpful! Owner came out to the tables to check on food and service, the over climate and culture of the establishment is top notch!
… moreTyler Martin
Thin cheese and sausage and fried zucchini was legit!! Lil tooo much red peppers i put on myself but hey. It still LEGIT! Good sauce and cheese taste…
… more