Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2151 Eagle Dr, Pagosa Springs, CO 81147
Phone: (970) 398-2409
Website: https://cityhallcafe.co/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
City Hall Cafe and Grille – Restaurant – Pagosa Springs, Colorado
City Hall Cafe serving lunch and dinner daily offering Prime Steaks, Seafood, Pasta Dishes and Salads, Dine indoors or outdoors.
City Hall Cafe & Grille | Pagosa Springs CO – Facebook
City Hall Cafe & Grille, Pagosa Springs. 963 likes · 5 talking about this · 945 were here. Restaurant.
City Hall Café & Grill – Pagosa Springs – MapQuest
City Hall Café & Grill is a popular dining destination in Pagosa Springs, Colorado, offering a diverse menu that features prime steaks and daily specials.
Reviews
Jade Tattersall
Rather disappointing after reading reviews. Service was lacking and long wait times for lukewarm food. Crab cakes weren’t terrible but they were cold to lukewarm. My Caesar salad didnt have cheese and was so lightly dressed I barely tasted any flavor (look at the pic its just limp lettuce) and they hyped the seafood stuffed shells up so much I was looking forward to a redemption and after waiting close to 40 mins after we were done with our appetizer a lukewarm salty dish came out. I was only able to eat one shell it was too salty. Said all of this to a passing waiter as ours came so infrequently. She said thanks for the feedback and that was all. No manager ever came to apologize or make anything right.
Im usually a 25% tipper regardless of food quality but the slow service with bad food reflected in my tip.
$100 bill for 2 entrees and an appetizer at a “cafe”.
… moreIm usually a 25% tipper regardless of food quality but the slow service with bad food reflected in my tip.
$100 bill for 2 entrees and an appetizer at a “cafe”.
Suzy Egan (Suzy Q)
Some of the most delicious food we have had. The calamari was excellent! So tender and tasty. My eggplant stack was delicious and enough for a meal. We showed up right before closing.. they still sat us and served us amazing food( can’t wait to eat the leftovers!). The staff is knowledgeable and our server was super nice. We highly recommend this place to eat a lovely upscale meal! Don’t forget the drinks and appetizers!
… moreSarah Frederick
The crab cakes were truly amazing—perfectly seasoned, tender inside, and beautifully crisp on the outside. You can taste the freshness in every bite. The chicken margarita was just as impressive: juicy, flavorful, and paired with a bright, zesty sauce that really brought the dish together. Both plates were memorable and definitely worth ordering again. Very impressed ❤️
… moreOmar Yanar
I love this place. Let’s start with the paradox of the eggplant tower. You’re thinking to yourself, that’s weird, maybe I should pick something I recognize. Don’t!
It’s literally a mountain of happiness and joy that will exude unicorns and rainbows upon the first bite. Not lying, I told our wonderful server this verbatim to describe how much we loved the tower.
The lamb chops were some of the best prepared I’ve ever had. Truly. I eat a lot of lamb; I’m half Lebanese. Wow, they were extraordinary with a unique taste you’re not going to get anywhere else.
The steak was also amazing. Here’s the thing: it was really, really good, but the lamb chops were so extraordinary that this amazing steak took a back seat. Order both and share. You’ll be glad.
We loved the staff! They were so cool, fun, outgoing, kind, thoughtful, and made amazing food into such a fun and amazing experience. They were so kind at the end that they provided their famous key lime pie (also super delicious) to us, which rounded out a perfect dinner.
Rarely does a place delight me so, please come here often.
… moreIt’s literally a mountain of happiness and joy that will exude unicorns and rainbows upon the first bite. Not lying, I told our wonderful server this verbatim to describe how much we loved the tower.
The lamb chops were some of the best prepared I’ve ever had. Truly. I eat a lot of lamb; I’m half Lebanese. Wow, they were extraordinary with a unique taste you’re not going to get anywhere else.
The steak was also amazing. Here’s the thing: it was really, really good, but the lamb chops were so extraordinary that this amazing steak took a back seat. Order both and share. You’ll be glad.
We loved the staff! They were so cool, fun, outgoing, kind, thoughtful, and made amazing food into such a fun and amazing experience. They were so kind at the end that they provided their famous key lime pie (also super delicious) to us, which rounded out a perfect dinner.
Rarely does a place delight me so, please come here often.
JJ Thompson
We loved our waitress! She was very bright and attentive, and even turned up the heater on the patio dining area for us! The food came in massive portions, and we thoroughly enjoyed our visit here.
… moreAshley Montoya
Had a great experience over here was our first time coming into town. Only downside is the prices. They are very expensive but overall enjoyed our meal. The black and shrimp was very salty. Couldn’t really enjoy eating it unfortunately but everything else was wonderful. The owner was a lovely lady Atmosphere was great.
… moreJeremy K
Prompt professional, yet friendly service.
Zach and Stephanie truly provided top notch service. The Chicken Piccata was maybe seasoned too heavily and not light and refreshing, however I loved it. I will definitely get that again or even try something else!
The staff, service, and food will be hard to beat at the price anywhere. Top notch.
… moreZach and Stephanie truly provided top notch service. The Chicken Piccata was maybe seasoned too heavily and not light and refreshing, however I loved it. I will definitely get that again or even try something else!
The staff, service, and food will be hard to beat at the price anywhere. Top notch.
Talia Byrne-Haber
The staff here were incredibly kind, but the food here I had was terrible. My coworker and I got the chicken parmesan pasta that we both decided was the worst pasta we have ever had. The chicken was overcooked, dry, and WAY oversalted. The pasta sauce itself tasted bitter as if too many herbs had been put in (not bitter as in a lack of sweet, but something was off). Hopefully this was just a one off, but especially for how expensive it was, I don’t think I’ll be going back. For how good the rest of their reviews were, I was pretty surprised.
… moreMichella Matthews
We had a wonderful experience at City Hall Cafe and Grille! The portion sizes were generous and perfect for a family dinner. Our kids devoured the fettuccine pasta and pizza, and my chicken piccata was outstanding — bright, flavorful, and cooked perfectly. The service was friendly, the atmosphere warm, and the food truly exceeded expectations. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreChad Wright
Don’t let the exterior throw you a
off. It has a dive-bar-ie feel from the outside, but the food was excellent. I had the Delmonico steak which was cooked to perfection. I had some interaction with almost every person working, and all were very friendly. The service was superb. If I’m ever back in town this will be a go-to spot.
… moreoff. It has a dive-bar-ie feel from the outside, but the food was excellent. I had the Delmonico steak which was cooked to perfection. I had some interaction with almost every person working, and all were very friendly. The service was superb. If I’m ever back in town this will be a go-to spot.