Vinny’s of Carroll Gardens

by

  4.5 – 820 reviews   • Italian restaurant

Social Profile:

Neighborhood Italian restaurant serving red-sauce fare in a family-friendly setting.

✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out Vinny's of Carroll Gardens 11231

Menu Photos

Order and Reservations

Order: Order online

vinnysofcarrollgardens.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Vinnys Of Carroll Gardens – Ristorante ltaliano est. 1997

We serve heartfelt Italian-American dishes with generous portions, family-style warmth, and a true Brooklyn spirit. Join us for classic flavors, good company, …

Vinny’s Of Carroll Gardens (@vinnysofcarrollgardens) – Instagram

A Brooklyn neighborhood gem! Open daily for takeout and delivery. Relaxed, casual Ristorante Italiano (718)875-5600 …

VINNY’S OF CARROLL GARDENS RESTAURANT | Brooklyn NY

We survived the blizzard. ❄️ The snow is cleared, the ovens are hot, and Vinny’s of Carroll Gardens is fully operational and open for business today.

Reviews

Ramona Carter
Traditional Brooklyn Italian Restaurant! We subways to it for lunch. The portions are huge! I highly recommend the Shrimp Fra Diavolo with creamy rice & peas as your side! The portions are huge, so plan to share or bring home leftovers. They do bring bread and butter to the table for free. The lentil soup was tasty, but it does have pasta in it that is not listed on the menu for those who may be gluten intolerant. The Sole Oregano is why we trekked down. It was fabulous as well. The broccoli was steamed a bit too mushy, but still good with the dishes we ordered.
… more
Lynda Howell
What a lovely restaurant. The food and service are excellent. The staff are very warm and kind. We met locals there who were a joy to chat with and were well know by the staff as regulars. Out of 11 days, it’s the only restaurant we made a point of eating there twice.
… more
Yelena Conaway
The restaurant has a fun, lovely decor. It feels authentic, warm, and friendly. The service was slow but it was two people working and it kind of added to the family-run restaurant vibe so I didn’t mind. The portions are huge and oh so much cheese! The food was ok. The veal was overcooked, the sauces were pretty good, flavorful, the pasta was also nicely cooked.
… more
Louis Pecceu
Came here because of all the good reviews but unfortunately I have to disagree. We (myself and girlfriend) received horrible service throughout our experience. Took about 30 minutes to even get seated which I initially thought was ok because the restaurant was full but even after parties left tables took 15-20 minutes to get cleaned and ready for us. Didn’t get water for another 15 or so minutes. No complementary bread or Parmesan cheese, both as promised by the single waitress working the place. Even with a half full restaurant, she seemed to always be taking breaks and working as slow as possible. When the food finally came it was lukewarm (it had been sitting out finished for a while). I didn’t even get what I ordered but just ate it anyways because I was hungry and sending it back would’ve taken another half hour. The food was alright. Took 15 minutes after asking to get the check as well. Maybe it was just a bad day but I’m not sure what’s going on here. As a Californian I understand the cultural differences regarding public demeanor but this level of service is unacceptable. I’m never the one to claim discrimination but us being Asian might have had something to do with this. We saw a gay couple stand up and leave after also not being helped for a very long time. I’ve never been treated this way at any restaurant anywhere in the world before, including places where I don’t speak the a word of the local language. Absolutely do not recommend unless you are willing to put up with total bs for mediocre food.
… more
Dena Oppie
Very delicious home authentic Italian grandma cooking. Large portions!!!!! You may want to share unless you are one that eats leftovers for days. Don’t expect Italian music playing in the background but you will see plenty Italian people walking in and out ordering to go. That’s when you know it’s good. You can see the food before you order off their fresh hot bar. I ordered the fettuccine Alfredo which was made fresh in the back and to order. My husband had the lasagna and oh my goodness was it a portion to feed a family of 4. It was cheesy, meaty and delicious.
I will be dreaming of this place until I can return and try another dish.
… more
Anthony Mendola
Great food, great portions, and great service. Come here with an appetite. Huge portions, deliscous italian food, Great choices from chicken, pork, veal, fish, sausage, meatballs, vegetables, and or pasta. Friendly service with a smile.
… more
Soonk Paik
I was roaming around the neighborhood (Caroll garden) and this place caught my eyes so I was like why not? This was the best decision I have ever made this week. The food is really great and love the vibe so bad.
Very cozy and comforting atmosphere.

Price is good too.
… more
Neil
The food is delicious and also the walls are covered in beautiful writing
… more
Charlie Adler
Great experience at Vinny’s. Everything we ordered was excellent. And I believe it was even Vinny himself making the rounds to check on customers. It’s easy to see why they’ve been a longstanding business in the neighborhood. Don’t miss this spot next time you’re in Carroll Gardens.
… more
Elizabeth Tavera
This place got recommended from a family friend. And hands down this was the #1 spot to grab my penne al vodka, until all went wrong one day. The order placed over the phone came out completely wrong and it felt like something whipped up on the spot just completely tasteless. I recommend have someone dedicated to taking down orders properly over the phone and if for some reason that doesn’t go well have someone overall with better communication.
I do mot look forward to continue going to this place after this very bad experience, not the 1 star rating worth either.
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact