Timothy Marshall
Its good ice cream. Nothing that special but still good. Portions were fine and price was okay. The theming was cool and the reusable cup is also cool.
… morePat Hoover
Courteous employees, fast service and a large selection of frozen custard desserts that are delicious.
… morePlants Over Animals
This was a fun experience to try, we got to come before they officially opened, staff was nice, got our orders pretty fast, I’m not a big fan of ice cream or custard but it was good, would like to see some dairy free options in the future
… moreLaQyn Jutaya
Just left Andy’s and I am not satisfied at all. Pictures for reference. This looks nothing like the advertisement in the first picture & they didn’t add the top layer of caramel. Not to mention, the ice cream was 75% melted before they handed it to me. I was the only car in line!
… moreAmanda Daniel
10 out of 10! We’re so kind handling our gluten allergy! Cleaned all of the spoons and mixers. We will be coming back!
… moreJulianna “Julie”
Interesting and tasty choices . The jackhammer treats you can customize are great and unlike most dessert places. It’s nice to try if you want something different and not the same old Carvel or Häagen-Dazs
… moreWAJ
This place was amazing. Plan on going there many times. Highly recommend this place
… moreNeither Name
We’ve gone about 15 times in 2 years. It’s consistently delicious frozen custard. But the application of toppings isn’t consistent– They can be really skimpy on the toppings! But, where they need to really improve is customer service. They don’t have very friendly employees. One young man in particular working yesterday 10/22/25 in the afternoon offered no greeting, no smile, no thank you, no eye contact. All he said was “Is that all?” And “You pay at the window.” And I went back for a water and got the same from him. Definitely some opportunities for re-training and making the team and the customer service experience stronger! In contrast, I went to a different one in Greenville recently and the two team members I met were extremely friendly. Simpsonville just needs to up their game!
… moreLaura Robbins
We only went here because the Baskin Robbins was being remodeled. It was more expensive and the wait was fairly long, but the custard cream was okay. The waffle cone was too big for one scoop of ice cream, which diabetic husband has to watch.
… moreShunlee Brown
Was too sweet for me I couldn’t finish it. Maybe it was the toppings I ordered so just plain vanilla next time. However service was very fast.
… more