David Torkelson
Andy D’s Milton: Taco Tuesday is a Must-Try!
My wife and I recently visited Andy D’s in Milton for their Tuesday Taco Night and were genuinely impressed by the value and attentive service. For couples looking for an affordable and fun weeknight dinner, this half-price special—featuring chicken, shrimp, or Wagyu tacos, plus one side—is an absolute steal. Being able to mix and match taco types made the meal a perfect shared experience.
The star of the show was undoubtedly the Shrimp Tacos. They were delicious, featuring perfectly cooked shrimp topped with a vibrant salsa and sauce (likely the sweet and spicy mentioned on the menu). The flavors were bright and well-balanced. The Wagyu tacos, while interesting, were simply okay, lacking the same “wow” factor as their seafood counterpart.
We paired our tacos with their unique French Fries. These aren’t your typical thin-cut fries; their unusual shape gives them a great crispy-to-fluffy ratio, making them a satisfying and solid side dish.
Beyond the food, the service truly stood out. The staff was attentive and very nice throughout our meal, ensuring a pleasant dining experience. The biggest surprise of the night was the bill: dinner for two, including the tacos and sides, came in at under $25! Given the quality and the excellent pricing, we were surprised the restaurant wasn’t more crowded. Andy D’s Taco Tuesday is a local treat that definitely deserves more attention.
Rating: 4/5 Stars (5/5 for value!)
… moreAnna Smith
We ate at Andy D’s for their Saturday brunch and it was delicious! Servings were big and our waiter went above and beyond to accommodate my picky toddler’s request for a strawberry pancake + even put a whipped cream smiley face on it. We will be back. ☺️
… moreTricia Scarbrough
The vegetables were extremely over Seasoned ( not edible). Hush Puppies were not completely cooked inside, still pretty raw and gummy. Coleslaw is bland (like shredding cabbage with a little bit of carrot and doing absolutely nothing else to it). Thank goodness, the shrimp tasted pretty good, not a lot of flavor but it was okay.
… moreManisha Moe
The food always comes out hot & tastes amazing. The lunch atmosphere is calm and you can hold a conversation without yelling with good music. The issue we had was with our waitress, we got a call to work but had to wait over 10 mins to pay and another waitress had to go get our waitress. We tip base on service and the waitress confronted me outside the restaurant as im trying to get to work demanding to know about the tip. When I calmly told her, she called me rude and disrespectful. She choose to give us extra sauce without charging, I didn’t ask for it, I was more than happy to pay for it that doesn’t automatically mean tip. The sauce issue was their menu says I can have 2 and she flat out said no, and I said it says so on your menu but she was like oh I will just give it to you and wont charge you. My husband’s drink was empty, then she gave us an employee discount using that as a threat for not tipping her. I told her I have to get to work and she said no then dont ever come back and I will talk to Mr. Andy. Well- My question is: Is it mandatory to tip for bad service at your restaurant? On the other hand if you go in ask for Jenny, our last visit with her was amazing and she kept our drinks full.
Update:
The management & owner reached out to me promptly and addressed the issue. I appreciate their urgency in addressing and stressing on the importance of how their customers are treated. We were so thrilled when Mr. Andy said we could come back because I was very sad that I would miss eating their awesome mullet basket and he suggested the steak tacos!! Thank you for your kind ess.
… moreTonia Ebert
We had breakfast at Andy D’s Roadhouse in Milton, and it was fantastic! We shared an omelet, potatoes, grits, French toast, and a biscuit — and every single bite was delicious. The potatoes and grits were perfectly seasoned and full of flavor, and the French toast was especially yummy.
It honestly feels like a hidden gem — more people need to discover this place! It just might be the best breakfast in the area.
The atmosphere is relaxed with plenty of seating, and they offer a lot of daily specials. We’ve also heard they feature live music at times, which we’d love to check out next time.
A big shout-out to Ali, our server — she was friendly, helpful, and made our visit even better.
If you haven’t been to Andy D’s yet, go! You’re missing out.
… moreSherri Sampson
A group of 9 friends met at Andy D’s early on a Monday evening after golf. It was our lucky day to have Bethany as our server. She was attentive, thorough, and friendly with a great accent. She joked with us while never missing a beat in keeping our drink needs met and taking our food orders. The food was excellent. The white fish basket with onion rings was just right. Not greasy, excellent texture, great taste. I had a veggie pizza that was delicious. We will definitely go back and be sure to ask for Bethany.
… moreTim C
I love this place. Definitely has an old, home style feel. I had a ribeye steak and the way that it was prepared and served was unique and awesome. It came on a iron skillet, still cooking. The waitress let me know that it comes out medium rare, so the longer I leave it on the skillet the longer it will cook. So it was cooked to perfection lol. I had a margarita that was pretty standard, and switched to a nice cold beer on tap. Not a huge selection but eclectic. A band started playing after I ate my meal, they were really good. They were called the Rowdies. They played great southern rock. Definitely a place I would go back to when I’m in Milton Florida.
… moreJericho
5-24-25 @ 1100am: first time here. Very good food and portions. Quick service! Music was not my thing but they have separate dinning area if you need that. Probably a good “go to anytime” they are open! May have to try an evening steak soon.
… moreSheena Horne
We LOVE Andy D’s! Sunday brunch is always amazing and the salads are delish! Huge portions & fantastic service! Ask for Ava! She always takes great care of us❤️
… moreSummer Hearn
I had the Cobb salad, southwest egg rolls (YUM!) & mozzarella sticks – delish! The Cobb salad dressing appears to be homemade. The menu was a bit limiting, but I did enjoy the food. The outside area was precious!!
… more