Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Located in Mr. Ed’s bar, stop by Put-in-Bay Cameo Pizza for lunch, dinner, or late night treats! Our menu features specialty and custom pizzas, cheesy bread, subs, burgers, meatballs, salads, chicken wings, chicken chunks, fries, bread sticks, and more! Why does our pizza taste so good? It starts with a secret family recipe for our pizza sauce and dough, a recipe perfected in Sandusky, Ohio, for over 62 Years. Our recipes and the freshest ingredients are used every day to make our sauce and dough, and we use only top quality ingredients in our pizza. We use only 100% real cheese on our pizza, vine-ripened tomatoes in our sauce and the best herbs and spices. Come visit us to try our pizza and see for yourself! We also deliver until 2:30am!
Long-running local pizzeria chain serving thin-crust pies & sandwiches in a casual setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 272 Delaware Ave, Put-In-Bay, OH 43456
Phone: (419) 285-4444
Website: https://www.putinbaycameopizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Put-in-Bay Cameo Pizza | Pizza Delivery Put-in-Bay, Ohio
Located inside Mr. Ed’s Bar on Delaware Avenue in downtown Put-in-Bay, Cameo Pizza is your go-to spot for lunch, dinner, or late-night eats.
Cameo Pizza – Put-in-Bay
If you have a craving for pizza and don’t feel like leaving the house, we deliver anywhere on putinbay until 3am daily! The Island Club home rentals, Put-in-Bay …
Put-in-Bay Cameo Pizza Menu | Pizza, Subs & More
THREE CHEESE. 15″ $27 | 12″ $23 | 9″ $20 · CHICKEN DELICACY. 15″ $30 | 12″ $26 | 9″ $21 · CHICKEN ALFREDO. 15″ $30 | 12″ $26 | 9″ $21 · CAMEO SPECIAL. 15″ $30 | 12 …
Last Updates
Reviews
Ashley Mann
My FAVORITE pizza on the island! Great service, great pizza, great location! This is the best late night snack to end your night, or your wedding! I just had to get a pizza to end off the best day ever! Cameo is a must visit spot on your next visit to Put-in-Bay! Be sure to try the pickle bread and add bacon!
… moreJeffery B. Novotny
If you’re visiting the island, Cameo Pizza is one of those stops that just makes sense. It’s inside Mr. Ed’s, with a side window that’s easy to swing by, especially later at night when hunger kicks in.
The pizza is usually hot and ready, which is exactly what you want after a long day or a night out. The hot honey pepperoni pizza is a must—sweet, a little spicy, and different enough to be memorable without trying too hard.
It’s not overhyped or complicated, just a reliable, satisfying slice that ends up being a must-have part of the Put-in-Bay experience.
… moreThe pizza is usually hot and ready, which is exactly what you want after a long day or a night out. The hot honey pepperoni pizza is a must—sweet, a little spicy, and different enough to be memorable without trying too hard.
It’s not overhyped or complicated, just a reliable, satisfying slice that ends up being a must-have part of the Put-in-Bay experience.
Mandy Holverson
Good Pizza, though ours was weirdly cut into long skinny strips. Prices aren’t bad either, and love that they are open late. I do wish they had faster air fryers since they don’t have deep fryers for their other offerings. 40 mins for some nuggets or fries is kind of a bummer when you’re trying to get something quick after a night of partying. Pizzas are fast though! Fries were also unexpectedly tasty. Cheese sticks weren’t great and seemed barely warmed through and were small. Otherwise we had great in-store service and delivery.
… moreTricia Zavala
Had this pizza a couple years ago and thought it was just okay-ish. Saw it was rated 3.8 stars now and wasn’t expecting much but omg this pizza was so good tonight, we got the chipotle chicken and it was delicious! I’m a pizza snob and this was one of the best pizza’s I’ve ever had! Surprised this place currently only has 3.8 stars
… moreRachel
Get a big, hot, sloppy pie to end your night on PIB! We have ended so many night outs with a pepperoni pizza from here. Love the staff, love the pizza ❤️
… moreEden Biofeedback, LLC
FANTASTIC PIZZA! So, so, so good! We ordered delivery and it was delivered much faster than promised so that was a great first impression.
The margherita pizza was exceptional. Vegetarian pizza really needs flavorful sauce and this pizza delivered. The salad was wonderful and fresh with house made dressing. My husband loved the jerk wings and said they were some of the best he’s had.
We don’t usually do delivery food on vacation but we’re going to order from Cameo again on this trip.
Also, the delivery driver was friendly and brought the pizza to our hotel room door! That almost never happens, usually delivery drivers either call from outside or leave your food at the front desk. This guy was on it and the extra service was appreciated.
… moreThe margherita pizza was exceptional. Vegetarian pizza really needs flavorful sauce and this pizza delivered. The salad was wonderful and fresh with house made dressing. My husband loved the jerk wings and said they were some of the best he’s had.
We don’t usually do delivery food on vacation but we’re going to order from Cameo again on this trip.
Also, the delivery driver was friendly and brought the pizza to our hotel room door! That almost never happens, usually delivery drivers either call from outside or leave your food at the front desk. This guy was on it and the extra service was appreciated.
Amanda Keller
Great food and services, everytime I order. Pick up window is super useful esp when the bar is full and you just want to grab a bite to eat and go.
… moreTiffany Trotter
This place should shut down. The chicken bites are horrible. Mac and cheese bites soggy. Mozzarella cheese sticks was nasty. Maybe their pizza is good but I won’t order from here again.
I can’t reply to the the owner. I called at 1228 5/19 and was on hold for awhile so it would have been around that time. I was unable to exchange as we already had to wait 50 minutes or more.
… moreI can’t reply to the the owner. I called at 1228 5/19 and was on hold for awhile so it would have been around that time. I was unable to exchange as we already had to wait 50 minutes or more.
Disjuan Zonue
Love the pizza I’m those unusual slices they float right down to my tummy. Great service, too!
… moreRachel DAlessandro
The pickle bread is one of my personal favorites. Cameos is always a great choice! Highly recommend.
… more