Welcome to Your Pie Pizza in Flagstaff, where we specialize in hand-tossed, brick-oven pizzas crafted with fresh ingredients and homemade sauces. Our menu caters to all with vegan, vegetarian, gluten-free, and keto-friendly options alongside classic favorites. Experience the convenience of curbside pickup, delivery, or enjoy our outdoor seating for a family-friendly dining experience. We also provide catering in Flagstaff for events, office lunches, and gatherings of all sizes.
Diners choose their dough, sauce, cheese & toppings at this pizzeria chain with gelato & microbrews.
the novice foodie
The atmosphere is incredible. Decorations are pretty, lighting is great. This place would be great to have a group of friends at.
I got a 10’ BYO Pizza with the drink and salad. Salad is very small their drink options are fine. The pizza is artisan so it’s the thin crust and crispy bottom. You can’t really go wrong with BYO since you are choosing ingredients, it tasted delicious.
Worker was respectful and service is nice there.
… moreMichelle Garcia
My family and I were driving cross country ahead of Winter Storm Fern and needed a place to get a bite. We felt so lucky to find this spot. It’s a decent size and seems like it would be a happening place if not for a storm outside. The selection of food, non alcoholic, and alcoholic drinks were great. They have a shelf with a few games and 2 TVs.
They staff that night was very friendly and provided great service to weary travelers. I highly recommend visiting!
… moreAnna Wilson
This is my second time getting take-out pizza from here; the first time my plant-based sausage & cheese were forgotten, but I decided I would give it another chance. I really WANT to love this pizza because the crust is actually really tasty, but both times the ingredients were super sparse and/or forgotten. A very middle of the road experience. I will say the service has always been very kind and efficient! I also appreciate a big, free parking lot for when I don’t feel like dealing with downtown Flagstaff.
… moreAnalisa Harvey
Delicious food. Friendly staff. Excellent service. Dog friendly. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Plenty of parking. The chicken Caprese was so filling and delicious. Must go back to try more of these menu items. Draft beers were also great. My root beer float had the best tasting vanilla ice cream I’ve ever had.
… moreMathew Aultman
Always a great experience here! Pizzas made to perfection, friendly staff, super clean and welcoming… I’ve been coming here for a few years and I’ve never once had a bad experience… If pizza is you thing check this place out you won’t be disappointed… Shout out to Tray who made my pizza perfectly today you rock brother
… moreSarah
Let me start off by saying we love it here. It’s overpriced but delicious, always cute and quiet. This review is based on 2 disappointing meals. I got wings and I don’t think there was even meat a single one. I wish I had taken a picture of the piles of fat coming off each wing. I have never seen anything like it. Then I got the “brisket” sandwich. The idea is excellent, but note it’s definitely not a sandwich but a calzone with almost nothing inside. You are not allowed to customize it which is ironic because it’s called YOUR Pie, with the whole point being that you can create a meal tailored to YOUR liking. I was told items could be taken off but nothing can be added to it. Then I get it with a total of THREE brisket pieces, about the size of a dime each. That was soooo disappointing and not money well spent. It’s so unfortunate because the sauce and crust are delicious but a brisket sandwich should contain brisket and I should be able to make it my own as it is just a personal pizza folded in half. Please do better so I can remain a regular and order more than pizza.
… moreJessica Howard
Depending on the time of day, service can be a tiny bit slow. But we still go often because of the vibes.
It’s got a fantastic patio, good beers on tap, and a shelf full of games. Not to mention awesome pizzas that are extremely personalizable, and delicious gelato. We love to go and take our kids and hang out and eat/ play games on the patio.
I’ve visited a couple of other chains similar to this — MOD Pizza, Blaze, etc – and Your Pie is definitely my fave of these type of restaurants!
… moreSondra Lynn Mize
Cute and efficient pizza stop with custom made options!
I love the opportunity to pay the same price for the ingredients I desire vs. the restaurant’s signature pies. What a wonderful option!
If you crave pizza and don’t have a lot of time, know what you will get a good pizza with exactly the toppings you want here at Your Pie.
The servers were super sweet too, and it’s a high ceiling, open concept room with tables – and booths if you prefer more privacy. They also have a huge patio and I heard we’re dog friendly.
Prices are less than I last paid for a good pizza – and they have gluten free options if you need.
Well done!
… moreDenise
Pretty good pizza, not the best in town, but gets the job done and the customizations are nice. They have a nice drink selection as well. A little pricey and slow but a nice place to chill and have a nice dinner. The gelato is delicious too!
… moreLetti Fodor
This place used to be so good. We loved coming here. Now it’s a total disaster. I have no idea who is running this place but they need to wake up! The pizza is constantly burnt, they are overusing the cornmeal that is covering your food. The place is extremely dirty, there are food and crumbs everywhere. It’s a shame that nobody cares!
… more