4.2 – 90 reviews • Pub
Wyckoff Tavern is a farm to table gastro pub. Offering excellent cuisine in an elegant but comfortable atmosphere. Perfect for date night, a night out with friends or come watch the big game. We offer 7 tv’s with the NFL Sunday Ticket. We have several craft and seasonal cocktails, and 8 beers on tap including Guiness. Happy hour every Monday through Friday 4-6. A family owned operation with attention to details.
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Wyckoff Tavern
At Wyckoff Tavern, we believe great food and drink bring people together. Rooted in the heart of Wyckoff, our story is one of community, hospitality, and a love …
Wyckoff Tavern | Wyckoff NJ – Facebook
Opening fall 2025, Wyckoff Tavern reinvents the former Café Amici with a fresh, farm‑to‑table tavern concept. Chef-owner Arthur Toufayan brings 40+ years of …
Reviews
Valeria Kharlamova
The food is amazing, starting with the rock shrimp, pretzels, and crispy tuna appetizers, all the way to the mains. If you go, you have to try their salad, it’s the best in NJ! The drinks are great too, and the vibes are cozy and fantastic. Definitely recommend!!!!!
… moreSuzy S
30 dollars for this? Were told it was an extra 6 dollars to add chicken.. looked at the bill and saw $12 for added chicken ontop of the 16 dollar salad. I thought they made a mistake, maybe charged twice for chicken. Called said it’s an extra 6 dollars for the chicken to be breaded. Rediculous. Salad wasn’t even good. Chicken was cold and other ingredients low quality, wilted lettuce, not chopped like said on menu. Never again. Atleast put on your website that if the chicken is breaded it’s an extra 6 dollars.
… moreMichelle Danton
A friend from town brought me and I loved this place! Great vibe, amazing veggie burger, stone crabs special, a pickled martini, great server, a friendly bar crowd…what more could you want!
… moreBobbi Rayot
We decided to check out Wyckoff Tavern tonight for the first time and so glad we did. We had a great time. We had a great drink at the bar while waiting for a table, the girl helping us had some nice recommendations which helped us decide on dinner once we got to the table. Our server was on point and very helpful going out of her way to make sure what we ordered was ok with my boyfriend’s allergy. The place was very busy but the manager made time to come over and check on us and he made sure everything was to our liking. If in the area we highly recommend this spot. We will definitely be back!
… moreExpert Tutor
We wanted to take our visitors from Spain to a special place with delicious food, great atmosphere and super service so we decided on the Wyckoff Tavern! We started with the classic spinach and artichoke dip ( they had never tried that before and loved it!) We also ordered a special appetizer ( Pork belly and ginger) was amazing! Two of us ordered our usual wedge salad with a protein and our friends from Spain ordered and enjoyed the chicken Milanese and the mushroom pizza. Both entrees were fantastic. What we really like is that the restaurant offers a terrific selection of wines. It’s difficult to appease the Spanish with wines from here and they absolutely loved the Cabernet we chose. They also loved the IPA selection. There was nothing missing from this dinner and we will definitely be back! Highly recommend a visit as you will not be disappointed! ( on a side note..I have a nut allergy and they were very aware and I felt very comfortable.
… moreSharon Mault-Weir
Dining at the Wyckoff Tavern is always an excellent experience. The food and service are exceptional and exceeds expectations.
As a loyal patron who dines here the average of twice per week, consistency is what we experience.
Thank you Lynn, for sharing your treasure with all of us and a special note of appreciation to Scott who continues to offer outstanding service.
Sharon Mault-Weir
… moreSadi Alimi
We go to Wyckoff Tavern often, and a huge reason is Ryan. He is absolutely amazing—so welcoming, attentive, and genuinely kind. He goes out of his way to make every visit feel special and remembered. Samantha is also wonderful and adds to the warm, friendly atmosphere they create together. The food is excellent, the drinks are always on point, and the overall vibe is fantastic.
… moreMaria Becker
The service was very slow .order our food it took about half hour later. The food wasn’t that great. Very noisy .Hopeful it will improve as time goes on .
… moreAbigail C
Wonderful dinner experience here! I ordered the scallops and while they did take a while to come out, it was worth the wait! Food was incredible! Our server, Tatiana, was very friendly as well. I definitely recommend giving this place a try, it’s a lovely atmosphere to meet up with friends or just to have a night out
… moreCoffee
Management was terrible. Got sassed by the hostess who I found out was the owner. heard her yelling at her staff too behind the kitchen.
Waited 1.5 hours for food and it was sub-par: burger was raw and my cousin’s pasta was bland and flavorless.
Don’t really know why we came here — thought it would be different from Cafe Amici but they barely changed their menu and just upped their prices.
Service was good at least – the kid who bussed our table was polite and understanding.
… more … View more