Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Family-run eatery preps Italian staples & a deep lineup of specialty pizzas in a simple space.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 999 Montauk Hwy, West Babylon, NY 11704
Phone: (631) 587-4394
Website: https://alitaliababylon.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant – West Babylon, NY
We are committed to bringing you the best Pizza in West Babylon. We are conveniently located on Montauk Hwy in West Babylon in the Great South Bay Shopping …
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant | West Babylon, NY – (631) 587-4394
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant is in West Babylon, NY. Call us today!
Alitalia Pizzeria & Restaurant | West Babylon NY – Facebook
Classic Italian favorites—done right ✨ From crispy appetizers to saucy entrées and everything in between… this is how we do dinner in West Babylon. # …
Reviews
Stephanie Hovanec
From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with great energy and even better service. Justine runs the front with total efficiency. She is always on the move, friendly, and truly the best person to have up front. She brings a whole new meaning to service with a smile.
And the pizza? Easily the best on Long Island. Consistently delicious and absolutely worth the stop.
… moreAnd the pizza? Easily the best on Long Island. Consistently delicious and absolutely worth the stop.
Richard K
Decent food but never order from this place during busy times because it will show up cold almost every time.
My family usually likes to order from here because I have a son with a Gluten allergy and they have a decent amount of Gluten free options. However, if you try to order for delivery, the food shows up cold more than 50% of the time. Therefore, the food doesn’t taste as good. In addition, when you try to call to resolve the issue, they ask you to call Door Dash when they should be the ones to call them since that’s who they use for a delivery service.
If only they can resolve their delivery issues then I’d bump up the rating a bit.
… moreMy family usually likes to order from here because I have a son with a Gluten allergy and they have a decent amount of Gluten free options. However, if you try to order for delivery, the food shows up cold more than 50% of the time. Therefore, the food doesn’t taste as good. In addition, when you try to call to resolve the issue, they ask you to call Door Dash when they should be the ones to call them since that’s who they use for a delivery service.
If only they can resolve their delivery issues then I’d bump up the rating a bit.
Juan Lima
Alot to choose from and this place was packed on an early weekend afternoon. We had their buffalo wings, fried calamari and a rice ball. The fried calamari and rice ball were delicious. The Buffalo wings were the tiniest of wings I’ve eaten in a long time and something I wouldn’t get again. Would go for their pizza on the next visit.
… moreLourdes Ortiz
Their pizza is delicious not one better than the other. I live in this area. They remind me of Brooklyn pizzas back when I lived there. HIGHLY RECOMMEND this place. Meals are ALL delicious great place
… moreDavid Villano Jr.
If this isn’t the best hot honey roni slice then I don’t know what is. Alitalia has the best hot honey slice on the island no questions asked. 10/10
… moreLou Pizzichillo
We already knew we loved their food, but when we had an issue with DoorDash during a party for my daughter, we got to see what great people were here. They went out of their way to make sure things were made right quickly and they gave us exactly what we needed. We couldn’t have asked for better service.
… moreMatthew Finn
The food is fine but too expensive for what it is, and these bozos can’t put an order together to save their lives. Literally every time I gotta go over it infront of them because they forgot to put something in the box. I’ve been the only person at the counter and they mess it up, it’s pathetic. They’re so petty here if you sit down in the back restaurant to eat they won’t serve you a regular slice a pizza from the front, even for a toddler, you gotta buy a mini pizza. Having the tip jar at the front is laughable, the attitude is garbage.
… moreIlene Gold-Corina
Been here a few times. Great wings but this was an off night. Food was not hot, service was awful, waiter seemed nervous and struggled with small requests. Forgot salad, extra napkins and made a major error on our credit card causing us to wait over 30 minutes to get it fixed. Thank goodness for Natalie, a young pleasant staff person who treated us well trying to fix the errors the waiter made.
So many Italian restaurants to choose from, this was not the first issue there.
… moreSo many Italian restaurants to choose from, this was not the first issue there.
Ame Chicas
Great options, staff, and tasty food. Quick service and nice seating
… moreNeil Pantelatos
Incredible pizzeria/restaurant. Very tasty food. Service was super friendly. What a great family business. I can’t wait to come back.
… more