Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream Company is a Pizza Restaurant located in Lakeland, FL. We offer Catering, Italian Food, Pizza, Pizza Takeout, Pizza Delivery, Chicken Wings, Ice Cream and other Pizzeria Services. Here at Wabash Pizzeria, we serve up some of the most delicious pizzas around. We use only the freshest ingredients for our made to order pizzas, so you can be sure you are getting nothing but the best. Come enjoy a bite with us, or call us for delivery & take out!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 217 N Wabash Ave, Lakeland, FL 33815
Phone: (863) 937-3773
Website: http://wabashpic.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Wabash Pizzeria & Ice Cream Company
Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream Company serves up handcrafted pizzas, creamy milkshakes, and hot subs made with care. Located in Lakeland, FL, …
Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream Company | Lakeland FL – Facebook
$1 wings here at the shop. Open from 11am – 8pm. Call us at (863) 937-3773 Or come join us at 217 N Wabash Ave Lakeland FL 33815.
Wabash Pizzeria & Ice Cream Company – View Menu & Order Online
Appetizers & Sides · Best seller. Garlic Knots · Mozzarella Cheese Sticks. 5 mozzarella cheese sticks, served with our homemade sauce. · Wabash Fried Dough – …
Reviews
Mairi Beckett
Excellent calzone. Reasonable priced and huge portion! Perfect ratio of mozzarella and ricotta, just wow. Their red sauce is also excellent. I’ll be back to try other things on the menu. The customer service was great, as well. I noticed they had air hockey—might bring my husband back to enjoy with a slice or two for a date night.
… moreDebora Lefort-Cintron
I lived in New York and New Jersey for over 15 years and it has been very hard to find a really good pizza in Lakeland. You have definitely won my heart over with my first order from your company.
I ordered delivery and you immediately called me back to tell me you did not have the small bottles of soda and offered to send a couple of ice and a 2 L. That was appreciated.
I ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni, and was astonished at how large it was. And although I originally took one slice out of the box, I knew I could not stop it just one piece. It was delicious, perfect crust, delicious toppings, And cooked perfectly.
If you are looking for pizza that is close to New York style pizza, I highly encourage you to try Wabash pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed.
… moreI ordered delivery and you immediately called me back to tell me you did not have the small bottles of soda and offered to send a couple of ice and a 2 L. That was appreciated.
I ordered a large pizza with extra cheese and pepperoni, and was astonished at how large it was. And although I originally took one slice out of the box, I knew I could not stop it just one piece. It was delicious, perfect crust, delicious toppings, And cooked perfectly.
If you are looking for pizza that is close to New York style pizza, I highly encourage you to try Wabash pizzeria. You won’t be disappointed.
robert colwell
Have tried their pizza, calzone, and wings with all being very good at the suggestion of the owner, today was a Boss Hog sub kinda day. And wow! Excellent toasted roll, homemade meatballs, house marinara, and the ‘cheesy pasta’. Described as a blend of Alfredo, queso, and mozzarella cheese it has redefined my thoughts about the perfect pasta sauce
Well played Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream!
… moreWell played Wabash Pizzeria and Ice Cream!
Evil Peanut
Update 8/2024 = 1star
The owner has jumped on his high horse with his keyboard warrior attitude & in the last few hours wrote comments about reviews from years ago. The old owner was kind & made this place great. The new owner gets mad at every bad review & it shows in his response. I’m writing this because the owner chose to respond to my girlfriends post but hasn’t touched mine. My reviews speak for themselves thru the years of coming here. If you can’t handle criticism & make your business better from that, you have no business owning a business. Take the hit & move on, in this new America there are several types of people, most aren’t going to like your attitude of how you respond to the reviews & base that on coming to your business, but if your looking on losing business your doing a great job, best of luck!
P.S.
People look at the people who are writing reviews for this business. If they have under 20 reviews & give 5 stars, it’s a fake review!
Update 1/2023 = 1 star
Walked in & it just felt different, Seeing G-money on a receipt is very unprofessional, then we find out the older gentleman sold this once great place. Pizza was slightly burnt, garlic knots burnt on the bottom. There is a child running around grabbing random things from the back, screaming that mommy said I could or said I can! I used to love this place because it was quiet, but new ownership, loud Mexican music, & kid screaming. Google says Sunday closes at 9 pm, but at 730pm, they are putting up chairs. The tables aren’t clean, This customer won’t be coming back.
Update 5/2022 = 5 stars
Another prefect visit, we just made it in before they closed at 9 pm on Sunday. As always, everyone was super friendly & it’s always a pleasure coming here. More pictures of wonderful food. Small is plenty for 2 people & garlic knots with that garlic dipping sauce. It was great! It’s funny how we get the same thing every time we come here!
Update 4/2022 = 5 stars
This time, we got a large meat pizza, wow, so big & garlic knots with garlic sauce to dip super sweet! If you are planning on coming, bring your appetite because you will leave full.
10/2021 = 5 stars
There are lots of choices to choose from, good . a few video games. The older gentleman who works there, I’m sure, owns the place very nice and accommodating. I joy coming here and girlfriend loves this place, I can hardly ever get her to get pizza but since she likes this place when we are in Lakeland it’s easier to get my pizza, so thank you for having great food and a nice atmosphere for your restaurant!
… moreThe owner has jumped on his high horse with his keyboard warrior attitude & in the last few hours wrote comments about reviews from years ago. The old owner was kind & made this place great. The new owner gets mad at every bad review & it shows in his response. I’m writing this because the owner chose to respond to my girlfriends post but hasn’t touched mine. My reviews speak for themselves thru the years of coming here. If you can’t handle criticism & make your business better from that, you have no business owning a business. Take the hit & move on, in this new America there are several types of people, most aren’t going to like your attitude of how you respond to the reviews & base that on coming to your business, but if your looking on losing business your doing a great job, best of luck!
P.S.
People look at the people who are writing reviews for this business. If they have under 20 reviews & give 5 stars, it’s a fake review!
Update 1/2023 = 1 star
Walked in & it just felt different, Seeing G-money on a receipt is very unprofessional, then we find out the older gentleman sold this once great place. Pizza was slightly burnt, garlic knots burnt on the bottom. There is a child running around grabbing random things from the back, screaming that mommy said I could or said I can! I used to love this place because it was quiet, but new ownership, loud Mexican music, & kid screaming. Google says Sunday closes at 9 pm, but at 730pm, they are putting up chairs. The tables aren’t clean, This customer won’t be coming back.
Update 5/2022 = 5 stars
Another prefect visit, we just made it in before they closed at 9 pm on Sunday. As always, everyone was super friendly & it’s always a pleasure coming here. More pictures of wonderful food. Small is plenty for 2 people & garlic knots with that garlic dipping sauce. It was great! It’s funny how we get the same thing every time we come here!
Update 4/2022 = 5 stars
This time, we got a large meat pizza, wow, so big & garlic knots with garlic sauce to dip super sweet! If you are planning on coming, bring your appetite because you will leave full.
10/2021 = 5 stars
There are lots of choices to choose from, good . a few video games. The older gentleman who works there, I’m sure, owns the place very nice and accommodating. I joy coming here and girlfriend loves this place, I can hardly ever get her to get pizza but since she likes this place when we are in Lakeland it’s easier to get my pizza, so thank you for having great food and a nice atmosphere for your restaurant!
A. Joseph Iglesias (JoAy)
Food’s okay, portions are not on point prices are extremely unreasonable but overall The atmosphere is good Management’s good people are good. Go here if you want to waste the paycheck and use cash you’ll get taxed with the credit card.
… moreAmber VDS
Great customer service, good food- pizza is flatbread style/ thin crust fyi! Small arcade that ranges from 50 cents for skee ball etc to 1.50 for pool table- some provide tickets to get small prizes. Hosts a boad game meet up every other Sunday starting at 11am ♡
… moreYadira Soto
We ordered 2 pizzas 10″ lasagna and garlic knots, very good price, the service when ordering and picking up quickly, only that everything was overcooked in the oven. The pizza was dry and toasted, the lasagna was very delicious, and the knots were overcooked. We will not stop going there and try soon.
… moreMara PC
We ordered from Wabash Pizza while we were down for a graduation. The pizza was delicious! The crust was foldable and perfectly textured. The sauce and toppings were generous and tasty. Highly recommend!
… moreTony Zinni
ordered pick-up of the 12*18 thick crust pizza with one topping, which oddly is not on their online menu anymore. As you can see this pizza was not thick at all with a very small amount of topping. I also did not like the flavor of the sauce nor the fact it left a lasting aftertaste in my mouth. I will usually save the leftover for the next day to eat, but this one I threw out what I didn’t eat. This was the first time getting food from here so I do not know if this is the normal quality. My wife ordered a calzone, however I did not try it so I can not rate the calzone.
… moreBethany Dow
Latest update per owners response. August 1st 2024.
Very unfriendly and cannot accept healthy criticism. Instead of blaming me for your burnt food, try fixing it and not having burnt food. And how am i supposed to talk to a manager, if there isn’t one there? Unless you were the unprofessional who had G money as your name in the receipt.
I am sure that there are some people who enjoy this place. It’s just not me. Lowered to 1 star.
New update: lowered to 2 stars
The food has changed. The food was burnt and tastes different and has New owner, and it’s not the same friendly place. Won’t be back.
… moreVery unfriendly and cannot accept healthy criticism. Instead of blaming me for your burnt food, try fixing it and not having burnt food. And how am i supposed to talk to a manager, if there isn’t one there? Unless you were the unprofessional who had G money as your name in the receipt.
I am sure that there are some people who enjoy this place. It’s just not me. Lowered to 1 star.
New update: lowered to 2 stars
The food has changed. The food was burnt and tastes different and has New owner, and it’s not the same friendly place. Won’t be back.