Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
At Brenz Pizza Co. in New Albany, we offer a premium pizza experience with something for everyone. Enjoy award-winning specialty pies, fresh salads, wings, and desserts, all made with the finest ingredients. Whether you’re picking up, dining in, ordering delivery, or planning a catered event, Brenz New Albany delivers food and service that leave a lasting impression.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4963 E Dublin Granville Rd, New Albany, OH 43081
Phone: (614) 665-0555
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
New Albany – Brenz Pizza Co
Specialty PizzasWingsSaladsSidesDessertsCustom Pizza. Locations. Chapel Hill, NCColumbus, OHDublin, OH. Durham, NCKnoxville, TNNew Albany, OH (Coming Soon!)
Brenz Pizza Co
Specialty PizzasWingsSaladsSidesDessertsCustom Pizza. Locations. Chapel Hill, NCColumbus, OHDublin, OH. Durham, NCKnoxville, TNNew Albany, OH (Coming Soon!)
Brenz Pizza Co. (New Albany) Delivery Menu | Order Online – Grubhub
Order delivery or pickup from Brenz Pizza Co. (New Albany) in Westerville! View Brenz Pizza Co. (New Albany)’s March 2026 deals and menus.
Reviews
Victoria Taylor
My son and daughter in law have been telling us to try your pizza, they love it. A couple of days ago we ordered it and took home. The pizza crust was very good. We were a little disappointed in the rest. Hardly any toppings compared to the picture on website. We got the ATM
… moreLet Jess Tell It
⭐️⭐️½ – Great Basil. Mid Chicken. Manage Your Expectations.
Brenz Pizza Co. – 4861 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Columbus, OH
️ Visit: August 2025
Ordered:
• Heritage Honey Pizza (me)
• Loaded Pep & Cheese Pizza (dining partner)
• 5-piece Hot Buffalo BBQ Wings (new flavor, not listed on menu)
⸻
PIZZA
• Crust: Fluffy and doughy — almost too bready. If you like a pillowy crust, you’ll be fine. If you prefer structure or crunch, this might feel underwhelming.
• Sauce: I requested a mix of red sauce and garlic butter base, but neither flavor came through. I only knew it was there because I could see it — not taste it.
• Heritage Honey: Sounded better than it tasted. Ingredients didn’t blend well — basil was the only real standout.
• Hot honey drizzle: Syrupy, overly thick, not as spicy or balanced as expected. That said, they don’t skimp — when I asked for extra, they gave me a full cup.
• Loaded Pep & Cheese: Heavier, saltier, and more flavorful than mine. If you like your pizza loud and cheesy, this might be your go-to.
Best bite of the night? The basil. No joke.
⸻
WINGS
• Flavor: We tried the Hot Buffalo BBQ (new flavor). Ordered extra saucy on purpose because online photos made them look dry — and they were right.
• Texture: Cooked evenly like they came out of a commercial convection oven — no crisp, no char.
• Taste: Chicken tasted like plain poultry with sauce sitting on top. No seasoning soaked into the meat. No flavor depth.
• Would I recommend? No. These are fine for catering a work lunch or feeding teens at a school function. But if you’re bringing these home to your people? They’re gonna look at you funny.
Quote the vibe: “The meat and the sauce had a meeting and decided not to collaborate.”
⸻
SERVICE
• Counter staff were friendly, patient, and helpful.
• The only thing more impressive than their pizza box display was how smoothly they handled questions and gave solid suggestions.
• Dining room is clean, minimal, and clearly set up for high-volume takeout.
⸻
OTHER USEFUL INFO
• Price per person: $15–25
• ⏱️ Wait time: 12–15 minutes
• Noise level: Low
• Seating: Booths & bar-height tables
• Vegetarian options: Yes
• Gluten-free crusts: Yes (10”, cauliflower & traditional)
• ️ Parking: Free lot
• Kid-friendly: Yes
• ♿ Wheelchair accessible: Yes
⸻
FINAL THOUGHTS
Brenz looks like it’s got everything together — streamlined branding, clean space, helpful staff. But the flavors didn’t match the packaging.
If you’re nearby and hungry, it’ll do. But if you’re expecting pizza that makes you pause or wings that leave a mark? You’ll probably walk away like I did — glad you tried it, but not rushing back.
Save this if you’ve been circling the menu. And if you go? Try it with low expectations, and let me know if I missed something worth returning for.
… moreBrenz Pizza Co. – 4861 Tuttle Crossing Blvd, Columbus, OH
️ Visit: August 2025
Ordered:
• Heritage Honey Pizza (me)
• Loaded Pep & Cheese Pizza (dining partner)
• 5-piece Hot Buffalo BBQ Wings (new flavor, not listed on menu)
⸻
PIZZA
• Crust: Fluffy and doughy — almost too bready. If you like a pillowy crust, you’ll be fine. If you prefer structure or crunch, this might feel underwhelming.
• Sauce: I requested a mix of red sauce and garlic butter base, but neither flavor came through. I only knew it was there because I could see it — not taste it.
• Heritage Honey: Sounded better than it tasted. Ingredients didn’t blend well — basil was the only real standout.
• Hot honey drizzle: Syrupy, overly thick, not as spicy or balanced as expected. That said, they don’t skimp — when I asked for extra, they gave me a full cup.
• Loaded Pep & Cheese: Heavier, saltier, and more flavorful than mine. If you like your pizza loud and cheesy, this might be your go-to.
Best bite of the night? The basil. No joke.
⸻
WINGS
• Flavor: We tried the Hot Buffalo BBQ (new flavor). Ordered extra saucy on purpose because online photos made them look dry — and they were right.
• Texture: Cooked evenly like they came out of a commercial convection oven — no crisp, no char.
• Taste: Chicken tasted like plain poultry with sauce sitting on top. No seasoning soaked into the meat. No flavor depth.
• Would I recommend? No. These are fine for catering a work lunch or feeding teens at a school function. But if you’re bringing these home to your people? They’re gonna look at you funny.
Quote the vibe: “The meat and the sauce had a meeting and decided not to collaborate.”
⸻
SERVICE
• Counter staff were friendly, patient, and helpful.
• The only thing more impressive than their pizza box display was how smoothly they handled questions and gave solid suggestions.
• Dining room is clean, minimal, and clearly set up for high-volume takeout.
⸻
OTHER USEFUL INFO
• Price per person: $15–25
• ⏱️ Wait time: 12–15 minutes
• Noise level: Low
• Seating: Booths & bar-height tables
• Vegetarian options: Yes
• Gluten-free crusts: Yes (10”, cauliflower & traditional)
• ️ Parking: Free lot
• Kid-friendly: Yes
• ♿ Wheelchair accessible: Yes
⸻
FINAL THOUGHTS
Brenz looks like it’s got everything together — streamlined branding, clean space, helpful staff. But the flavors didn’t match the packaging.
If you’re nearby and hungry, it’ll do. But if you’re expecting pizza that makes you pause or wings that leave a mark? You’ll probably walk away like I did — glad you tried it, but not rushing back.
Save this if you’ve been circling the menu. And if you go? Try it with low expectations, and let me know if I missed something worth returning for.
Chan Man
I ordered the chefs salad and let’s just say it was delicious and large enough to share with 1 other person. I was extremely surprised on how big the bowl is and how delicious it was.
… moreZac W
Picked the old world and Bianca pie from here and enjoyed both pies. Meatballs on the old world were almost like meatloaf and turned out well this visit. Both hearty pies so it does take a lot to get full. Will be back and worth a try.
… moreJames Goodman
Ordered pizzas today for all my workers at Zoom Express and Nate took special care of my team and added some cookies. Great to have good neighbors that look out for each others hard workers. The pizza is damn good as well.
… moreAlexia Andrade
This was our first time trying Brenz Pizza Co and we are fans! We ordered the BBQ chicken pizza which was really tasty and the crust was nice and fluffy but not too thick. We also ordered a gluten free crust pizza with pepperoni, pineapple and onion. The gluten free crust was not great. It was very grainy, almost like it was not fully cooked. We have tried gluten free crusts at many other spots and this was definitely not the best. The pepperoni is also a little spicy- we liked it but just as an fyi for families with kids or spice sensitive people. We also ordered the cheesy bread and that was delicious! Just the right amount of cheese. When picking up our order I saw then giant cookies and made an impulse decision lol and we were not disappointed! The chocolate chip chunk and sugar cookies were super tasty, moist, and chewy! I will also add that the cookies ended up being on the house, which was a really pleasant surprise. This is a customer service touch that I have not seen in quite a while. We will absolutely be recommending Brenz to others and be repeat customers!
… moreTodd Starr
Food and people are good. Impossible to sit and eat comfortably one the prison cafeteria style cemented-in stools and tables. If you don’t have a place to take the pizza to eat, you’re screwed. Love the pizza but have to make other choices for lunch because of the inability to eat in comfortably.
… moreMichael Hlavsa
I’ve ordered here a bunch of times and it’s always been very good. This last time my pizza order got messed up. The GM Nate took very good care of me. I don’t expect everyone to be perfect but I do expect good service. He did a great job. Thanks!
… moreBrian Farneth
First time trying Brenz. I ordered a Mediterranean pizza, cheese bread, a salad, and cookies.
The pizza looked good but wasn’t anything I haven’t had at other places. The crust was semi-thick with a chewy feel, like a thicker New York style. Unfortunately the chicken was dry and had zero flavor. Not having a tomato or crème sauce also took away from the flavor. It ended up being like tough bread with toppings.
The garlic cheese bread was good but the cheese came off in two bites, leaving a thick, somewhat undercooked dough stick. Additionally the dipping sauce, which I assume to be their pizza sauce, was sweet. I get adding sugar to cut down acidity, but it was too much for my taste. I ended up throwing away the entire breadstick order.
The salad was good but the cup pepperoni was almost black and had a slight char taste. I didn’t mind the burn flavor but I wonder if that’s normal. The Italian dressing was good but I wish there was more, along with toppings.
The cookies are where they shined. Delicious. All their deserts looked amazing. Soft in the center but just a little crispy on the edge. Bravo.
Service was great, store was clean. The only criticism I have is their signage wasn’t on and the parking lot was empty, so the store appeared closed. They were open but the visual from driving by is that they weren’t.
Unfortunately I see no reason to return. The deserts may be excellent but everything else was disappointing. I was hoping for a new pizza addiction. Oh well.
… moreThe pizza looked good but wasn’t anything I haven’t had at other places. The crust was semi-thick with a chewy feel, like a thicker New York style. Unfortunately the chicken was dry and had zero flavor. Not having a tomato or crème sauce also took away from the flavor. It ended up being like tough bread with toppings.
The garlic cheese bread was good but the cheese came off in two bites, leaving a thick, somewhat undercooked dough stick. Additionally the dipping sauce, which I assume to be their pizza sauce, was sweet. I get adding sugar to cut down acidity, but it was too much for my taste. I ended up throwing away the entire breadstick order.
The salad was good but the cup pepperoni was almost black and had a slight char taste. I didn’t mind the burn flavor but I wonder if that’s normal. The Italian dressing was good but I wish there was more, along with toppings.
The cookies are where they shined. Delicious. All their deserts looked amazing. Soft in the center but just a little crispy on the edge. Bravo.
Service was great, store was clean. The only criticism I have is their signage wasn’t on and the parking lot was empty, so the store appeared closed. They were open but the visual from driving by is that they weren’t.
Unfortunately I see no reason to return. The deserts may be excellent but everything else was disappointing. I was hoping for a new pizza addiction. Oh well.
MRBARBQ 1
Out cruising today and decided to check Brenz Pizza in New Albany out. Ordered a small Pepperoni Pizza. They opened last November. Talked with Adam about the operation. He said that dough is made fresh daily. All vegetables are brought in fresh from their suppliers, no frozen vegetables. They’re cut up once they are in the store. On to the pizza. It was cooked perfectly for me, slight crispy to the crust. The sauce had the slightest spicy taste to it which was perfect. Nice mild cheese and the pepperoni was a nice addition cup and char type. Might be Ezzo’s, not sure. Good experience, will definitely return. Everyone needs to check them out.
… more