Valerie Gibson
Four of U.S. adults went to Arthur’s Pizzeria tonight for dinner. The seating is very small, but the food was delicious. We weren’t expecting much since New Lothrop is such a small town, but my olive burger was delicious and juicy. Everyone commented that their food was way above expectation. The have pizza, hamburgers, chicken wings and other things, but for a quick night out for a light dinner I would highly recommend this little known nugget of gold.
… moreChris Dark
We had been wanting to check this place out, and we finally did. We got a large pizza with bacon and pepperoni and a side of bread sticks to go. Both were excellent, and the staff was attentive and friendly. We will definitely be making this a regular place on our pizza nights.
… moreCortney McLellan
Arthur’s is a quaint family owned pizza place with some yummy pizza and stromboli. I recommend getting the cream cheese dip. We had the Asian chicken salad too. It was delicious!!
… moreDawn Adkins
Great little hole in the wall. Great service, yummy food. Props out to Miya for taking g good care of us!
… moreJulie Radford
Waited all day for my birthday pizza. Got home and the pizza was raw. Hubby took it back and they remade it and it was raw in the middle too. Ruined my appetite and my birthday dinner. The girls that work there are nice though. This also happened previously with one of their oven baked sandwiches. It was raw too. For a pizza place, you’d think you could make pizzas. Guess not.
… moreTaeju
it was my amazing mother’s birthday today, and yet they can’t even cook a pizza correctly. redid it twice, and yet it was still raw. i will literally turn into the second version of gordon ramsay and have an aneurysm if they can’t figure out how to do it correctly. literally what the gaggleshart
… moreBrie G
The pizza crust is sooo good, it’s crispy and like the best consistency, the pizza sause is also amazing. Definitely recommended! The cheese bread sticks are great too, overall wonderful
… moreCarmen Fry
My husband and I stopped in during a family wedding between the ceremony and reception. We ordered the fried mushrooms and a BLT pizza and it was so good! The cashier was super nice and brought our food to our table. No one else was dining in but plenty of customers came in for take out. It was a super laid back and quaint atmosphere and you get your own drinks at the fountain! I really enjoyed it. It’s definitely not formal dine in, but that’s what I loved about it.
… moreMegan Roney
You can never go wrong with Arthur’s. The quality is great. The prices are as expected for a small family owned business and honestly well worth it. We’ve gotten a little bit of everything from pizza to side to burgers and sandwiches. Never had a bad pick.
… more