Amanda Ray
My family and I always like to come here when we are craving pizza. We each get the personal and choose our toppings or pick an option that’s listed on the board. The tomato sauce is light, good topping options and the fresh dough crust cooked in the brick-oven is what wins us over! You can also make it a combo that includes a beverage and a side salad OR our favorite … the gelato (so good!).
… moreChuck Varnum
Ordered a pizza and cheese bread for pick up on a Friday night. When I got my pizza, I noticed it didn’t seem especially hot. Got out to my car and opened the lid to find that the pizza and breadsticks were pretty cool. When I got home (3 minute drive), I had to microwave both items in order to eat them. I’ve never had to warm up a fresh pizza before.
In addition, the breadsticks were burnt so bad on the bottom they had to be thrown out.
I will not be back and cannot recommend anyone go here.
… moreNeka Smith
I ordered their pizza and cookies yesterday, which looked nothing like the photos. The crust was tough, yet not crisp at all. The manager said that this was because it was hand-tossed. The pizza had 4 small chunks of chicken, that looked canned, on the entire pizza, some random unidentified item on it, and the pesto tasted spoiled. The manager stated that the pizzas I ordered were the most popular, hinting at there being no way they were not good or there being an off day. He also blamed everything on the pizza being delivered rather than dining in, stating “I highly recommend trying our food in-house as it shows the freshness and flavorful mixtures that a delivered food can’t” which points to delivery of their pizza not being fresh nor flavorful.
I hate to say this, but the pizza was the worst I have had, which includes Pizza Hut, Little Caesars, and frozen options. I am more than disappointed in both the taste and the service that I received. The empty spot that you see within the box of pizza, is a piece I took, took a bite, and threw it right into the trash.
… moreAmanda Burns
There are a lot of pizza places around and this one is good in concept but just ok in execution. The restaurant was nice and clean and very spacious. The staff was friendly but sparse and I liked that they had some Vegan & Dairy free options. I ordered a Large Cheese Pizza, a Small Pepperoni & Mushrooms Pizza and a scoop of White Chocolate Peppermint Bark Gelato. The food looked good but the flavors just weren’t there and the portions were quite small for the price. The crust had too much debris from the oven on it to taste good and was thinner than most wood fire style crusts. I could have eaten the entire Large Pizza and still been hungry. The gelato was by far my favorite part of the meal. Not really worth coming back just for that though.
… moreAmanda Green
Mixed feelings about this one. I was the only person in the restaurant at 130 on a weekday, fyi. The restaurant is new thus very clean. Handicapped accessible. Spacious– good for social distancing. Also the plexiglass-like dividers placed between booths looked very nice. Well thought out and purposeful. I got the lunch special…single pizza with salad and a drink (many combos available). The pizza had a garlic oil base with mozzarella and basil and tomatoes. It tasted fine but was NOT pleasing to the eye. It did not look good. I chose a Cesar salad and it and the dressing (chosen separately) were fresh and tasty. There was one employee and a man who seemed to be management. He was present yet distant. Since the restaurant wasn’t busy I thought he could have come over and asked about my food or thanked me for coming by. The place wasn’t super impressive but spacious and clean are big winners for me. Maybe Ill try the pasta next time. New, easy access parking behind the restaurant. I almost forgot. I planned on needing a box to take leftovers in so asked them to put pizza directly in a box. The take out boxes were cheap and there were shreds of cardboard from the massive cutting machine, I guess, next to the food.
… moreEmilee Miller
Your Pie has the best pizza in Marion that I have tasted hands down. And I’m a born and bred Northeast PA raised NY style pizza lover girl. Their pies never disappoint! The gelato is amazing too :). Try their house made pesto with your pizza, you won’t regret it. Get the garlic cheese bread too while you’re at it. On the other hand, just order the entire menu, it’s all delicious!
… moreAmanda Fowler-Arias
Got the peach bbq wings and they are just awful and inedible. The sauce itself was just peachy but not bbq and tasted stale. Wings were burnt and so tiny and tasted old. Tossing these in the trash waste of 15 bucks
… moreAiden Kuennen
The pizza here is absolutely amazing, and the service is out of this world! A manager named Ella went above and beyond—she was so polite, kind, and really took the time to explain all of the pizza options. It made the whole experience even better. I’ll definitely be coming back!
… moreJohn Louzek
Definitely will come back, best Pizza I’ve had in this area of iowa, Definitely not the best in the state or best I’ve had ever, I loved the crust and the toppings were fresh. Only complaint was the sauce wss a bit watery, so it wasn’t perfect but an amazing option for Pizza in Marion.
… moreIndea Harris
Came during baseball tournament traveling from Illinois. Very clean stations, clean atmosphere! Pizza is great! You can tell it’s fresh ingredients and handmade.
I hate to say it…but I think they’re better than Blaze Pizza! Definitely will be back next time in this area. ❤️
… more